dadwdw 2021-04-13

Why are you all so fast? My lab senior submitted a paper a year ago and just received comments for revisions. I submitted a paper in January and it's still "with editor" for the March issue. When I requested to withdraw the paper, it changed to "decision in progress," but after waiting for two weeks, there is still no change. I suspect it hasn't been sent for review yet. I truly envy those of you who get results in just one or two months.

可乐 2021-04-12

Posted on January 24th, sent to reviewers on March 10th, and notified of acceptance on April 11th. In conclusion, the efficiency is still good!

opticalnoob 2021-04-09

The review speed of the journal editorial department is really slow. After submitting for a month, it is still "with editor." Unable to bear it any longer, I withdrew the submission, and it was reviewed by OSA within three days.

dadwdw 2021-04-08

Article 1
Posted on March 31, 2020
Minor revisions on April 7, 2021
Be cautious when rushing to submit for graduation

Article 2
Submitted on January 19th
Still with the editor as of April 8th, not yet sent for review

小刘 2021-04-08

4.1 with editor
4.8 Still with editor
It can't be that slow, can it?

科研仕子小马 2021-04-06

3.25 submit - Submitted on March 25th
3.27 with editor - Under review by the editor since March 27th
4.6还是with editor 没有消息 - Still under review by the editor, no update yet
听说别人一个月with editor然后拒稿 心慌慌 - I heard someone's manuscript was under review with the editor for a month and then got rejected. Feeling anxious.

valder 2021-04-06

Too slow, I'm getting anxious to graduate any minute now. I submitted it in early November 2020, and it's already March 2021 and still under review...

鸣沙山下 2021-03-30

Those who are eager to graduate, be cautious when submitting to this journal. It's too slow! It took a week to become "with editor," and then after a month, it was rejected. Other journals usually take only one or two days to reach the "with editor" stage, but this journal took a whole month. I'm baffled.

optics 皮卡丘 2021-03-28

Does being in the second category of the smaller class count as being in the second category??? Also, it is a basic class!!!

optics 皮卡丘 2021-03-28

May I ask which school you are from? Thank you!

一只小菜鸟 2021-03-11

According to the regulations of our own institution, our school follows an upgraded version of calculation.

vvv007007 2021-03-10

Still considered as Zone 3, currently the basic version is still the main category.

optics 皮卡丘 2021-03-10

Excuse me, can someone tell me if the journal "小类 光学 二区" is still considered as a second-tier journal? Urgent request, thank you!

Franklinliu 2021-03-10

How can we view real-time 'if'? Isn't 'if' only at 3.2 now?

Silence~雨 2021-03-09

"Submission on the 2nd of April."

Silence~雨 2021-03-09

2.10 under review
2.19 required reviews completed
2.21 decision in process
2.21 minor revision
2.24 with editor
2.27 under review
2.28 required reviews completed
3.1 decision in process
3.4 accept
Thank you to the editor and reviewers for their speed.

optics小师妹 2021-03-06

"12.28 return to the first-instance opinions."

optics小师妹 2021-03-06

Posted on November 11, 2020, during the period, it was in "with editor" status for one month. After one day, it changed to "required reviews completed" status. At that time, I thought it was not going well. This status lasted for more than half a month. On December 18th, the reviewer's comments were returned. There were three reviewers, and they all believed that it could be accepted after revisions, but the editor requested major revisions. After revising on January 11th, it was submitted again. It stayed in "with editor" status for a week and then under review for nearly a month. Finally, it has been accepted today. I hope the journal will continue to improve!

哇咔咔2 2021-03-05

The Basic Edition will be upgraded to Zone 2 in 2021, but currently it is still in Zone 3. Most schools do not recognize the upgraded version. However, the Basic Edition will be announced for the last time at the end of 2021, and there will be no Basic Edition afterwards.

optics 皮卡丘 2021-03-03

However, I did not enter the major category 2 district, but only entered the minor category 2 district. Can it still be considered as the second district?

哇咔咔2 2021-03-03

Real-time IF3.7, exceeding OE, OL... This year, the basic version will be upgraded to Zone 2 and firmly implemented.

神奇神 2021-01-18

I have 8 reviewers...

valder 2021-01-11

Translate the following text into English: "I submitted it in November, and it's still under review after two months. Is the review process usually this long? I'm getting a little anxious because I'm about to graduate."