已投结果未知 2021-09-21

The manuscript has been under review for three months. I send an email once a month, and each reply is "I have received your review comments, thank you for your letter. The editing process depends on the complexity of the article." Other reviewers seem to be faster... I wish you the best in having your paper accepted as soon as possible.

Zhiyuan Liao 2021-09-21

2021.5.13 Submitted
2021.6.15 Major revision
2021.7.25 Submitted after major revision
2021.8.9 Minor revision
2021.8.11 Submitted after minor revision
2021.9.18 Minor revision
2021.9.18 Submitted after minor revision
2021.9.21 Accepted

Leezihao 2021-09-20

Ah, waiting to graduate, I am also worried that if I keep being so critical like you, then it will be disastrous.

fivelei 2021-09-20

2021.4.13 Submission
2021.5.20 Editing pre-review and major revision
2021.5.29 Major revision resubmission
2021.8.25 Minor revision
2021.9.8 Minor revision resubmission
It has been over ten days for the minor revision, and there is still no result.

fivelei 2021-09-20

It has been 12 days since the minor repairs.

AXXZ 2021-09-20

Reply to Leezihao: You have only been reviewing for two months, so relax.

Leezihao 2021-09-19

Oh, mine is the same as yours. It's a very niche field and I've been waiting for almost 2 months for my submission to show any progress. I wonder if the review process will take as long as yours too?

AXXZ 2021-09-18

You said it wrong, it is directly through editing pre-review.

AXXZ 2021-09-18

The review process took six months, which should have achieved the longest review time for this website and journal. This indicates that directly going through external review is not necessarily good news. Preparing the reminder letter...

Leezihao 2021-09-18

Will the status of "Under review" change during the period? For example, the date. I have been "Under review" for a month.

zhizi0504 2021-09-18

2021.3.2 Submission
2021.4.29 Major revision (two reviewers, additional experiments)
2021.6.15 Major revision resubmission
2021.9.17 Accept

buguoruci 2021-09-16

May I ask what files you have returned for the revised submission? I have submitted the reviewer's comments on the PDF and the modified version of the paper in PDF format. Why do they keep getting returned, saying that mine cannot be processed?

cptbtptp2333 2021-09-16

2021.03.25 Submission
2021.04.18 Editing and preliminary review, major revision
2021.05.28 Revised version submitted
2021.07.16 Major revision after first review
2021.09.07 Revised again
2021.09.16 Under review

daidaigun 2021-09-16

Submission Experience:
2021.6.2: Submitted;
2021.7.24: Major revision;
2021.8.4: Revised and resubmitted;
2021.9.16: Accepted.

哦啊 2021-09-14

Hello, I encountered a problem when submitting my article. The issue is that the PDF generated by the system is incorrect. I uploaded the LaTeX version of the paper in the manuscript section and included the PDF version of the paper in the Figure option. The automatically generated PDF is a messy thing. Have you experienced this issue?

陆小哄 2021-09-08

June 18, 2021 Submission
July 6, 2021 First round of major revisions Editor's comments
July 19, 2021 Revised submission after major revisions
August 6, 2021 Second round of major revisions Reviewer's comments
August 12, 2021 Revised submission after major revisions
August 26, 2021 Third round of minor revisions Reviewer's comments
August 29, 2021 Revised submission after minor revisions
September 5, 2021 Acceptance
The journal has a high efficiency, the editor is very rigorous, and the process is very standardized.

seven_gcc 2021-09-05

Does anyone know what's going on? Is the probability of being rejected high?
I'm waiting to postpone my graduation.

seven_gcc 2021-09-05

It has been three months since I submitted it, but there is still no news. I have already sent a reminder once...

FFSnow 2021-09-04

Yes, yesterday it was still with the editor, but this morning it became a major revision...

FFSnow 2021-09-04

Yes, yesterday was still with the editor, and this morning it became a Major Revision.

三脚猫 2021-09-04

I used Turnitin for plagiarism detection before.

三脚猫 2021-09-04

Excuse me, did you go directly from "With the Editor" status to "Major Revision"? Thank you.

FFSnow 2021-09-04

2021/8/17 Submit initial draft
2021/8/18 with the editor
2021/9/4 Major revision
The revision suggestions are making it more burdensome... Does anyone know how to specifically reduce the workload? I'm crying.

huaerkaile 2021-09-03

Hello, may I ask if you submitted minor revisions for the first time on April 6th and received them again on April 11th? During this process, will the edits be sent to the reviewer? (What I mean is, did the status "Under Review" appear?) My revisions are also minor. I submitted them yesterday, saw "with editor" last night, and today the status I see is "Under Review." If they have to be sent back to the reviewer, it will take a long time!

huaerkaile 2021-09-03

Hello, may I ask if after you submit the minor revisions on August 9th, will the editor send it to the reviewer? (What I mean is, will it show the status "Under Review"?) Mine is also a minor revision, I submitted it yesterday, and today I saw the status as "Under Review". If it needs to be sent back to the reviewer, I estimate it will take some time again!

huaerkaile 2021-09-03

Hello, may I ask if after you submit the minor revisions on August 9th, will the editor send it to the reviewer? (What I mean is, will it show the status "Under Review"?) Mine is also a minor revision, I submitted it yesterday, and today I saw the status as "Under Review". If it still needs to be sent back to the reviewer, will one week be enough?

穆头 2021-09-02

Submitted on May 1st, after about two weeks, two experts provided suggestions for major revisions. After a month of making the revisions, feedback for minor revisions was given a week later. After that, the work was accepted. In total, it took two and a half months. I feel that the editor was very responsible and efficient.

jessicazc 2021-09-01

Is proof required before payment? It has been 20 days since I submitted my proof and I haven't received any news.

哈皮果仁 2021-08-29

May I ask if you have any results now? I also returned from major repairs on July 28th.

dabingzi 2021-08-26

Have you finished your proof?