尹弼君 2022-07-07

First trial from May to July 2021.
Second trial from August 2021 to June 2022.
Then the minor revision was also rejected without any substantial comments.
Finally, they mentioned a lack of innovation.
However, why did they start saying it was insufficient?
Basically, the process takes 13 months, so those who want to graduate quickly should carefully consider this.

luckyupupup! 2022-07-04

Excuse me, does your manuscript number have a "d" in the middle?

luckyupupup! 2022-07-04

May I ask how long you have been with the Editor?

lsjlxc 2022-07-01

I advise you not to submit to this journal. It is too slow, taking 5 months to respond with a rejection letter. There were 5 reviewers, which is quite frustrating.

luckyupupup! 2022-07-01

It has been almost a month since I became an editor, but there hasn't been any news. I am feeling anxious.

小宋ssss 2022-06-30

1 day with editor
14 days under review
Hope the review process can be faster.

richen_lp 2022-06-27

In English, the text "吸一吸你的好运" translates to "Take a breath of your good luck."

JiangBin 2022-06-27

5.8 with editor
5.9 under review
5.24 major revision
6.10 under review
6.26 accept
During the first and second rounds of review, it went from under review to required review completed and then back to under review. It's a bit chaotic.
Overall, the process has been quite fast. Thank you to the editor and reviewers.

DLDL 2022-06-20

Sincerely advise those who are eager to graduate not to submit to this journal, as the speed is too slow and really delays people.

墨墨如君 2022-06-16

I also have a D, it has been 6 months already, I have reminded them twice, still waiting.

DLDL 2022-06-16

It's been almost a month. Is the editor not going to work? Has he/she been not doing any work?

csjwsc 2022-06-13

Are you guys biased towards visuals? I also have a D in the middle of my number, does that mean it takes two months to get a D??

Chongkyi 2022-06-10

Overall it's okay, the entire process took 2 months and 5 days. It was submitted at the beginning of April, and it took only 5 days for external review. The feedback was received at the end of the month. There were two reviewers, and I spent more than ten days revising based on their comments. The second review took another 20 days. The speed of the reviewers varied, some returned their feedback within a few days, while others were slower.

bajini 2022-06-09

Submitted on March 25th, returned for major revisions on April 25th, with two reviewers. Submitted again on May 22nd, received by the editor the next day, and sent for review a few days later. External review completed within 5 days. Accepted notification received in just three days! It went quite smoothly!

dukaix 2022-06-05

Very slow. After submitting the manuscript, it has been two months and it has not been reviewed. From submission to publication, it takes about a year as a unit of measurement.

论文要中 2022-06-02

required reviews completed. Two weeks later, Decision in Process. How long does it usually take for this status? It has been almost 10 days already...

尹弼君 2022-06-01

I'm really fed up with this guy, Lao Liu.
It has been 10 months since the second review.
It has been 12 months from submission till now.
There is only one chance in life to submit to this.
I suggest graduating students who need a thesis to completely blacklist this journal.

chrisjia 2022-05-28

Excuse me, may I ask whether after my notice of major revisions, I was asked to resubmit and given a deadline for modifications? Is it the same for you? Did you submit the manuscript using the teacher's account? I am unable to see the manuscript under review on my account anymore.

chrisjia 2022-05-28

May I ask, after my notification of major revisions, I was asked to resubmit with a deadline for modifications. Is it the same for you? Did you submit the revised manuscript using the teacher's account? I can no longer see the manuscript under review when I log in with my own account.

luckyupupup! 2022-05-27

Excuse me, is there a 'd' in the middle of your manuscript ID?

luckyupupup! 2022-05-27

Is this journal very slow?

Lingbin 2022-05-25

If it takes two months to be reviewed with the editor, the speed of this editor is really slow, but as long as it can be reviewed, I am also satisfied...

chrisjia 2022-05-24

There is also a "D" in the middle of mine, does this represent different editors?

chrisjia 2022-05-24

After two months with the editor, it was finally submitted for review at the end of April, and now it is in the reviewing process.

Lingbin 2022-05-20

Comrades, it has been two months for me too. Have we encountered the same editor? Do your article numbers have a "D" in the middle?

倔强的奥斯特 2022-05-19

Big brother, I have changed editors twice. What happened to you later?

zrrrleo 2022-05-08

Laser processing direction, previously submitted to the group and accepted after 3 months. This time went unexpectedly smoothly.

2022.3.24 submitted
2022.4.15 required reviewers completed
2022.4.25 major revision (1 reviewer)
2022.4.29 R1 submitted
2022.5.4 major revision
2022.5.4 R2 submitted
2022.5.5 accept

Thanks to Associate Editor Dr. Sentis.

sys8866 2022-04-29

Already hired, providing a timeline for reference, undergoing two major revisions with a duration of 6 months.

2021.10.4: Submitted
2021.10.5: With editor
2021.10.6: Under review
2021.11.20: Major revision
2022.1.12: Revision submitted to journal
2022.1.13: Under review
2022.2.2: Required reviews completed
2022.2.7: Required reviews completed
2022.2.13: Major revision
2022.3.2: Revision submitted to journal
2022.3.4: Under review
2022.4.6: Under review
2022.4.23: Required reviews completed
2022.4.25: Accepted

zjx-886 2022-04-26

Translation: The date for review has been changed and the reviewer has been changed. I have changed the date four times, approximately once a month, and there is still no result up until now.

chrisjia 2022-04-25

I submitted it at the beginning of March and have been with the editor for almost two months. During this period, the date with the editor changed once, and I don't know what happened!!?? Has anyone else encountered the same situation as me? What does it mean to be constantly not sent for review, staying with the editor for almost two months?