恭喜发财Zz 2023-06-05

Now it's been in this state without any changes.

Jonas_H 2023-06-03

May 31, 2023 Under Review

zachary58 2023-06-01

Almost the same as you, now the processing speed is very slow!

新潟县 2023-06-01

5.12.2023 submitted to journal
5.16.2023 with editor
It has been over half a month and it is still in the hands of the editor. I have sent emails inquiring about it but have not received any response. Does anyone have any advice or suggestions?

Jonas_H 2023-06-01

Until now, it is still in the hands of the editor, and further follow-up is ongoing.

fk editor 2023-05-30

MAR 13, 2023 submitted to journal
MAY 19, 2023 with editor
MAY 30, 2023 with editor

The submission has been with the editor for two and a half months, and the "with editor" status is a little shocking.

zachary58 2023-05-29

May 17, 2023 Submitted to Journal
May 18, 2023 With Editor
May 24, 2023 With Editor
Date changed, status unchanged, still not reviewed yet, the speed is a bit slow!

七陌 2023-05-18

May 17, 2023 Renovation

别卷 2023-05-18

April 26, 2023 with editor
May 17, 2023 with editor
The dates have changed multiple times, but it's still with the editor!!!

我要毕业啊 2023-05-16

Did you submit it for review?

临时演员 2023-05-16

4.26 Received notice of major repair!
5.16 Return for rework delivery!

临时演员 2023-05-16

Received notice for major repairs on April 26th.
Return for rework delivery on May 16th.

吴女士 2023-05-15

The translation of "我的两个多月送的" into English is "What I've been doing for over two months."

吴女士 2023-05-15

Hahaha, it's really slow.

吴女士 2023-05-15

Submitted in October 2022, received a response from an expert in February 2023, replied to the second expert's opinion in April 2023, and chose to revise and resubmit. Finally, accepted on May 11, 2023. It took approximately 7 months from submission to acceptance, which is really a long time.

cyx1602 2023-05-12

Did it get sent for review later?

别卷 2023-05-11

I have been waiting for over two months since I submitted on March 3rd, and I am still with the editor.

cyx1602 2023-05-09

4.19 Submission
4.20 with editor
Still with editor until now

mhhmhh 2023-05-09

2023.4.17 Submission, with editor
2023.4.21 Status remains unchanged, but the date has changed
It has been over twenty days now with no progress, still not being sent for review.

七陌 2023-05-09

Worry about graduating soon, be cautious when submitting manuscripts. It has been 6 months since submission, but no feedback has been received from the first review.

cyx1602 2023-05-08

I have been more than half a month already.

chenyuxin997 2023-04-28

As long as the editor does not reject my submission, I will be content.

chenyuxin997 2023-04-28

4.19 submission
4.20 with editor

正义的小笼包 2023-04-26

Submitted on December 1, 2022, accepted on April 26, 2023, totaling almost 5 months.
Among them, the review and revision process took less than a month, very smoothly. However, the combination of "With Editor" and "Required Reviews Completed" took nearly four months... the editorial handling was too slow.

yorelll 2023-04-24

Approximately one or two months.

guang2018 2023-04-23

It has been over a month and it has not been submitted for review yet. How long does it usually take to submit for review?

临时演员 2023-04-19

26th March Required Reviews Complete - Ongoing
Reviews completed: 2
Review invitations accepted: 2
Review invitations sent: 2+

It could be due to conflicting reviewer opinions, further review might be required or the editor will directly decide.

临时演员 2023-04-19

Brother, how are you doing?

SUXINZHILA 2023-04-17

3.17 submission
Approximately 4 days later it will be reviewed
Returned with initial review in early April. 3 reviewers, major revisions suggested by the editor
Sent back on 4.17. Currently waiting for news

I have submitted to this journal twice and both times the initial review was completed in less than a month. Based on the comments section, it seems like other articles take several months. It feels like this journal handles laser-related articles relatively quickly.

Andy 2023-04-10

Until now, there is no "under reviewer" status, it is still in the hands of the editor.