JeffryFu 2023-03-11

I am the first reviewer, and there are two reviewers in total. The first reviewer made revisions and sent them back after half a month. It has been over a month since the second reviewer made revisions, and I don't know if the editor has assigned another new reviewer.

YugiOh 2023-03-11

Several reviewers were invited for the first review, and as soon as the opinions of two reviewers came back, it was RRCed. The editor may still be waiting for opinions from other reviewers.

JeffryFu 2023-03-09

Ask the experts, after my second revision was sent back, it changed to "required reviews completed" on February 7th. Now it has been a month and there is still no news. Is it possible that it has been rejected or the editor just hasn't seen it? Is it necessary to send a reminder letter to inquire?

JeffryFu 2023-03-09

May I ask, sir, after my second revision, my third revision changed to "required reviews completed" on February 7th. Now, a month has passed and there is still no news. Is it possible that it is rejected or the editor hasn't seen it? Is it necessary to send a reminder letter to inquire?

YugiOh 2023-03-08

20221209 Submitted to journal
20221215 With editor
20221217 Under review
20230203 Major revision (3 reviewers, 22 comments)
20230219 Revision finished
20230303 Accepted
20230307 Online
Fast speed, trustworthy.

accepted xin 2023-03-07

I hope everyone graduates smoothly.

accepted xin 2023-03-07

Submitted on December 6, 2022, accepted on March 3, 2023.
One and a half months later, there was a revision. Returned for further revisions in early February 2023. Three reviewers, two minor revisions, one suggestion to resubmit after recommended modifications. A total of approximately 6-8 issues.
After 10 days of revisions, a second revision was made (one issue by one reviewer).
Accepted after the second revision, approximately one week later. The entire process took three months. The efficiency is really high! Those who are anxious to graduate can give it a try, the success rate is indeed quite high.

袋底洞的木糖醇 2023-03-07

No, it has been almost 7 months. I suppose the reviewer did not take on the manuscript, so I have been waiting for a long time. In conclusion, it is an abnormal situation.

kingtonali 2023-03-06

2023.03.02 required reviews completed
2023.03.03 accepted, finally hired, thanks to the editor and reviewers.

小H24 2023-03-06

Excuse me, for those classmates who have not received a reply from RRC for more than twenty days, has the status been updated now? It has been almost a month since I received any news. The second review has been going on since last July until now...

alivedeng 2023-03-02

Is it normal to have the first round of review after two months?

taylor1993 2023-03-02

Not this link. If you are a Wechat user, then you can also receive status updates via Wechat. To do this, please click the following link... You can use Wechat for the link below.

ldamienrice 2023-03-01

My submission also had its status changed to "with editor" two days later, but then there was no further information. It has been half a month now, and there is still no news.

yldl 2023-03-01

May I ask if the OP inferred the number of reviewers and their opinions based on the changing time of "under review" on the website? I haven't received the email link mentioned by other OPs that allows tracking of reviewer status and quantity...

alivedeng 2023-03-01

In addition, I speculate that the first reviewer gave accept or minor revision, the second reviewer definitely gave reject, and the status of the third reviewer is unclear.

alivedeng 2023-03-01

The text translates to: "Submitted at the beginning of November, based on the website status speculation: the first reviewer returned in early December and completed the second round. However, another reviewer was found, indicating a conflict of opinions. As a result, the third round is still in progress in mid-February. Currently, at least three reviewers are required to complete the manuscript. I am waiting for the editor's feedback to see what the situation is. It has been a rather convoluted process."

accepted xin 2023-02-28

Just send a reminder letter directly, if you're lucky, you'll be hired directly.

yldl 2023-02-27

After my submission was under review, the corresponding author's email did not receive such an email! The only emails received during submission were those with the following links:

1. Go to this URL: https://www.editorialmanager.com/oe/

2. Enter your login details:
Your username is:
If you need to retrieve password details, please go to: https://www.editorialmanager.com/oe/l.asp?i=850077&l=V2TQW0FG

3. Click [Author Login]
This takes you to the Author Main Menu.

4. Click [Submissions Being Processed]

Thank you for submitting your work to this journal.

taylor1993 2023-02-27

After submission, the corresponding author will receive an email indicating that the paper is under review. There will be a link below that allows the author to track the status of the paper through WeChat. This includes information on the number of reviewers, whether they have accepted the review, and whether the review process is complete.

yldl 2023-02-27

Several reviewers, how do we track the status of reviewers?

yldl 2023-02-27

Hello, may I ask where can I see the status information of the reviewers? I haven't received such a link...

taylor1993 2023-02-27

I am the same, tracking the status of the reviewers. Three reviewers have gone missing for two weeks, and after about a month, the system automatically changed to "required reviews completed".

taylor1993 2023-02-27

In the second review, three reviewers dropped out, leaving only two. However, the system still shows "required reviews completed". This status has been ongoing for over 20 days. How will the editor handle this? There is only one reviewer's opinion. Will there be another review or a decision made? Does anyone know how this will develop?

嘿耶 2023-02-26

Gradually becoming more diluted, obediently heading straight towards 2000 articles per year!!! No more submissions.

JeffryFu 2023-02-26

Borrowing the building to seek help from all experts, currently in the process of reevaluation, the status changed to "rrc" on February 7th during the third review. Since then, there has been no news about the decision. It has been around twenty days now, and I don't know if the result is good or bad. Can someone please write a letter to the editor to inquire about the situation?

zhangjiayu123 2023-02-23

Excuse me, has the original poster received any results yet? I have also submitted mine for 20 days, and it's still "with editor." I'm starting to feel a bit anxious.

yldl 2023-02-22

Can I ask if the original poster has received the first-instance opinion? My first-instance has also been almost four months now, and there was only one date change during the "under review" period, and it has been like this ever since...

undefined 2023-02-17

The journal does not have template requirements, just standardization is sufficient.

希望早点顺利毕业 2023-02-17

This should depend on luck. If the reviewer keeps dragging, the editor can't do anything either.

追风9 2023-02-15

Look at the domain, this major is not easy, but there are also outlier papers, which is very normal.