DM 2022-11-25

Hello, hello! It has been two months since I submitted my work, and it has been "with editor" ever since. There was one update in the middle regarding the timeline, but it still hasn't moved to "under review." Should I send an email to inquire about the status? I'm thinking of giving a gentle reminder, as waiting for two months without any progress feels like a waste, especially since it hasn't been sent for review yet.

yunbin 2022-11-25

The submission was made during the second year of research, and it has already been accepted in the first year of the PhD program. The whole process took more than 26 months, which is very disheartening. In short, if anyone is submitting to this journal and hasn't received a response for a long time, it is suggested to send reminders every month, as there is no better solution. For those who need to graduate, it is not recommended to submit to this journal. Finally, I wish all the anxious waiting friends good luck in getting accepted!

yunbin 2022-11-25

Posted on September 16, 2020, it took about 2 months with the editor, and then it was under review. This process continued until January 2022, with the under review time constantly changing. Around June 2021, they started reminding once a month. I didn't know who the AE (Associate Editor) was, so I could only contact the email in the system. The responses I received were similar, saying they were working on it urgently.

After continuing until January 2022, I received the reviewer's comments for major revisions. I completed the revisions on March 3, 2022, and it remained with the editor until September 28. I kept reminding during this time. After about forty days, it was still under review. On November 11, 2022, I sent an email inquiring about the status, and the reply stated that the reviewer's comments had been collected ten days ago and they had urged the AE to make a decision. The day after I sent the email, on November 12, 2022, it was stated that the decision was in process, and the result was announced on the same day, requiring minor revisions. I completed the revisions on November 14, 2022, and it was accepted on November 24, 2022.

METAVERSE 2022-11-04

April 7, 2022 - Submitted to the Journal;
April 8, 2022 - With Editor;
April 9, 2022 - With Editor;
May 31, 2022 - Under Review;
August 12, 2022 - Under Review;
September 8, 2022 - Under Review;
October 28, 2022 - Under Review;
October 29, 2022 - Decision in Process;
November 4, 2022 - Reject.

METAVERSE 2022-11-02

Normal, it is expected that this process will not exceed three months and will remain normal.

DM 2022-11-01

Posted on September 27th, reviewed by the editor on September 29th, is it normal to have no update on the submission status until now?

METAVERSE 2022-10-31

Why do I have no required reviewers completed and go directly from under review to decision in process after 6 months of peer review?

METAVERSE 2022-10-31

2021.09.25 sub (Submitted)
2021.11.16 ur (Under review)
2022.01.01 ur (Under review)
2022.01.16 ur (Under review)
2022.01.24 rrc (Reviews requested from reviewers)
2022.01.28 rrc (Reviews requested from reviewers)
2022.02.16 decision in process
2022.02.19 decision in process
2022.02.20 major revision
2022.04.22 revision submit
2022.04.26 ur (Under review)
2022.05.04 rrc (Reviews requested from reviewers)
2022.05.10 rrc (Reviews requested from reviewers)
2022.05.10 decision in process
2022.06.30 revision submit
2022.07.02 ur (Under review)
2022.07.09 rrc (Reviews requested from reviewers)
2022.07.12 rrc (Reviews requested from reviewers)
2022.07.13 decision in process
2022.07.17 minor revision
2022.07.31 revision submit
2022.08.07 accept

浪里小花猫 2022-10-29

I have also encountered something similar. Most likely, it is because during the first round of review, one reviewer directly gave minor revisions, which is considered "suspicious" for the editor. Therefore, it is necessary to add more reviewers to avoid such "suspicion".

哈哈哈哈嘿 2022-10-29

Jan 12 Submission
Jul 19 First review major; two reviewers, one major and one minor
Aug 10 Revised submission
Oct 19 Required reviews completed
Oct 28 Under review
Asked customer service and they said two additional reviewers were added. Can someone please explain if there is a difference in opinions? Is arbitration needed?

lgxt 2022-10-25

Can the journal accept submissions on the topic of speech recognition?

hnqin 2022-10-24

Two years... two years... Do you know how I have been living these two years? Do you know?

浪里小花猫 2022-10-20

The PR journal is a good journal with high recognition in the industry.

March 24, 2022: Submitted for review;
June 26, 2022: Major revisions;
July 12, 2022: Returned for revisions;
September 4, 2022: Accepted for publication.

Zyric 2022-10-11

I submitted it in August last year. It took two months for the first trial to be delivered. The first trial took more than half a year, and it took three months for the second trial to be delivered. It has been another two months, and the total time so far is 14 and a half months.

阿克苏 2022-10-05

Same situation, I asked in the middle and was told that they have been continuously searching for reviewers. If they still can't find an expert reviewer, will the editor reject the submission? The editor has been searching but it seems like no one has reviewed it yet. Can they withdraw the submission or should they just wait?

二狗蛋 2022-10-02

I have been waiting for 9 months, while you are still nowhere near. Don't worry, just wait slowly.

明楼饮浊酒 2022-09-23

The pricing is determined based on the word count, it seems that less than 8000 words cost $410, and around 10,000 words cost $470.

公鸡不下饭 2022-09-22

I was mentally prepared for the submission cycle of PR, but it has been four months and it still hasn't been reviewed. This is truly beyond expectations, and I am anxiously seeking graduation!

阿克苏 2022-09-09

2022.1.28 Submitted
2022.6.25 under review
2022.9.4 under review
Submitted in August, either unable to find reviewers or reviewers refused to review, there is no hope left.

凌蓝落 2022-08-22

2021.10.7 Submission
2022.2.24 Major Renovation
2022.3.23 R1 Submission
2022.6.2 Major Renovation
2022.6.13 R2 Submission
2022.7.26 Accept

Cosmic Machine 2022-08-16

What is the cost for proofreading?

machao199271 2022-08-07

After submitting on May 9, I received an email notification saying that there were a lot of manuscripts in the journal, and they requested to be reminded after three months. Then, I kept in touch with the editor without the manuscript being sent for review, and I didn't dare to urge them either. On August 2, within the tight three-month period, the editor directly rejected the submission and suggested transferring it elsewhere. I had previously experienced a prolonged peer review process, lasting over a year. This time, the editor was very irresponsible, and I won't submit to this journal again in the future.

zzh1995 2022-07-17

2022.6.30 revision submit - The revision was submitted on June 30, 2022.
2022.7.2 under review - It is currently under review as of July 2, 2022.
2022.7.9 required reviewers completed - The required reviewers have finished their evaluation on July 9, 2022.
2022.7.12 required reviewers completed - The required reviewers have finished their evaluation on July 12, 2022.
2022.7.13 decision in process - The decision is currently being processed as of July 13, 2022.
2022.7.17 minor revision - A minor revision is required on July 17, 2022.
2022.7.31 revision submit - The revision was submitted on July 31, 2022.
2022.8.7 Completed - Accept - It was completed and accepted on August 7, 2022.

The Answer 2022-07-17

Sep 06, 2021: Init Submit - Initial submission
Sep 27, 2021: Completed - Reject - Completed, but rejected
Sep 29, 2021: Resubmit - Resubmission
Jan 13, 2022: Major Revision - Major revision required
Feb 28, 2022: Submit Revision - Revision submitted
May 07, 2022: Minor Revision - Minor revision required
May 07, 2022: Submit Revision - Revision submitted
Jun 19, 2022: Required Reviews Completed - Required reviews completed
Jul 09, 2022: Decision in Process - Decision being processed
Jul 16, 2022: Completed - Accept - Completed and accepted

jack21 2022-07-08

Wow, 3 days went by so quickly! I need to remind them, it's been almost a month since the decision was made...

xxyh 2022-07-08

The decision has been in process for 3 days.

jack21 2022-07-06

Also, recommending to switch to this kind of operation, are there any at the same level?... Brother, how long did the "Decision in Process" status last? Share it.

xxyh 2022-07-06

2022.6.30 Transfer Pending

PR experience is almost zero. After waiting for 13 months, I finally received a recommended transfer!

jack21 2022-06-26

Previously, the review process for PR submissions took a long time, but the decision was relatively quick. Now, the speed of PR review is acceptable, but why does the decision always take at least 10 days? It has been 10 days since the third review decision, and I hope the editors can provide a result while enjoying their afternoon tea...

哈哈哈哈嘿 2022-06-20

2021.11.07 Submit
2022.02.08 Two reviewers, 8 comments, seems like they are major, deadline for revisions is two months
2022.03.14 Submit revised draft
2022.04.19 Required reviews completed
2022.06.20 Two reviewers, 3 comments, still major, quite strange, it seems like it can be fixed in just 2 days, deadline for revisions is two weeks.