njfulxy 2022-02-24

It has been one month with the editor already.

努力科研 2022-02-17

The processing speed of the journal is quite fast, but the external review is relatively slow. After two major revisions and one minor revision, it is accepted.

JWC 2022-02-11

Posted on June 15, 2021
Received review comments on January 8, 2022
Revised on January 14, 2022
Accepted on February 2, 2022
The review period depends on luck, and I noticed that the review status changed many times. I have been patiently waiting. I sent a reminder in December 2021 and received the review comments in January.

少年锦时 2022-02-07

May I ask how your submission is doing now?

朽木 2022-01-30

Already submitted and accepted after major and minor revisions.

ding_yr 2022-01-23

Mine too, waiting to switch journals.

良月不语 2022-01-02

The speed is a bit slow, and the status has been under review all the time, but the previous time has already been changed three times.

appleman 2021-12-20

I have five reviewers, and I gave them one month for major revisions.

徐磊 2021-12-19

Have you got the result?

天晴色 2021-12-17

Mine is the same, just after I submitted it, it went into "decision in process", it has been several days already. How about yours later?

appleman 2021-12-14

May I ask how long does the "Decision in Process" usually last? It has been 3 days and it's a bit agonizing =.=

苏越123 2021-12-02

Blessings. It was submitted on August 2nd and is still under review until now. I hope everything goes smoothly.

朽木 2021-12-02

On September 20th, I submitted it. On December 1st, the decision is in process. I hope to be given an opportunity for modification.

haobt 2021-12-02

I want to ask everyone, when submitting an article, how long does it usually take for the editor to review it before sending it for approval?

Xue 2021-11-26

I would like to know that I recently submitted an application a week ago and the status is already "decision in process". Does this mean there is a high probability of rejection?

luckydog_cwj 2021-11-25

May I ask which editor it is?

wswdly445 2021-11-22

Hiring process is really slow. It took a long time to receive feedback on my minor revisions, and the second review was delayed for over a month. It's exhausting for my mind. Fortunately, the outcome is still acceptable. Be cautious when in a hurry to apply.

wswdly445 2021-11-21

Hello, may I ask if you have any results yet? Mine has been in the same state for two weeks, and still no results...

SLRAN 2021-11-20

May I ask how often do you assign article numbers, with the editor?

SLRAN 2021-11-20

May I ask how long have you been with the editor?

乔小乔 2021-11-18

11.16 Required Reviews Completed
The reviewers' speed of reviewing is acceptable, looking forward to a good outcome.

SLRAN 2021-11-18

May I ask how long did it take for you to review the manuscript in the first round?

appleman 2021-11-14

Thank you very much! I hope mine can also be reviewed quickly. Congratulations on having your article accepted!

appleman 2021-11-14

Hello, may I ask how many reviewers do you have in total?

yixizuotian 2021-11-13

I am quite lucky, the editing process is quite fast.
9.3 submit
9.10 under review
9.26 required reviews completed
10.05 decision in process
10.06 major revise
10.24 r1 submit
10.26 r1 under review
11.03 minor revise
11.05 r2 submit
11.13 accept

kust1 2021-11-11

The review process is slow, and it takes about 10 days for the editing to be completed.

kust1 2021-11-11

First trial, second trial, third trial, a total of five months to receive.

wswdly445 2021-11-10

10.1 First-instance minor repairs, but there have been no results since returning until now... I'm so anxious... Hoping for good luck...

雕大吃四方 2021-10-30

2021.5.11 submitted to journal
2021.8.24 major revisions
2021.10.30 accept
The overall processing speed of the RE manuscript is indeed slow, but luckily, with the help of a supportive editor, it was successfully accepted.

乔小乔 2021-10-23

4.30 submitted 8.7 under review 9.6 major revision after first review 10.4 revised Currently still with editor. This journal is unbelievably slow, the time spent in the editor's hands is much longer than the review process.