T大勤奋哥 2023-03-02

2023.01.17 submitted
2023.01.23 with editor
2023.01.25 under review
2023.02.16 required reviews completed
2023.02.27 The editor has not replied to the reviewer's comments yet, and the process has slowed down significantly.
2023.03.01 Today's date has changed, but the status remains the same. Have any of you also experienced a change in the time status today?

tianshi 2023-02-28

Yong Wang is the new editor-in-chief who just joined.

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-27

2023.01.17 submitted
2023.01.23 with editor
2023.01.25 under review
2023.02.16 required reviews completed
2023.02.27 The editor has not responded to the review comments yet, and the progress has slowed down significantly.

Ctrller 2023-02-25

It has been under review for three months.

科研民工112 2023-02-24

2023.2.17 submitted
2023.2.18 with editor
2023.2.20 with editor
The dates have changed but the status hasn't. Does anyone know why? I feel worried.

acs chemistry 2023-02-23

The editorial department has replied, and the editor has been changed to the acceptance given by Yong Wang. This is because both reviewers said it could be accepted. The acceptance letter was delayed for more than 40 days. It's not easy to have my third article published in ACB, one per year. I wish everyone good luck.

冷面男 2023-02-22

Photocatalysis China Editor Li Hexing

acs chemistry 2023-02-22

The article has been urged for submission. The editorial department also replied apologizing for the long delay and mentioned they will assist in contacting the editor in charge of the manuscript. However, the current status remains as "Required Reviews Completed."

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-16

I hope we are all lucky.

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-16

My status is still "required reviews completed", sigh.

luci@ 2023-02-16

Nam is getting older and has too many editorial tasks. I reckon he won't be able to handle them anymore.

acs chemistry 2023-02-16

Still shows "Required Reviews Completed"

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-16

Accepted? Are you still waiting?

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-16

2023.01.17 submitted
2023.01.23 with editor
2023.01.25 under review
2023.02.16 Required Reviews Completed

Translation:

2023.01.17 submitted
2023.01.23 with editor
2023.01.25 under review
2023.02.16 Required Reviews Completed

acs chemistry 2023-02-16

The assigned editor is In-Sik Nam. He gave me two minor revisions before the new year, and I thought I could quickly accept them after making the changes. It turns out they wanted to change the editor-in-chief, and I complained about having to wait so long even after the review was finished. I checked ACB's homepage and couldn't find the name of the editor-in-chief anymore. Why would they change the editor-in-chief when I think In-Sik Nam was doing a great job?

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-15

Surprisingly, the first trial result has not been given yet.

可爱的小函数 2023-02-13

Should we remind or prompt in a situation like this?

冷面男 2023-02-13

Dear colleagues, may I ask about the influence of ACB in the field of catalysis? Is it not as good as JMCA? It must be worse than ACS Catal, right?

hhhhgsj 2023-02-11

Oh no wonder! The manuscript has been under review for two months with no progress. It's all because of this editor from Korea.

liuyi123 2023-02-10

Just like me, if you are assigned to Editor-in-chief Nan Yinzhi, it will be a tragedy. Coincidentally, there is a change in the editor-in-chief during this period, and the situation has been stagnant.

科研废物啊 2023-02-09

May I ask which editor is this?

acs chemistry 2023-02-09

2022.11.09 submitted
2022.11.10 with editor
2022.11.11 under review
2022.12.08 required reviews completed
2022.12.10 revise
2022.12.22 with editor
2022.12.24 under review
2023.01.10 required reviews completed

This status lasted for a month, and there was still no progress. Fortunately, another article in ACS Catalysis was accepted during the Lunar New Year.

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-04

2023.01.17 submitted
2023.01.23 with editor
2023.01.25 under review

Translation:
2023.01.17 submitted
2023.01.23 with editor
2023.01.25 under review

T大勤奋哥 2023-02-04

What is your experience in submitting contributions?

yolo365 2023-02-03

2022.12.28 submitted
2023.01.01 with editor
2023.01.03 under review
2023.01.16 required reviews completed
2023.01.26 required reviews completed
Still in this status currently
2023.02.12 Decision in Process

科研废物啊 2023-02-02

It has been two weeks and there is still no reviewer accepting the manuscript for review.

海大曹县人 2023-01-22

It has been under review for 46 days since submission in August.

lz_prince 2023-01-19

1-16 submit: This means that something needs to be submitted between the dates 1st and 16th.

1-17 with editor: This indicates that on the 17th, something will be reviewed or edited by an editor.

Ctrller 2023-01-05

After resubmitting two weeks later, it has been under review for two months now.

吴小姐4707 2022-12-11

Received a message late at night, quite happy!