ReggieZhang 2023-05-13

2023.4.17 Submission
2023.5.3 Under Review
The submission to the lab was almost successful. It took four months for some to be accepted and up to six months for others.
2023.5.31 Required Reviews Completed. One word, fast!
2023.6.16 Decision in Process
2023.6.18 Revision. Two reviewers, the first with 21 questions, suspected lack of understanding, and the questions were quite absurd. However, they did not request rejection. The second reviewer praised it and suggested some wording changes.
2023.7.14 Revision Submitted to Journal, Under Review
2023.7.27 Decision in Process
2023.8.1 Revised accepted. Although the first reviewer seemed busy and unfamiliar with the topic, after carefully responding to each comment, they provided polite feedback and accepted it after a few word changes.
2023.8.2 Revision Submitted to Journal
2023.8.4 Editor Invited

wc 2023-05-11

2023 5.11 Under Review (The review process is so fast, it must be the editor reviewing it; if it's done by external reviewers, this speed is unbelievable.)

wc 2023-05-10

2023 5.9 Editor Invited.

wc 2023-05-09

2023 5.7 Submitted to journal
2023 5.8 With Editor

Translation: The text indicates that a submission was made to a journal on May 7, 2023, and on May 8, 2023, it is currently with the editor.

青青子衿 2023-05-08

May I ask if all the reviewers' opinions will be returned during the second review?

青青子衿 2023-05-08

Feb 11, 2023 Submitted to Journal
Feb 14, 2023 Editor Invited
Feb 19, 2023 With Editor
Mar 02, 2023 Under Review
May 01, 2023 Required Reviews Completed
May 02, 2023 Decision in Process
May 07, 2023 Revise and Reconsider

Two reviewers provided limited feedback but requested an increase in theoretical analysis and additional experimental indicators, which requires a significant amount of work. Two months were given to make the revisions.

正未搁浅 2023-04-14

Is it this slow? My article is still in the Editor Invited stage. I don't know if the next status will be the same as yours, with an editor, or the same as others, directly under review. I hope it can be faster!

lukasswu 2023-04-13

2023/4/13 under review. Why is it so slow?

Irrevers 2023-03-29

I would like to ask, for this "submit to journal," does it require confirmation from every co-author before it can be sent to the editor?

hghghhg 2023-03-20

Hello, may I ask how long you have been in the "completed" state? What did it turn into afterwards?

Una 2023-03-13

Delivered on October 9, 2022.
Required reviews completed on February 27, 2023.
The status has remained unchanged until now. Currently, two reviewers have been found and their feedback has been received. It is unclear whether new reviewers are being sought or what the situation is. The status has remained unchanged for half a month. I want to send a reminder and inquire about the progress, but there is no email link in the EM system.

Lopeture 2023-03-11

2022.4.31 Submitted
2022.8.01 Major revision
2022.9.18 Resubmitted after modification
2022.10.30 Accepted

zzl123zzl 2023-02-27

The reviewers were very diligent, and one reviewer questioned the novelty of the research. However, after reading the rebuttal, their opinion changed.

May 14, 2022: The paper was submitted to the journal.
October 02, 2022: The decision is being processed.
October 03, 2022: The paper needs to be revised and reconsidered (not for nn letter).
August 02, 2022: [No specific information provided]
November 02, 2022: The revised paper was submitted to the journal.
February 05, 2023: The paper was accepted.

好难过xcx 2023-02-25

Boss, may I ask if you submitted your work in Word or LaTeX? Do you have a Word template? I beg you, thank you!

好难过xcx 2023-02-25

Boss, may I ask if you prefer submission in Word or LaTeX? Do you have a Word template? I humbly request it. Thank you!

好难过xcx 2023-02-25

Boss, may I ask if you are submitting in Word or LaTeX? Do you have a Word template? I beg you, thank you!

好难过xcx 2023-02-25

Dear experts, do you have a template for submission? I beg you!

Kesp 2023-02-24

May I ask if you have invested in OA or subscribe?

yunxi 2023-02-21

Employed on February 20, 2023, after one round of revisions, the entire process took less than 5 months with 2 reviewers.

Oliver L 2023-02-19

Just use the official LaTeX template of Use Case, the numbering of images and the layout are automatically generated, and it is single-column. You can find it in NN's author guide.

Quantrix 2023-02-11

12.9 Submission
2.1 Under review
3.13 Decision in process

yunxi 2023-01-24

September 19th submission
December 2nd major revision (two reviewers, one minor revision, one additional experiment)
January 9th return
January 20th under review

hghghhg 2023-01-21

2023.01.19: Under Review
2023.03.07: Required Reviews Completed
2023.07.06: Revision Submitted to Journal

Translated into English:

2023.01.19: Under Review
2023.03.07: Required Reviews Completed
2023.07.06: Revision Submitted to Journal

hghghhg 2023-01-12

2023.01.10: Submitted to Journal
2023.01.12: Editor Invited

Translation:

2023.01.10: Submitted to Journal
2023.01.12: Editor Invited

lukasswu 2023-01-12

2022/12/13 - Submitted to journal
2022/12/17 - Under review by editor
2022/12/20 - Editor invited
2022/12/27 - Under review by editor
2023/1/11 - Under review

kjp 2023-01-02

Completed and submitted after 2 months, received feedback after 3 weeks. During the process, encountered the New Year holidays. The result was announced on January 2nd and I have been accepted. Wishing everyone good luck!

运气爆好 2022-12-31

There should be no need to find new reviewers.

katrina_666 2022-12-27

2022/12/16 Required Reviews Completed
2022/12/27 The time has been updated again, but the status has not changed Required Reviews Completed

anguszhao 2022-12-16

2022/12/16 Con Editor

yanhailong 2022-12-16

It has been a few days, why is it still "Submitted to Journal"…^_^