Verified Reviews - NEUROCOMPUTING
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

努力努力再努力s 2021-03-30

2020.09.30: submit to the journal
2020.09.30: with editor
2020.10.28: under review
2020.11.18: required reviews completed
2020.12.05: decision in process
2020.12.05: revise and consider
2021.01.09: submit to the journal
2021.01.09: with editor
2021.01.09: editor invited
2021.01.18: with editor
2021.02.13: under review
2021.03.22: required reviews completed
2021.08.28: decision in process
2021.03.29: accept

Translated Text:

2020.09.30: submit to the journal
2020.09.30: with editor
2020.10.28: under review
2020.11.18: required reviews completed
2020.12.05: decision in process
2020.12.05: revise and consider
2021.01.09: submit to the journal
2021.01.09: with editor
2021.01.09: editor invited
2021.01.18: with editor
2021.02.13: under review
2021.03.22: required reviews completed
2021.08.28: decision in process
2021.03.29: accept

woxiangbiye 2021-03-29

Why am I still with the editor after 13 days?

只想毕业 2021-03-26

My editor has been invited for over a month and there hasn't been any change.

等风南吹 2021-03-25

2021.02.19: submitted
2021.02.20: with editor
2021.02.21: editor invited
2021.03.22: Under Review

Translation:
2021.02.19: submitted
2021.02.20: with editor
2021.02.21: editor invited
2021.03.22: Under Review

冲冲冲冲 2021-03-24

Congratulations, may good fortune be with you!

XILLV 2021-03-23

3.23 revise and reconsider Two reviewers. The first one gave positive feedback, while the second one raised some critical issues that hit the mark. Currently making revisions.

10+SCI 2021-03-23

It is accepted today, and usually results are given within about a week starting from the decision.

xiaomujiang 2021-03-23

2020.11.03 submit - Submitted on November 3, 2020
2020.12.19 major revision - Major revisions made on December 19, 2020
2021.01.17 revised submit - Revised version submitted on January 17, 2021
2021.03.08 accept with minor revision - Accepted with minor revisions on March 8, 2021
2021.03.12 revised submit - Revised version submitted on March 12, 2021
2021.03.23 accept - Accepted on March 23, 2021

静而守道 2021-03-23

August 28-29, 2020: Submitted with editor
September 14, 2020: Editor invited
November 7, 2020: Revised and reconsidered
December 2, 2020: Revision with editor
January 22, 2021: Accepted with minor revision
February 11, 2021: Revision with editor
March 23, 2021: Accepted

Seven reviewers were invited, and six of them provided helpful feedback for the paper's revision. It seems that one of the reviewers, likely from a foreign country, provided additional comments after the initial revision, indicating a rigorous review process.

hituestc 2021-03-23

Congratulations. Is it released today? Mine is also being decided, praying.

10+SCI 2021-03-23

Thank you, and I also wish you the same smoothness!

匿名账户 2021-03-23

Congratulations, may you have some good luck.

10+SCI 2021-03-23

It's done, accept on 3.23.

hituestc 2021-03-22

Did the decision result come out?

10+SCI 2021-03-22

The reviewer's opinions are quite fair, so it should lead to good decision-making.

10+SCI 2021-03-22

If the opinions of the two reviewers are consistent, the decision will be made quickly. If they are not consistent, a third reviewer will be sought for arbitration, which may cause a delay in the process.

lkkl 2021-03-21

Hello, author. May I ask what is the result?

hituestc 2021-03-20

Why is yours so fast?

lucky pig 2021-03-19

It has been 7 months since the initial draft was submitted, and it is still under review. What is going on?

10+SCI 2021-03-19

2020.11.29 Submission - 2021.01.20 Modification - 2021.02.20 Revised Submission - Awaiting Decision on 2021.03.15

已投结果未知 2021-03-19

Now I just want to get the results quickly, without feeling sad about rejection. If I get rejected, I can switch sooner. It's too costly to keep wasting time.

zmxcheer 2021-03-18

Author, you finished reviewing so quickly. What were the results? I'm a little afraid mine was reviewed too quickly.

冲冲冲冲 2021-03-18

You are faster than me. I submitted it in July last year, and now it has been almost two months since the second review was sent back. The "Under Review" date has never changed. I hope everyone can be successful!

已投结果未知 2021-03-18

It has been more than half a year since the initial submission. I submitted it on September 3rd, 2020.

hituestc 2021-03-18

May I ask which month did you invest in?

hituestc 2021-03-18

May I ask in which month did you first make a投?

已投结果未知 2021-03-18

The translation of the text into English is as follows: "I guess it should be that the second review is usually sent to the group of reviewers from the first review. I'm really afraid of changing reviewers. It has been almost 7 months since the initial submission until now. I really don't know when it will end. I feel anxious."

匿名账户 2021-03-17

Did the several reviewers of the first review not agree on the review?

已投结果未知 2021-03-17

It has been 40 days since the second review, and currently only one reviewer has agreed to review. Have you ever encountered a situation where a decision can be made based on the opinion of one reviewer for editing?

冲冲冲冲 2021-03-17

Blessings. I hope everyone will achieve success soon!

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started