LL 2021-12-18

I also have no news, I missed the time, let's wait slowly.

ddddddddddddd 2021-12-17

Have you received any news? I'm really anxious waiting. I hope I don't have to wait until the Christmas and New Year holidays are over.

srf 2021-12-16

The translation of "编辑是X E. Verykios" into English is "The editor is X E. Verykios."

唐吉诃德 2021-12-16

May I ask who is the editor?

srf 2021-12-16

Update the status, notification for modification on the afternoon of December 15th, modification period of 1 month. It took a total of 20 days from submission to receiving the first review.

ACB 2021-12-15

The translation of the text into English is as follows: "Similarly, I hope that Lao T has gone on vacation and comes back in a happy mood, celebrating with all of us."

srf 2021-12-15

11.24 submitted 11.28 under review 10.9 required reviews completed 12.15 status updated but still required reviews completed. Does anyone know what's going on?

Note: The original text appears to be a mixture of Chinese and English.

LL 2021-12-15

My progress is similar to yours. The manuscript was submitted on 11.13 and is currently under review. The required reviews were completed on 12.3, but there hasn't been any news until today. The editor is TJW, and I am anxiously waiting.

LL 2021-12-15

My progress is similar to yours. The manuscript was submitted on 11.13 and is currently under review. The required reviews were completed on 12.3, but there has been no news until today. The editor is tjw, and I am anxiously waiting.

ACB 2021-12-15

What field are you in? Which editor are you?

ACB 2021-12-15

I filled in the 32 revision forms, and it has been 15 days since the required reviews were completed. There is no news, and I am very worried about finding another reviewer.

Peng 2021-12-15

It has been 20 days since my return for repair, and there is still no result now.

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-12-15

Gianluca Li Puma, although he did not make any modifications, his editing is quite good. The main issue is that one of the reviewers who specializes in photocatalysis intentionally made things difficult, while the other reviewer made minor suggestions that can be accepted.

唐吉诃德 2021-12-14

May I ask who the editor is?

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-12-14

The review process is indeed cooling down. It's now in Transfer Pending status. It's cooling down. Good luck to all of you.

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-12-13

I sent it for review for more than ten days in the first review, and it has now changed to "Decision in Process". It used to take over a month before, causing nervousness.

ACB 2021-12-13

Has the second review opinion come back? It has been a month since my second review, and it has been two weeks since the required reviews were completed. I don't know what the situation is. I'm worried.

ACB 2021-12-13

9.20 submitted - Submitted on September 20th
9.21 with editor - With the editor on September 21st
9.22 under review - Under review since September 22nd
10.20 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed on October 20th
10.27 一审回来，（两个审稿人，不算太难，只有一个问题，不太好回答，解释了一下）- First review returned on October 27th, (two reviewers, not too difficult, only one question that was difficult to answer, explained it)
一审阶段都很快 - The first review stage was fast
11.13返修 with editor - Sent back for revisions with the editor on November 13th
11.23 under review （很慢）- Under review (very slow) since November 23rd
11.30 required reviews completed - Required reviews completed on November 30th
至今无音讯 - No news until now
请问这是什么情况呢？- May I ask what is the situation?
担心编辑会不会再找新的审稿人？- Worried if the editor will find new reviewers again?

LL 2021-12-12

Just asking, what field is the expert working in, and which editor is assigned?

minmin1016 2021-12-11

4.21投稿 - Submitted on April 21st
5.20返回，2修1拒，编辑给大修 - Returned on May 20th, 2 revisions and 1 rejection, editor requests major revisions
6.30修回 1天后直接接收 - Resubmitted on June 30th, accepted directly 1 day later
第二天 online - Online the next day

sunny45690 2021-12-10

You're so fast, good luck~
I'm already done for, 555.

sjrxx 2021-12-09

Why is your submission so fast? Mine has been 15 days and it's still with the editor, I don't know what's going on.

srf 2021-12-09

I am under review on 11.28 and the required review will be completed on 12.8, which is shorter than your time. Currently, there are no results.

albert0909 2021-12-09

11.23 submitted to journal
11.24 with editor
11.25 under review
12.09 required review completed

Why is it so fast? Is it going to be rejected...

sunny45690 2021-12-07

I don't know why I can't reply to private messages, so I can only reply to my own comment. Let's answer everyone collectively~
I think "with editor" means it is in the hands of the editor, and "under review" represents it being reviewed.
The article was submitted for review on November 13th, and today the status was updated to "Required Reviews Completed", but I still can't see the reviewer's comments. I guess the editor is still reviewing it. I hope to receive good results. Praying~

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-12-03

Our progress is about the same. I hope we both have good luck. In the past, it usually takes less than a month to receive review comments for the work.

忘川 2021-12-02

2021.11.28 submitted
2021.11.29 with editor
2021.12.01 under review
Anxiously waiting, praying

每一天 2021-11-30

Has the OP's article been submitted for review?

POSEIDONOK 2021-11-26

How can I know which editor is in the "with editor" status?

王路飞 2021-11-25

14th submitted to journal
16th with editor
17th under review
21st required reviews completed
How could the required reviews be completed so quickly until now?