敬圣 2021-07-28

May I ask, what is your submission number, OP? I plan to submit to this journal and give it a try. I noticed that the review process is often very lengthy. Is it because of the large number of submissions?

ppsq 2021-07-28

May I ask which editor it is? I have already submitted my contribution for ten days, but it hasn't been reviewed yet.

催化小白 2021-07-27

4.1 Submission
4.2 Rejection due to formatting issues, requesting addition of references and figures in the main text
4.9 Resubmission after modification
4.18 Under review
5.11 Reviewer comments received, three reviewers, one major revision, one minor revision, and one rejection. Editor allows 30 days for revisions.
6.2 Submit R1, response letter with over 8000 words, full of determination to survive~
7.3 Second round of reviewer comments received, two reviewers accept the paper, and one reviewer raises two minor issues. However, this reviewer is very responsible and even helps advocate for the paper. Editor allows 30 days for revisions.
7.13 Submit R2
7.16 Still under review, still waiting.
Overall, the waiting time is a bit long, but the editor and reviewers are very nice. Hoping for a positive outcome, haha~

ppsq 2021-07-26

7.18投 - 7.18 Submission
7.19 with editor
7.26 still with editor

alan@hnu 2021-07-10

May I ask how long it usually takes from submission to acceptance? I submitted on the 6th, and the current status is "with editor."

第九次去北京 2021-07-10

Still very fast, thanks to the Greek editor, who made a lot of experiments, three out of four reviewers were positive, one Korean rejected it, but not completely, and provided many meaningful suggestions, enriching the article. Acceptance within one week after revision.

HLXDLYXZ 2021-07-07

I have also been in the "required review completed" state since June 17th, and it has been maintained until now.

鸡涌 2021-07-06

May I ask how your paper is doing? My status with the editor has not changed as of June 18th, 2021.

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-07-02

Confirmed, but still can't see it. Very strange.

longzu1984 2021-07-02

If you receive an email asking you to confirm information and you click on confirm, you will be able to see it. The system can display the corresponding author and other authors.

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-07-01

How can we check the status of an article on ACB, apart from the corresponding author's account? Does anyone know? (Other authors' email accounts cannot view the status of the article)

科学怪人乀群爷 2021-06-30

Later on, I was hired, and the whole process took about three months, which is considered relatively slow.

hanhan5556 2021-06-29

Hello, did you mention the previous submission number in the cover letter when you resubmitted?

hanhan5556 2021-06-29

Hello, did you mention the previous submission number in the cover letter when resubmitting?

催化小白 2021-06-23

May I ask what happened to your article later? How long after "Required Reviews Completed" did you receive any updates?

中中中中中呀 2021-06-07

It was received on the afternoon of April 29th, and went online on May 1st.

acs chemistry 2021-06-05

2021.3.25 submit
2021.3.26 with editor (Editor-in-Chief In-Sik Nam)
2021.3.27 under review
2021.4.10 comment required completed
2021.4.23 under review
2021.4.26 revise (First review by four reviewers, three minor revisions, one rejection with 17 comments)
2021.5.21 submit
2021.5.22 with editor
2021.5.23 under review
2021.5.29 accept (All three minor revisions were accepted, no comments from the rejecting reviewer were seen)
From submission to acceptance, it took exactly two months, very fast. This is my second article in ACB, and I would like to thank Editor-in-Chief In-Sik Nam and the reviewers. I hope ACB's impact factor will increase to 20 or higher soon. If interested, you can open and read for mutual exchange. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apcatb.2021.120402

karl 2021-05-20

2021.3.4 submit
3.5 Modify the format
3.8 Resubmit
3.9 Under review
4.3 Revision (two minor revisions and one rejection, the second reviewer requested a significant amount of additional experiments and also rejected, the editor provided one month)
4.16 Revise and resubmit
4.20 Revisions being processed
5.9 Accepted

I only know two reviewers, both industry experts in China, and the journal is not very selective. They raised very detailed questions, indicating that the research must have been done meticulously and at a high level. This is my first SCI paper, and it exposed various issues. Thank you to the experts for their careful revisions. Lastly, I would like to thank Editor W. E. Mustain for his trust and I hope ACBE continues to improve.

minmin1016 2021-05-18

Rejected in 3 days?

minmin1016 2021-05-18

How do I view editors and reviewers? It has been 5 days since I submitted my manuscript, but there has been no response. I am anxiously waiting.

minmin1016 2021-05-18

How are you doing now?

monicaylqq 2021-05-15

To update you, I found out today that my submission was rejected. It took 25 days for the review process to complete, and it has been 3 days since it was reviewed. I haven't seen the reason for the rejection yet. I hope to learn from this experience and make improvements. I will submit it elsewhere.

中中中中中呀 2021-04-29

2.3 Submission;
2.4 Editing for formatting changes;
2.15 Resubmission (during the Spring Festival);
2.16 Under review;
3.12 Revision (should be minor changes, the reviewer's questions are not too difficult);
3.23 Revisions (10 days for revisions);
3.26 Under review (to be sent for a second review in 3 days);
4.12 Required Reviews Completed;
Today, on 4.29, there is still no news. The "Reviews Completed" status has been ongoing for 17 days. I don't know what the final result will be, and I anxiously check every day.

acs chemistry 2021-04-21

If the ordinary reviewers do not respond within a month, will the editor send an email to remind them? Our teacher received a letter from the editor urging for the review comments when it was almost a month.

勋范 2021-04-20

It has been two months since submission, and it has always been "with editor". I want to know if it is not showing as "under review" now, or if it really hasn't been sent for review.

carrier徐小幺 2021-04-20

4.3 Submission
4.5 with editor
4.20 with editor, may I ask how did it go for you in the end?

carrier徐小幺 2021-04-20

4.3 Submission
4.5 with editor
4.20 with editor, how is yours?

许文强 2021-04-19

3.6 Submission
3.9 With editor
3.13 Under review
4.19 During the under review period, the status remained unchanged, but the date changed several times.

monicaylqq 2021-04-19

4.12 Submitted
4.13 with editor
4.19 Under review
Will continue to update. Good luck.

林结衣 2021-04-07

20210209-Submission
20210216-Under review
20210317-Three reviewers, two minor revisions, one reviewer did not provide feedback. The editor gives one month to make modifications.
20210404-Revision
20210407-Accepted
We would like to thank Professor Xenophon Verykios from the University of Patras, Greece for recognizing our work. We also appreciate the comments and suggestions from the three anonymous reviewers. This is the first SCI paper during my master's degree, a good start indeed.