小巢 2022-04-17

I have to say that this journal is really slow.

tuntuny 2022-04-17

2022.4.16 submitted.

shuyupiaopiao 2022-04-16

Hello, may I ask if it is normal for my submitted paper to be in the "editor invited" status for a month without any changes? Should I send an email to inquire about it?

shuyupiaopiao 2022-04-15

Hello, may I ask if it is normal for my submitted paper to be in the "editor invited" status for a month? Should I send an email to inquire about the status?

shuyupiaopiao 2022-04-15

Hello, may I ask if it is normal for my submitted paper to be in the "editor invited" status for a month without any changes? Should I send an email to inquire about this situation?

baal 2022-04-13

Feb 14, 2022 resubmit
Feb 14, 2022 With Editor
Feb 15, 2022 Editor Invited
Feb 16, 2022 Under Review
Mar 28, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 29, 2022 Under Review
Mar 30, 2022 Decision in Process
Apr 03, 2022 Completed Accept
After acceptance, the online process is very fast, and all the messy procedures for copyright transfer are completed, and it will be online in 3 days.

baal 2022-04-13

The first round of results came out, with two reviewers suggesting minor revisions and one suggesting major revisions. In fact, their opinions were quite similar, mainly emphasizing the need for a comparative experiment with the existing methods. Personally, I feel their comments were fair. However, the comments from reviewer 3, who suggested major revisions, were a bit off. He didn't seem to understand several points and didn't read carefully.

Dec 27, 2021: resubmit
Dec 27, 2021: With Editor
Dec 28, 2021: Editor Invited
Jan 02, 2022: Under Review
Jan 14, 2022: Required Reviews Completed
Jan 15, 2022: Under Review
Jan 21, 2022: Required Reviews Completed
Jan 22, 2022: Revision

This time, there were very few comments, and the article only made changes to some paragraphs and descriptions. No additional experiments were added.

baal 2022-04-13

Last year, I submitted 2 articles, and this is the second one. I estimated that the quality of the article was acceptable and didn't want to bother, so I submitted it to Neurocomputing again. As a result, it went through 2 revisions and took 7 months of back and forth. I checked the status every day, so the status record should be quite complete.

Sep 06: submitted
Sep 07: with editor
Sep 09: editor invited
Sep 10: with editor
Sep 10: under review
Oct 06: under review
Oct 27: required reviews completed
Oct 28: under review
Nov 14: required reviews completed
Nov 15: decision in process
Nov 16: major revision

Z12138 2022-04-13

2022.3.24 Submitted to Journal
2022.3.25 With Editor
2022.4.11 Transfer Pending

Submitted half a month ago for transfer, but it got rejected. They said, "The scope of the manuscript is too specialized and not directly related to the main interests of this journal," even though they previously published many related papers.

Abbyi 2022-04-11

Delivered on 2022.03.04, turned into RRC on 03.11, and provided reject comments on 04.10. Three reviewers, one accepted, one requested major revision, and another questioned the novelty, resulting in rejection overall. The comments provided by the three reviewers were sharp and valuable.

柠檬汽水96 2022-04-11

I sent an email but no one replied. I heard from various sources that "transfer" is equivalent to politely declining, and if the review comments are not direct enough, it means the paper has been rejected. It is speculated that the journal may have too many submissions or they want to decrease the acceptance rate of Chinese papers. I have given up and am preparing to submit to other journals for a try.

Abbyi 2022-04-08

Delivered on 2020.03.04, changed to "Required Reviews Completed" on 03.11 until now. It feels like the speed of becoming RRC is too fast, does it mean it's hopeless...

柠檬汽水96 2022-04-05

2022.4.4 Transfer Pending. The first round of review results have been returned. Both reviewers and the Associate Editor have provided relatively positive feedback. The main issue is that they feel the contribution and novelty of the paper were not adequately explained. However, it is unclear why the editor recommended transferring the paper without requesting revisions. Currently, I am sending an email to inquire if it is possible to revise and resubmit to Neurocomputing. Please pray for me. ?

xhy 2022-04-01

How can non-communicating authors view the status of an article?

柠檬汽水96 2022-04-01

I feel that your response should be normal because the review time given by Neurocomputing to reviewers is one month, so it is normal for the first review result to take one month or more. Best wishes.

疆龙 2022-04-01

My submission was on February 7th, 2022. The decision is currently in process since March 30th. I am still waiting for the result and hope everything goes smoothly.

柠檬汽水96 2022-04-01

2022.3.10 submitted
2022.3.13 with editor (This stage seems to be the editing for the format check of the paper)
2022.3.15 editor invited (This stage should be after the format review, and then inviting the editor responsible for contacting the Associate Editor (AE) and reviewers)
2022.3.17 under review
2022.3.26 decision in process
Until now, decision in process

Has anyone experienced a similar situation as mine? It seems that from submission to decision in process, it took only about 15 days. Does this situation indicate that the AE directly rejected it without sending it for external review? However, I don't know why the result has not been announced yet. TAT

阿宁2021 2022-03-31

2021.9.23 submit
2021.9.25 with editor
2021.9.28 under review
2022.1.9 required reviewers completed
2022.2.21 revise and reconcile
2022.3.27 revise submit
2022.3.29 editor invited

Submitted after revision, hoping for everything to go smoothly, bless~
Will continue to update everyone with time points for reference.

mmmmmmm 2022-03-25

Wrong number

疆龙 2022-03-24

May I ask if the non-corresponding authors can check the status of the article through their respective accounts?

疆龙 2022-03-24

Can authors other than the corresponding author check the status of the article?

xinke0802 2022-03-24

Mar 23, 2022 - Con l'Editor (Italian)
Mar 23, 2022 - With Editor (English)

Navigator 2022-03-24

Word is fine, just upload the photos and author information. Best wishes!

zeddnluv 2022-03-23

Brother, I would like to ask you a question. What format should I use to upload biographies and pictures of all authors? Thank you very much.

xinke0802 2022-03-23

Mar 22, 2022 Submitted to Journal

一念执着 2022-03-23

Thank you, @envoy3! Hehe, you will also succeed soon! Keep it up!

KaZuI 2022-03-22

Cried, invested in October, will update status in February. Still in the decision process now.

Navigator 2022-03-22

October 06, 2021 - Submitted to journal
October 07, 2021 - Under editor's review
October 10, 2021 - Editor invited
October 12, 2021 - Under review
November 08, 2021 - Required reviews completed
December 16, 2021 - Decision in process
December 18, 2021 - Revision needed

January 18, 2022 - Revision submitted
January 18, 2022 - Under editor's review
January 19, 2022 - Editor invited
January 29, 2022 - Under editor's review
January 30, 2022 - Under review
March 13, 2022 - Required reviews completed
March 14, 2022 - Decision in process
March 21, 2022 - Accepted

envoy3 2022-03-21

Congratulations, congratulations! I have been following your updates all along, and I hope that I can also be hired like you.

一念执着 2022-03-21

2022.03.20 Completado Aceptado

2022.03.20 Completed Accepted