Dabang250kg 2022-07-29

2022.7.5 Under Review
2022.7.18 Under Review
2022.7.28 Required Reviews Completed
The first review took two months, hopefully it will not be rejected.

小白白白白白 2022-07-18

From submission to acceptance, it took approximately 3 and a half months. There were 3 reviewers in the first round of review and 2 reviewers in the second round. Overall, the process went smoothly and the speed was not slow.
22.03.27: Submitted
22.05.16: Revised
22.06.06: Submitted revised manuscript
22.06.30: Required reviews completed
22.07.05: Decision in process
22.07.17: Accepted

龙鱼 2022-07-15

Brother, how much is the layout fee?

xuzhiyong 2022-07-15

Overall, it is relatively fast. Finding reviewers is also fast. There are a total of two reviewers who went through two rounds of review and were ultimately accepted. The first round took 40 days, the revision took 40 days, and the second round took one month. Finally, it was accepted.

wejoin 2022-07-05

Pretty fast, less than 3 months.
3.24 Submitted
3.25 With Editor
3.27 Under Review
5.7 Required Reviews Completed
5.8 Revise (due by 6.21)
5.17 With Editor
5.20 Under Review
6.12 Required Reviews Completed
6.17 Accepted

18954930777 2022-07-04

Hello, I am also on the 14th for Required Reviews Complete, but I still haven't received any updates. Have you received any updates on your article?

eryueniao8008 2022-06-29

Excuse me, the original poster (OP), when submitting an article, requires selecting 3 to 5 classifications. However, when clicking on "add classifications," there is only one option available: 10: Ocean Engineering. It is mandatory to select at least 3 options; otherwise, the submission cannot be made. What should I do?

柯里昂 2022-06-28

2022.1.21 Submission
2022.3.18 First round of comments returned
2022.4.26 Revised based on first round comments
2022.6.2 Second round of comments returned
2022.6.14 Revised based on second round comments
In the first round, both reviewers provided constructive feedback. Although the first reviewer suggested rejection, they still offered encouraging words and recommended resubmission after revisions. The second reviewer's comments were more positive. Considering both opinions, the editor decided on major revisions.
In the second round, the second reviewer did not provide any recommendation for acceptance. The first reviewer mentioned that the English proficiency of the article is not high and suggested that I revise and resubmit. After making the revisions, the article is currently under review.
It is important to take every comment seriously and not overlook any details. I hope for acceptance and will continue to work diligently.

whui 2022-06-23

Every opinion is valued and will be taken into account. Best wishes for continued efforts and graduating soon.

柠檬啊 2022-06-22

I received the first instance opinion after five months and twenty-five days.

hzdhym 2022-06-21

Hello, may I ask if Apr. 14 is the deadline for submitting the R1 revision? Is the second review period from Jun. 20 to Apr. 14?

DHF 2022-06-21

Apr 14, 2022 With editor
Jun 20, 2022 Required Reviews Completed

My first article, currently in the second review stage, anxiously waiting, hoping for a good outcome. Today is the second day after the completion of the required reviews.

Derek Wang 2022-06-18

Is the probability of being hired higher after a second trial and a major revision?

acptasitis 2022-06-16

2022.6.13 Required Reviews Completed.
The speed of review is still commendable. The next step should be a waiting period of one month. Wishing for a smooth follow-up.

BOSH 2022-06-14

This article went through two rounds of review, and I submitted three articles, but only this one was the fastest. His (article) was very slow.

BOSH 2022-06-14

Do you know the editor's email? I want to urge the submission. It has been over 3 months since the revision, and over 6 months since the submission!

cx7 2022-06-12

I have also been under review for more than 4 months. Many people around me have been accepted after 4 months of applying.

熊黎 2022-06-10

Jun 09, 2022 Under Review

hzdhym 2022-06-09

Excuse me, did it only take a little over 3 months from submission to acceptance for you? It feels so fast. How many times did it go through the review process?

我与春风皆过客 2022-06-08

Today I received an email, it was rejected, out of scope!

acptasitis 2022-06-05

No layout fee was chosen, so it is unclear which one has a higher acceptance rate. However, after being hired, you will be asked again to confirm whether you choose open source.

熊黎 2022-06-05

Do you want to know if the acceptance rate is the same for paying and not paying the layout fee?

熊黎 2022-06-05

Are you paying the layout fee or not paying the layout fee?

acptasitis 2022-06-04

The following text has been translated into English:

"Subsequent updates
Submitted to the journal: 2022.05.09
With editor: 2022.05.11
Decision in process: 2022.05.26
Decision rescinded: 2022.05.28
Under review: 2022.05.29
Under review: 2022.05.30

After going through the decision in process, I thought my paper would be rejected. However, I am now waiting for the final result after the editor rejected the opinion of the responsible editor and sent it for review. Hopefully, everything will go smoothly in the future, and I will continue to provide updates."

熊黎 2022-06-02

First submission. Recording for reference.
2022.5.23 Submitted to Journal.
2022.5.29 Under review by editor.

我与春风皆过客 2022-06-02

2022.6.1 Decision in process. Without review, a direct decision, it might end up in tragedy...

BOSH 2022-06-01

The comments on the manuscript are quite objective, and the reviewers are also very responsible. The journal's editors are also responsible, and the review results are notified promptly. Recently, the review process has been relatively slow, taking more than three months from the beginning to the end. After the final revision, it was processed online quickly, and the volume number and page numbers were provided.

Dabang250kg 2022-06-01

First submission, recording the review process.
2022.5.26 Submitted to Journal
2022.5.28 With Editor
2022.5.31 Under Review
To be updated later, welcome to discuss.

我与春风皆过客 2022-05-26

What day did you vote?

acptasitis 2022-05-26

I also stayed with the editor for a long time. Is it because during this period the review speed was slow?