Env_Sci 2023-07-10

Excuse me, how did your final result turn out for completing the review in one day? Is it good or bad? It seems like I encountered a situation where completing it in one day was a disaster.

Env_Sci 2023-07-10

2023-06-30: submit to journal
2023-06-30: with editor
2023-07-01: under review; review invitations sent: 10; review invitations accepted: 1;
2023-07-04: under review; review invitations sent: 10; review invitations accepted: 1;
2023-07-09: under review; review invitations sent: 18; review invitations accepted: 1;
2023-07-10: under review; review invitations sent: 18; review invitations accepted: 3; reviews completed: 1
Today, two reviewers agreed to review and one has completed the review tonight, feeling like a tragedy is about to happen.

芷卉 2023-07-10

Jun 28, 2023 submitted to Journal - This means that on June 28, 2023, a document or article was sent to a journal for consideration or publication.

Jun 28, 2023 with editor - On June 28, 2023, the document or article was received by the editor of the journal.

Jun 29, 2023 Under Review - As of June 29, 2023, the document or article is currently being evaluated or assessed by the journal's reviewers or editorial board.

ysy001 2023-07-09

2023/4/17 Submitted to Journal
2023/4/17 With editor
2023/4/23 Under Review
2023/5/15 Under Review Date Change
2023/6/1 Required Reviews Completed
2023/6/4 Major Revision
2023/6/17 Revisions Submitted to Journal
2023/6/18 Under Review
2023/7/9 Accept

Translation:
2023/4/17 Submitted to Journal
2023/4/17 With editor
2023/4/23 Under Review
2023/5/15 Under Review Date Change
2023/6/1 Required Reviews Completed
2023/6/4 Major Revision
2023/6/17 Revisions Submitted to Journal
2023/6/18 Under Review
2023/7/9 Accept

whoiam 2023-07-09

May I ask you: Where can I check for plagiarism? Thank you!

whoiam 2023-07-09

May I ask you: Where can I check for plagiarism?

HIRAM@YUE 2023-07-09

Excuse me, OP, have you encountered this situation before? 6.30, RCC; 7.1, RCC; 7.3, Under review. It has been under review until today, continuously tracking the review status. Three review comments have already been received for 7.1.

Tiny98 2023-07-08

07/08/2023 resubmitted

Translation: The date 07/08/2023 has been resubmitted.

笨笔丁丁 2023-07-08

Just now, it was rejected after a major renovation was submitted for review.

yllk2011 2023-07-08

20230705 submitted to journal
20230705 with Editor
20230707 Under Review
20230721 Required Reviews Completed
20230723 Under Review
20230726 Required Reviews Completed
20230728 Under Review

Translated:
20230705 submitted to journal
20230705 with Editor
20230707 Under Review
20230721 Required Reviews Completed
20230723 Under Review
20230726 Required Reviews Completed
20230728 Under Review

小僧鸠摩智 2023-07-07

I added you, what happened in the end?

化城小胡椒 2023-07-07

Turn into RRC

cnpk 2023-07-07

The status has changed to "uc" and it is going to be rejected.

kekekeg 2023-07-06

Same question, is there a high possibility of being rejected after sending it for review?

kekekeg 2023-07-06

2023/6/22 with editor (12 days later)
2023/7/4 under review
Waiting for reviewer's comments

小仙女dpt 2023-07-06

Submitted on July 1st, but it has not been reviewed yet.

cnpk 2023-07-05

7.1 submit
7.1 with editor
……

HIRAM@YUE 2023-07-05

4 days, and then it was under review again.

一个蛋 2023-07-05

How long does it take to complete the required reviews?

zhhhui 2023-07-05

Feeling slowed down, if you want to reject, just reject directly. Instead of pushing it to Aisiweier to recommend transferring to another journal, if you have time, you could have already submitted the next one. Very disgusted with this.

pic123 2023-07-04

It has been 15 days with the editor, and it feels like there is a 90% chance of being rejected. If it's going to be rejected, then please do it quickly.

引吭高歌 2023-07-04

6.21 with editor
6.24 under consideration
7.4 rejection

ddzddzddzddz 2023-07-04

Reviewer feedback is helpful in improving the quality of the manuscript, which is a very good choice.

HIRAM@YUE 2023-07-04

Has anyone experienced that after completing the required reviews, the status changes back to "under review"? I am tracking the review status and have already received three review comments.

小章鱼吃柠檬 2023-07-04

Based on everyone's replies, it seems that the possibility of being rejected by the editor for another 10 days in UC is high. However, now UC will also continue for 10 days before finally rejecting, which will waste time.

--ABBA-- 2023-07-04

6.30 submit
6.30 with editor
7.2 under review, two reviewers accepted the review
7.3 one reviewer completed the review
Does completing the review in just one day mean it's a tragedy??? What is the minimum number of reviewers required for the overall review process?

笨笔丁丁 2023-07-04

No need to confirm all.

kekekeg 2023-07-04

May I ask how the host is doing now?

kekekeg 2023-07-04

May I ask how the situation is going for the original poster? How many days have you been with the editor?

kekekeg 2023-07-04

Does the longer the time, the higher the possibility of being rejected?