futianbo 2021-08-08

3.19 submission
3.20 with editor
4.04 under review
5.03 under review
5.29 major revision
6.27 with editor
6.29 with editor
6.30 Under Review
7.19 required reviews completed
8.07 accept

It has not been easy all along the way, with a mixture of anxiety and joy. Fortunately, the outcome is good. The overall progress is currently slow, so everyone should be mentally prepared.

专治不服 2021-08-07

Did you submit it for review?

科研小白 2021-08-06

This situation is basically tragic and has been transferred to the journal office.

zrdb111 2021-08-06

6.30 submit - Submit at 6:30.
7.03 ur - Your (or you're).
8.02 reviews completed - Reviews completed at 8:02.
8.05 Decision in Process - Decision is currently being processed at 8:05.

zrdb111 2021-08-06

May I ask if you have any results now? Mine is also in the same state.

阿hao1 2021-08-06

On August 1st, the Under Review date was updated once, and we are still waiting.

十年后的下午茶 2021-08-06

On my third day of review, I felt it was quite fast. I didn't expect you to be even faster. Do you have the results now? Best wishes~

Geehy 2021-08-05

Have you received any news?

鼬天涯佐 2021-08-05

20210525 submitted to journal - Submitted to the journal on May 25th, 2021.
20210526 with editor - Under the editor's review on May 26th, 2021.
20210608 under review - Under review by the journal on June 8th, 2021.
20210703 major revision - Major revision requested on July 3rd, 2021.
20210725 revised, with editor - Revised version submitted to the editor on July 25th, 2021.
20210726 under review - Under review again by the journal on July 26th, 2021.
20210803 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed on August 3rd, 2021.
20210804 minor revision - Minor revision requested on August 4th, 2021.
20210804 revised, with editor - Revised version submitted to the editor on August 4th, 2021.

念念啊 2021-08-04

Guys, how difficult and fast is this journal? Thank you.

zhangzhang0102 2021-08-04

Excuse me, experts, is there any news? I want to submit a general article recently, but I don't know if the competition is fierce or not.

艾小红 2021-08-04

I hope for good luck, I just sent it out today.

baily 2021-08-03

I have also been waiting for over a week, and it is still "with editor". The status has not changed at all.

努力向前 2021-08-03

Mine too. I have been submitting for a week but it hasn't been reviewed yet. I'm anxious. Have you submitted it now?

Geehy 2021-08-02

The status "under review" has changed 3 times, does it mean that there are 3 reviewers reviewing it?

lebron_keke 2021-08-02

May I ask if you have received any feedback after the review was completed on the 29th?

gaodingshixionglema 2021-08-01

Yes, welcome to communicate.

科研小白 2021-08-01

It has been a month since I submitted, and I still haven't received any response. Is this the platform for submitting and exchanging works?

double好运 2021-07-31

I hope that one day I can also come to share the timeline. (ㄒoㄒ)/~~

paper_怪 2021-07-30

It has been two weeks since my required review was completed.

lebron_keke 2021-07-30

I also voted on the 19th and it is under review on the 29th.

鲸落南北 2021-07-30

20210405: submission
20210406: under review
20210521: major revisions (two reviewers, many minor issues but no major problems)
20210614: submission
20210615: under review
20210701: minor revisions (previous two reviewers had no issues, but a third reviewer emerged and raised three major problems)
20210718: submission (minimal changes to the main text)
20210719: under review
20210730: accept
Overall, the handling by the editor and the speed of the review process were quite fast. The second round had an additional reviewer who raised some major issues, but since we didn't make changes, it was sent back. The following ten days or so were quite stressful, so we decided not to continue arguing. Hopefully, this information is helpful to everyone.

军哥93 2021-07-29

Posted on July 19th, still "with editor" until now. Why is the process so slow?

军哥93 2021-07-29

Number 16 submitter, have you submitted it for review?

lebron_keke 2021-07-29

0729 - under review

lebron_keke 2021-07-28

"Hey, upstairs neighbor. Did you submit the document you mentioned on the 16th for review now?"

zrdb111 2021-07-26

What a disaster, it has been two weeks and I still haven't received the required reviews.

深海鳕鱼子 2021-07-26

Oh my god, I'm screwed. I just complained about how long it took in the morning, and now the Required Reviews are already completed in the evening. Hilarious!

阿hao1 2021-07-26

May 18 submission, reviewed on the same day, below are the date changes:
May 26 Under Review
June 6 Under Review
June 18 Under Review
June 31 Under Review
July 17 Under Review until now
It has been over two months, feeling anxious. Does anyone have a similar situation, buddy?

chenzhili 2021-07-26

Submitted on July 16th, it has been ten days since then and it is still "with editor." The status has not changed at all during this period. Has it become this slow now?