万里悲秋常作客 2021-12-21

When will it be upgraded to Zone 1?

nijajja 2021-12-20

I am also in this situation, under review, the date has changed 4 or 5 times, what does it mean?

我是小渣渣 2021-12-16

Early November, submission.
Early December, required reviews completed, status unchanged, dates changed three times.

牛逼的博士 2021-12-15

Submitted in September 2021, still under review after three months.

winnerche 2021-12-06

The date has been frequently changing, indicating that many reviewers have been sought for the review process. At least 7 reviewers were found, of whom 6 provided feedback. The editor's suggestions for revision were given. Does it mean that so many reviewers were sought just because I am an independent author?

万里悲秋常作客 2021-12-04

7.25 submitted to journal
7.27 with editor
7.29 with editor
8.8 under review
9.4 required reviews completed
9.5 decision in process
9.10 revise
9.22 submitted revised manuscript
9.22 with editor
10.4 under review
10.25 decision in process
10.30 revise (minor revision)
10.30 submitted revised manuscript
10.30 with editor
11.01 with editor
11.21 decision in process
11.27 accept

Translation:

7.25 - Submitted to journal
7.27 - With editor
7.29 - With editor
8.8 - Under review
9.4 - Required reviews completed
9.5 - Decision in process
9.10 - Revise
9.22 - Submitted revised manuscript
9.22 - With editor
10.4 - Under review
10.25 - Decision in process
10.30 - Revise (minor revision)
10.30 - Submitted revised manuscript
10.30 - With editor
11.01 - With editor
11.21 - Decision in process
11.27 - Accept

霓虹又 2021-12-04

Hello, may I ask how the result is now?

须眉绛凯 2021-12-03

The approval process is quite fast, I don't know what the result will be. I will patiently wait and share any updates.

winnerche 2021-12-03

It has been over 20 days since the required reviews were completed.

winnerche 2021-11-25

Why is the date frequently changing, but the status remains "required reviews completed"?

winnerche 2021-11-24

The date changed again yesterday, but the status remains "required reviews completed." It seems that the editor must have sent the manuscript to many reviewers for review.

mpf1004 2021-11-23

I submitted it in June, received revision suggestions in mid-September, made the changes and submitted it again in early October. I received the acceptance notice on November 19th. "Required reviews completed" only means that some reviewers have responded with their comments, but it doesn't imply that all reviewers have responded. So, my friend, you may still have to wait a little longer.

gyyme 2021-11-22

Then you may still have pending opinions from reviewers. My required reviews were completed on the 4th. On the 14th, I received the comments from two reviewers.

蒋智明 2021-11-21

Hello, do you have any relevant templates? Can you provide them for me to study? If it's convenient for you, please send them to my QQ email 1162181252. I would be very grateful!

肥工吴彦祖 2021-11-20

The submission made on October 11th, on November 11th, it became "required reviews completed". However, the editor has not yet sent an email with the review comments. Additionally, another revised article has been in the "with editor" status for a week, and it has not been sent for review. Is it because there are too many articles at the end of the year, causing a slowdown in the process? Is the journal controlling its acceptance rate?

tingyu 2021-11-19

The manuscript was submitted on September 19th, and its status changed to "required review completed" on November 3rd. It has remained unchanged until now, which is November 19th.

winnerche 2021-11-18

The date has changed, but the status remains "required reviews completed".

SLRAN 2021-11-17

I submitted it on February 26th at the beginning of the year. The external review started on March 2nd. It has been nearly 9 months for the first review. Has anyone else encountered this situation? Is it already a tragedy?

winnerche 2021-11-15

The required reviews have been completed for 3 days.

yangxiaomao 2021-11-05

I feel like you're in Versailles... Hahaha

gyyme 2021-11-04

How long has the status "required reviews completed" lasted for everyone?

piggy_one 2021-11-04

I have previously submitted something out of scope, and I hope this time it can be reviewed.

winnerche 2021-11-03

Today under review

winnerche 2021-11-01

It has been 13 days with the editor.

小红0509 2021-10-12

How should I put it, this magazine is definitely quite easy to get published recently. I have reviewed manuscripts recently, and they either required minor revisions or were rejected, and there was one that needed major revisions, but the editor-in-chief still gave an opportunity for revision. However, most of the reviewers' opinions are fair. I have had two articles accepted before, and the review comments were also very professional and serious. The high acceptance rate may be due to the editorial board, perhaps the magazine has some strategic plan, hoping to control the number of publications and maintain its top position.

学术圈就是个坑 2021-09-04

Indeed, the amount of articles published is a bit excessive, and the quality varies. Articles that I feel good about won't be submitted here. As for concluding the topic, a little bit of watering down is acceptable.

学术圈就是个坑 2021-09-04

The time is too long, six months for the first review, but the second review is fast, accepted within one month. Overall, the quality of the articles is uneven. I have seen articles with obvious problems, and their quality is definitely not as good as IEEE JOE. Personally, I don't think it is as good as AOR either. However, there are indeed not many excellent ocean engineering journals. In terms of interdisciplinary research, OE is not suitable. It is acceptable for mixing in the smaller categories, but it certainly cannot be considered a representative work. PS: If I really think I have written a good article, I wouldn't submit it here. I would definitely submit it to a major journal.

牛13科研D 2021-09-02

The journal is okay, with a level similar to second or third-tier journals. However, to consider it as a top-tier journal is excessive. After submission, the probability of acceptance is approximately forty to fifty percent.

lwjjtt 2021-08-31

After reminding them a few days ago, I received it yesterday. I guess it took too long and they forgot about my manuscript. They couldn't even find the Word version of the revised manuscript. The proof will be available in the next 4-6 weeks, probably because there are too many backlogged submissions.

Submitted on June 1, 2020.
Received the first review result on July 19, 2020.
Submitted the revised manuscript on September 1, 2020.
Sent a reminder on August 25, 2021.
Received acceptance on August 30, 2021.

夜幕初下 2021-08-30

If we compare it with CE, IEEE OE, I actually admit it, but in the same field, others...