frgjfrghfsgh 2022-01-07

This journal is too slow and very irresponsible. After submitting, it took two months for it to be under review, and the timeline changed once during that period. After another two months, they sent me an email saying they haven't received any review comments and that my article doesn't align with the journal's theme??? What were they doing all this time? It's such a delay!

花落zhi多少 2022-01-04

My September submission has been under external review for two months, and I still haven't received any updates.

密码123456789a 2022-01-04

October 28, 21 Submission
December 2, 21 Minor revision
December 14, 21 Rework
January 4, 22 Acceptance
Thanks to Yu for editing and the two reviewers. I wish PT all the best!

15532018286@163.com 2022-01-04

2021.11.08 submit to journal
2021.11.09 with editor
2021.11.28 under review
2021.12.20 required review completed
2021.12.21 minor revision (two reviewers, one minor revision and one acceptance)
2021.12.28 submit revision (actually revised on 12.22, held by the corresponding author for a week)
2021.12.29 with editor
2021.12.30 required review completed
2022.01.03 accept

婕妮 2021-12-16

Received 27 July 2021
Received in revised form 20 October 2021
Accepted 21 October 2021
Available online 29 October 2021

Reviewed for a month, major revisions were required. I procrastinated for nearly two months before making the revisions, and it was accepted the day after resubmission. The whole process took a total of 3 months. The editorial handling was very fast.

Wishing you all the best!

majorwen 2021-12-13

The text has been translated into English as follows:

Received on June 20, 2021.
Revised on September 28, 2021.
Accepted on December 1, 2021.

ChenHL 2021-12-07

9.4 Submitted to journal
9.7 With editor
10.11 Major revision
11.16 Returned for revision
11.17 Revised manuscript submitted after modifying figures
11.18 Under review
12.7 Required review completed
12.7 Accepted
First SCI top journal. It took 3 months for acceptance, which is nice! Thanks to the recognition of Editor Yu and the reviewers! Wishing Powder Technology to become even better!

wh 2021-12-06

Where can I find a thesis template, please?

15532018286@163.com 2021-12-04

That's quite lucky, the whole cycle should be about five months.

susuyy 2021-12-04

After a month and a half of minor repairs, it was finally accepted. Although it took a long time, the result was good.

TGCG 2021-11-30

May I ask how many days after acceptance will it be online?

我不是研究生 2021-11-28

7 months is okay, I'm 8 months, haha.

科研界小学生 2021-11-26

07.04.21 Submission
28.04.21 Rejection, requires revision
04.05.21 Resubmission after revision
04.05.21 Submission
06.05.21 Under review with editor
16/17/22.05.21 Under review
03.08.21 Major revision (deadline 17.09.2021)
19.08.21 Revised submission with editor
21.08.21 Under review with editor
28.08.21 Under review
31.08.21 Required reviews completed
18.09.21 Minor revision (deadline 02.11.2021)
20.09.21 Revised submission with editor
21.09.21 Under review with editor
24.10.21 Under review
24.10.21 Required reviews completed
22.11.21 Accepted
25.11.21 Online
Speed, quality!

wan929127717 2021-11-22

After 10 days, under review with editor.

J@L 2021-11-18

October 18, 2021 with edit
November 18, 2021 still with edit

15532018286@163.com 2021-11-18

Has it been submitted for review now?

默存* 2021-11-12

Posted on October 22nd, still being edited on November 12th, is this status considered normal?

dalingzi 2021-11-10

It is October 27th.

dalingzi 2021-11-10

Posted on 11.27, it is still with the editor now, which is very convenient.

虎式微笑 2021-11-05

2021.10.15 Submitted to Journal
2021.10.18 Revised highlights- Submitted to Journal
2021.10.19 with editor
2021.11.01 Urged for submission
2021.11.02 Reject
They urged me to submit it and then told me that the subject matter does not meet the journal's requirements. They suggested submitting to another journal. If they didn't urge me, they could have kept dragging it on. The speed is truly slow.

nx 2021-10-31

Is it normal for my with editor to take one month?

AM123 2021-10-29

Brother, do you have the process of "under review"? I have been waiting for 15 days now and it is still "with editor".

15532018286@163.com 2021-10-26

I would like to ask whether classmates' submissions are in the DOC or DOCX format and whether they used the built-in equation editor in Word for the formulas.

15532018286@163.com 2021-10-26

I want to ask whether the submission upstairs is in manuscript format, or in a doc file or a docx file. Did you use the built-in formula editor in Word for the formulas?

AM123 2021-10-26

Brother, how many reviewers do you have?

wan929127717 2021-10-22

2021.07.06 Submission
2021.07.19 Review
2021.08.11 Major repair
2021.09.24 Rework
2021.10.07 Major repair
2021.10.13 Rework
2021.10.18 Acceptance

Barntee 2021-10-22

I returned for repair on September 22nd. Today is already October 22nd and I have been with the editor all this time.

Barntee 2021-10-22

After receiving feedback, make the necessary revisions and submit it. It has been a month with the editor, how should we proceed?

15532018286@163.com 2021-10-19

August 10, 2021 Post
August 10, 2021 Paper format issue, revised and submitted
August 11, 2021 Modification submitted
October 4, 2021 Received review comments (one direct acceptance, two minor revisions)
October 7, 2021 Revised manuscript
October 18, 2021 Accepted
Overall, it went smoothly. Thanks to Academician Fan Liangshi, the editor-in-chief.

学习666666 2021-10-16

The speed is really slow...