Verified Reviews - NEUROCOMPUTING

Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

layee 2022-07-02

I seem to have never seen the status "editor invited", it has always been "with editor". Look, it took almost a month for my second revision to go from submission to under review.
Just a comment: LetPub's comment reply system is really terrible.

暮烟水 2022-07-01

May I ask, how long does it take for the second review to be under review? Why has my second review been in "edit invited" status for several days?

kenramzes 2022-07-01

june 30, 2022 Submitted to Journal

暮烟水 2022-06-30

Does the editor invited for the second review really need such a long time, like ten days?

Billhe_zju 2022-06-30

The following text translates to: "The submission was transferred after 10 days of review, but no reason was provided in the email. The key issue is that after using the transfer system, it was redirected to a journal that is not indexed in SCI. It's really frustrating."

layee 2022-06-28

● 5/30/2022, resubmit
● 6/1/2022, with editor
● 6/17/2022, Accept with minor revision
● 6/18/2022, resubmit
● 6/21/2022, with editor
● 6/22/2022, decision in process
● 6/27/2022, completed accept

During the second review period, I was extremely anxious and visited LetPub every day to read everyone's shares. I wish everyone success in publishing their work in order!

layee 2022-06-28

It took more than 8 months, but it is finally fully accepted. Sharing the status:

● 10/15/2021, submitted
● 10/17/2021, with editor
● 11/3/2021, with editor
● 11/18/2021, under review
● 11/20/2021, under review
● 12/26/2021, decision in process
● 1/6/2022, revise and reconsider
● 2/15/2022, revision submitted
● 2/16/2022, with editor
● 3/10/2022, under review
● 4/21/2022, required reviews completed
● 5/1/2022, required reviews completed
● 5/3/2022, decision in process
● 5/22/2022, accepted with minor revision

暮烟水 2022-06-26

May I ask how long it takes for the second review to be submitted to "under review"?

暮烟水 2022-06-23

May I ask how slow is the second review? How long does it usually take? It has been three days since my second review editor was invited.

wang_xw 2022-06-23

The text translates to: "My submission was rejected after one month, with the same reason as yours. Now it is pending for transfer..."

BeCalm 2022-06-22

How long does it usually take for the RRC status? Mine has been 18 days already.

取一个好听的昵称有点难 2022-06-16

Add one, enter the proof stage, and spent the whole afternoon reading papers. There were more than 30 missing spaces between characters and words. The capitalization of "subsection" was all messed up. The tables that were painstakingly drawn looked terribly ugly after being modified. I really can't believe it, let's continue making changes. Just a question, there shouldn't be any problem with the numerous modifications, right, brother?

卡农max 2022-06-15

Never did I imagine that after the manuscript was formally published, what I saw was an unedited version that hadn't undergone any proofreading. There were missing formulas, misplaced images, and the most unbearable thing was that even the presentation of the experimental results was messed up. Was he disconnected from the internet and unable to receive my correction emails, or was he blind? Such irresponsible typesetting should not be published. Peers may think that I am not rigorous in my academic work and lack academic ethics. To put it more seriously, it may even affect my personal reputation. After this experience, I will no longer consider your journal. Finally, I wish you all the best with a smile.

卡农max 2022-06-15

First of all, let me explain that this is a negative energy post. Let me just vent about neucom. During the proofreading stage after receiving the article, the proof I received was edited randomly by the editorial staff. There were numerous formula errors, symbol errors, and misplaced experimental results. There were quite a few mistakes, but I thought neucom receives a large number of submissions/publications, so I understand the negligence of the editorial staff. Well, I ended up spending a whole half day carefully and patiently making corrections and providing understandable comments for revisions. This should be able to restore the original content and information of the manuscript... (To be continued)

高乐高不加冰 2022-06-08

I wrote a paper on medical imaging and submitted it to the editor 2 days ago. However, I have not received any updates since then. After about a month, the editor informed me that they do not accept papers on medical imaging and it is pending transfer. If you are in a hurry, don't submit it elsewhere.

cxyccc9 2022-06-08

Hello! Sorry for bothering you again. I have already sent you a private message to ask about the questions regarding expert systems with applications. I hope to receive your reply. Thank you!

cxyccc9 2022-06-06

Hello! My research direction is computer artificial intelligence, and I plan to submit to Experts Systems with Applications. I saw your comment under the discussion section of this journal regarding the issue of repetition rate, and I would like to seek your advice. However, since you are not the original poster of that thread, I encountered a bug on Letpub (unable to submit a reply) when trying to directly reply to you. So, I am disturbing you here. I have already sent you a friend request, and I hope you can accept it and communicate via private message. Thank you very much!!

wang_xw 2022-05-30

Does this mean that the editor needs to be reassigned?

jjyifan 2022-05-29

It has been one month since I submitted it. The editor said they couldn't find a reviewer. What should I do?

ticky_yan 2022-05-29

This article has been submitted for the third time and has been revised countless times. It has been two years since I started writing it. It's been really tough.

Submitted on July 23, 2021.
Revised on November 23, 2021.
Revised and submitted again on December 26, 2021.
Required reviews completed on April 14, 2022.
Decision is in process since May 23, 2022.
Accepted on May 28, 2022.

It took a total of 10 months from start to finish. In the first review, one reviewer questioned the originality, making it a difficult battle to submit. The second review was slow, but in the end, the decision was acceptance. The reviewer replied that their concerns were addressed. Overall, as long as there are revisions, there are opportunities. Keep up the good work, everyone!

imsyz 2022-05-24

The previous text is incorrect.

imsyz 2022-05-24

2022.2.23 under review translates to "February 23, 2022 under review."

jing0922 2022-05-24

During the submission process, the system will prompt the authors to select the sub-editor responsible for the paper's direction. It is essential to make a choice! Where did you learn this information from? I didn't select one at the time, and it has been six months without receiving the first review result. It has been continuously under review.

wang_xw 2022-05-24

Where do I select the deputy editor when submitting a post?

wang_xw 2022-05-24

Does "revise and reconsider" mean a state of starting over?

agrichron 2022-05-24

zeddnluv 2022-05-22

Reply to shqq: It should be that after receiving the article, it can be modified during the proofreading stage. I'm not sure about the possibility of two-way communication.

zeddnluv 2022-05-22

Reply to layee: After submitting on March 24th, it quickly went under review, but there was no update for a long time. The required reviews usually take a few days, and then we will be notified of acceptance. I guess you are currently waiting for another reviewer's opinion.

silkyrose 2022-05-19

4.30 submitted
5.3 editor invited
5.3 with editor
5.19 with editor

Translation:
4.30 - Submitted
5.3 - Editor invited
5.3 - With editor
5.19 - With editor

layee 2022-05-16

May I ask how long the decision has been made? I resubmitted around the same time as you, and it has been nearly two weeks since the decision was made, but there has been no update. It has been almost a month since the required reviews were completed.

Verified Reviews - NEUROCOMPUTING

Discover Peeref hubs

Publish scientific posters with Peeref