Vincent_mfy 2022-09-03

May I ask if it is necessary to resend the revised draft to the person who previously reviewed it after submission? What is the reason for the delay in receiving any updates on the track submission?

Vincent_mfy 2022-09-01

"May I ask if the revised manuscript has been sent to the three reviewers for a second round of review after you received it?"

乱世巨星 2022-08-31

5.13 Submission
5.14 with editor
5.15 under review
Waited for almost a month before someone agreed to review.
6. Late in the month, one review feedback is received.
At the same time, another expert agrees to review.
7. Late in the month, after a month of waiting, the review is still delayed.
Editor sends another invitation.
The third expert is more efficient and quickly accepts and submits.
8. Early in the month, major revisions
Two weeks of modifications, submitted on 8.25, under review at night.
Review process ends on 8.30.
Accepted on 8.31.

Wilson411424 2022-08-24

It took nearly 4 months, finally received.
Submitted on August 11th, with editor on the 12th, finally under review on the 24th.
Major revision on October 28th, one month for extensive revision.
Submitted the revised version on October 23rd, with editor.
Under review on October 25th.
Required Reviews Completed on December 5th.
Accepted on December 7th.

和论文谈一场恋爱 2022-08-22

5.22-投稿 translates to "5.22-Submission"
5.27-under review translates to "5.27-Under review"
6-19-major revise translates to "6-19-Major revision"
7-20-submite translates to "7-20-Submit"
8-18-accept translates to "8-18-Accept"

Wilson411424 2022-08-17

I have also submitted for a week, but I am still "with editor". I see that some people are quite fast. Is it possible that some editors are being slow and making me anxious?

科研不苟 2022-08-15

7.14 Submission
8.14 Review Completed
Hoping for a good outcome

乱世巨星 2022-08-12

It has been three months, and finally, the major has arrived. It was delayed for over a month by one reviewer, but the editor found a third expert reviewer. Both of these reviewers were quite efficient, and it was completed within two weeks. Hopefully, everything goes smoothly!

阿隆 2022-08-07

The text is already in English. It states the following:

Received on April 27, 2022;
Received in revised form on July 4, 2022;
Accepted on July 27, 2022;
Available online on July 29, 2022.

乱世巨星 2022-08-03

Ah, it's been three months and one of the reviewers has been delaying giving a result. The editor just invited a third reviewer, but it would have been fine to reject them too. This way, we can't bear the delay.

盒马 2022-07-23

The second reviewer agreed, but didn't finish it all along, delaying it for a month. The rest of the processing speed is still quite fast.
July 7: Review ended, major revisions.
July 15: Uploaded revised manuscript, under review on the same day.
July 19: Completed.
July 22: Accepted.

科研不苟 2022-07-23

My week is under review, the results are currently unknown.

十三AGE 2022-07-15

Is there an update now? It has been over twenty days for me.

Vincent_mfy 2022-07-12

I have been submitting for ten days and have been continuously with the editor. Do you know why? The initial review is too slow!

和论文谈一场恋爱 2022-07-09

Excuse me, has the original poster requested editing and proofreading?

hy666 2022-07-09

Does the owner of the post have any skills? It's too fast! Take a deep breath for good luck~

小damn 2022-07-08

Special thanks to Editor Quan for the support of the article; Reviewers: 2; Direction: Electrochemical wastewater deep treatment and resource utilization.

Here is a recent submission experience for this journal:

May 11, 2022
Submitted to Journal;

May 11, 2022
With Editor;

May 16, 2022
With Editor;

May 16, 2022
Under Review;

May 17, 2022
Under Review;

May 22, 2022
Under Review;

Jun 09, 2022
Required Reviews Completed;

Jun 13, 2022
Major Revision;

Jul 05, 2022
With Editor;

Jul 05, 2022
Accept

爱祖国 2022-06-19

Excuse me, OP, did you submit something related to the direction of civil engineering safety risk assessment? Did you submit a special issue or a regular module?

唐吉诃德 2022-05-21

5.6 Submission, 5.17 Review

Until today, only one reviewer has accepted the review. Invitations have been sent to 2+ others.

It seems like finding reviewers for this journal is not easy.

盒马 2022-05-20

I will send a link to the communication. Opening it will be "Track your submission," where you can track the progress of your article.

乱世巨星 2022-05-20

May I ask where can I find the information regarding the approval of the manuscript from this reviewer?

左耳钉 2022-05-18

Can the original poster's article be found in Web of Science? My article has been published since February, but it still cannot be retrieved. I can only find it on the official website of the journal. Why is this?

seven632 2022-05-17

What is the status displayed when the editor returns for modification after submission?

盒马 2022-05-17

4.20 submission
4.25 under review
5.2 Review invitation accepted: 1
5.14 Review invitations accepted: 2

Currently, it is unknown how many reviewers are needed and how long it usually takes for reviewers to complete their reviews. Can anyone who has submitted before share their experience with me?
I hope there will be good news and progress can be made quickly.

盒马 2022-05-16

How many reviewers are there for your article? In the "Track your submission" section, how long does the review process take after the reviewers have agreed to review it? Thank you.

Nian1997 2022-05-16

Excuse me, which editor is it?

Nian1997 2022-05-16

Just wanted to ask, which editor are you?

jiaotongxi 2022-04-26

2022.04.05 Second major revision, but there were only a few suggestions, only 8 in total.
Submitted the modifications on 2022.04.25.
Accepted on 2022.04.26.
Graduation is now possible!

盒马 2022-04-26

May I ask how long does it take for "with editor" to become "under review"?

阿隆 2022-04-26

Received 25 October 2021 - This means that the text was received on October 25, 2021.

Major revise 8 December 2021 - This indicates that a major revision was made on December 8, 2021.

Received in revised form 17 February 2022 - This means that the revised version of the text was received on February 17, 2022.

Accepted 12 March 2022 - This indicates that the text was accepted on March 12, 2022.

Available online 16 March 2022 - This means that the text became accessible online on March 16, 2022.