什么什么是什么辣 2022-11-04

Excuse me, have you found the Word template?

yldl 2022-11-02

How long does it usually take for the With Editor status of the ocean engineering journal to be sent for external review? I am anxiously waiting.

yldl 2022-11-02

2022.10.17 Submit
2022.10.18 With Editor
2022.10.21 With Editor

It has been almost half a month since "With Editor" status. It was with the editor on the second day after submission, and after three days, the "With Editor" date was updated once. What's going on? Is the editor taking longer to process during this time? ... Praying for good news in the future!!!

xxxt 2022-10-28

I give up, the dip has not been submitted for review now.

追风9 2022-10-28

Jun 19, 2022 Initial Date Submitted
Jun 19, 2022 With Editor
Jun 23, 2022 Under Review
Jun 24, 2022 Under Review
Jul 27, 2022 Under Review
Jul 29, 2022 Under Review
Jul 30, 2022 Under Review
Sep 19, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Sep 24, 2022 Revise
Oct 07, 2022 With Editor
Oct 10, 2022 Under Review
Oct 27, 2022 Accept
2 reviewers, 70+ comments, response is 30 pages long, greatly helpful for the quality of the paper itself. Also, very grateful for the time invested by the reviewers, and the editor's efficiency is relatively high. The first paper of my master's degree, very satisfied.

kivooooooo 2022-10-26

Submitted at the end of May
Received reviewers' comments at the end of June, with significant differences in opinions between the two reviewers. Given one and a half months for major revisions.
Submitted the revised manuscript and response in early August, received revise2 after about half a month, one of the reviewers still had reservations. The editor gave an additional two weeks for revisions.
Submitted the second response in early September, and received acceptance notification after half a month.
Thank you very much for the editor's support. Despite the reviewers' firm opinions, the editor still provided an opportunity for revisions. The reviewers' comments were also very constructive, and the article has been greatly improved after the modifications.

xxxt 2022-10-25

10.25 with editor.

IdaWang 2022-10-25

Hello, I would like to ask, how many times has your ocean engineering been reviewed? After I made the revisions in the second review, it is now "under review" again. Have you encountered this situation?

追风9 2022-10-23

How do I view major and minor revisions, senior? Mine only shows one "revise" and then asks for the modifications to be submitted within a month.

xxxt 2022-10-23

The given text "10.23 submit" is already in English and does not require translation. It seems to indicate a submission deadline of October 23rd.

古树余音 2022-10-23

Submission in May.
Review process completed by the end of June, with significant conflicts between the two reviewers. An additional reviewer was added, and the review process continued until mid-July, requiring major revisions.
Revised manuscript submitted by the end of September (due to delays in modification timeline caused by the pandemic, after discussion with the editor).
Minor revisions provided in early October, and the revised manuscript was submitted a few days later.
Acceptance in the middle to late October.
The editor was very responsible and selected reviewers with high expertise. Their suggestions greatly improved the quality of the paper, resulting in significant enhancements.

IdaWang 2022-10-20

Just want to ask, is your questionnaire sent back to you after receiving suggested revisions? And then you make further changes based on the feedback from the questionnaire and it gets accepted afterwards, is this the process?

Dabang250kg 2022-10-19

2022.9.2 With Editor
2022.9.3 Under Review
2022.9.6 Under Review
2022.9.20 Required Reviews Completed
2022.10.16 Accept

Translation:
2022.9.2 With Editor
2022.9.3 Under Review
2022.9.6 Under Review
2022.9.20 Required Reviews Completed
2022.10.16 Accept

Dabang250kg 2022-10-19

2022.9.2 With Editor
2022.9.3 Under Review
2022.9.6 Under Review
2022.9.20 Required Reviews Completed
2022.10.16 Accept
Overall, it went relatively smoothly, although the time for the second review was a bit long. There was one reviewer who did not review the manuscript in a timely manner, so the editor proceeded without waiting.

追风9 2022-10-17

Okay, thank you for the big brother's answer.

舞动的风铃6345 2022-10-17

I checked my two links, they are the same. You just need to look at the link I gave you the first time.

追风9 2022-10-17

Does every submission come with a tracking link? I only received one before, but then it disappeared.

舞动的风铃6345 2022-10-17

8.01 Submission
8.19 Received first review, two reviewers, deadline: 9.08
9.06 Submission
9.18 Received second review, one reviewer had no comments, one reviewer provided 6 additional comments. Deadline: 10.01
9.29 Submission
10.16 Accepted. Reviewers have around 10 days, and the editor has around a week.

The journal has a review status tracking system, which is very convenient. Recently, this journal has been fast.

LZ13 2022-10-11

Can I resubmit after rejection?

IdaWang 2022-10-10

Hello, I would like to ask, what are the chances of my manuscript questionnaire being accepted after submission? I'm feeling anxious~~~~~~~

追风9 2022-10-09

My first trial will take 4 months, so let's wait patiently.

追风9 2022-10-09

I also have the same questionnaire, but this is my first time participating, so I am not clear about the previous situation.

舞动的风铃6345 2022-10-09

The meaning of a questionnaire is that the editor has listed some questions for the reviewers to choose from below, right? OE's review comments are all like this.

舞动的风铃6345 2022-10-09

The first major revision was fast. After two reviewers, when the revision was done, one reviewer agreed while the other raised 6 more questions. After another revision, the journal sent it to the reviewers on September 30th, and they agreed to review it. It has been 9 days and the review is not yet completed. According to the time I gave for reviewing OE before, the journal usually gave me around 8 days to provide my review comments. Why is my own manuscript taking so long? Can any classmates who have done OE reviews share how long the journal usually gives reviewers to complete their reviews?

发SCI的小白 2022-10-08

2022.10.8 Accept

zmx-ly 2022-10-08

It has been 10 days since submission and it is still "with editor". I hope it won't be rejected directly.

蛋蛋886 2022-10-05

The paper has been submitted for almost three months now, and it is still under external review...

IdaWang 2022-10-04

The feedback from the second revision is presented in the form of a questionnaire. Does anyone have this situation?

川页 2022-10-03

Received repair suggestions for a whole two months, how are you doing now? Good luck!

IdaWang 2022-09-21

Currently, the renovation is in progress, but we are still very worried about the possibility of rejection.