张平房 2023-06-06

Yes, I received an email today, rejecting the submission and suggesting to resubmit it elsewhere.

ZaZa 2023-06-06

The translation of "henhao" into English is "very good" or "great".

kwi 2023-06-06

Comprehensive quality improvement

bloomying 2023-06-06

Direct UC without external review means rejection. After external review, UC basically means waiting for the execution of the editor's suggestion to transfer or reject.

张平房 2023-06-06

6.4 submitted
6.6 under consideration

bloomying 2023-06-06

Add me as a friend. Yesterday morning, I received an invitation to review four manuscripts. Three of them came back, but in the evening, they were changed to RRC (Reconsider after Revision and Resubmission). This morning, they changed to UC (Under Consideration) again. This editor is quite unreliable, but it's okay because most likely they will reject at least one.

aaas，truth 2023-06-06

To me, I also got rejected after RRC, so I suppose I have been rejected too. I feel sad. I don't know how many rejections there are, still in the UC status.

bloomying 2023-06-06

The editor is Dan Tsang from The Hong Kong Polytechnic University. A search on Zhihu found that this editor has very poor reviews.

bloomying 2023-06-06

And then, my RRC turned into UC, and then three days later it was rejected. There were five reviewers, two major revisions, two minor revisions, and one rejection. It feels like when it becomes UC, it means rejection, right?

bloomying 2023-06-06

Have you experienced the "under consideration" status after your RRC?

bloomying 2023-06-06

I submitted last month. There were five reviewers, and it ended up being under consideration. Three days later, it was rejected. Two major revisions, two minor revisions, and one rejection. The editor rejected it. Now I submitted another one, and yesterday it became under consideration again. I guess there are reviewers who might reject it. It will either be sent to the associate editor or rejected.

HIRAM@YUE 2023-06-06

Record: June 6th: under review.

小僧鸠摩智 2023-06-05

Congratulations, congratulations, Xiao Xiu is definitely fine now.

huangkan 2023-06-05

6.5, minor revision. It seems like the editor finally approves of me.

huangkan 2023-06-05

6.5 - Minor Revision. It seems that the editor still approves of me.

aaas，truth 2023-06-05

Did anyone receive any modifications after being under consideration by the RRC, or were they rejected directly?

HIRAM@YUE 2023-06-05

June 5th, still with the editor, it has been a week already.

小僧鸠摩智 2023-06-04

Chosen Charlotte Poschenrieder

dragonlord 2023-06-04

Which editor did you choose?

小僧鸠摩智 2023-06-04

Submission record
2023.5.25 submitted to journal
2023.5.26 with editor
2023.5.27 under review

wpm 2023-06-03

Is it necessary for all authors to confirm?

wpm 2023-06-03

Do all authors need to confirm?

aaas，truth 2023-06-03

I also became UR after RRC.

aaas，truth 2023-06-03

After RRC, I also changed back to UR.

Tiny98 2023-06-02

06/01/2023 Under Review means that something is currently being examined or evaluated.

aaas，truth 2023-06-02

Added you as a friend, friend.

Riccardia 2023-06-02

2023 05-31 submitted - Submitted on May 31, 2023
2023 05-31 with editor - With editor on May 31, 2023
等待中 - Awaiting

HIRAM@YUE 2023-06-02

It has been four days with the editor, but there is still no news.

pppppppinzz 2023-06-01

How long have you been voting?

哈哈哈1992 2023-06-01

Have you received the results yet?