hjyai94 2021-09-14

My 8.30 submission, until today, hasn't been assigned an editor.

星辰 2021-09-10

It seems like it has indeed slowed down recently. I submitted it on June 2nd, but it wasn't reviewed until June 28th...

小丫uhan 2021-09-09

What was submitted on August 24th is still being distributed for editing. What kind of speed is this?

Dr. Lengtoo 2021-09-09

My review is complete, it has been ten days and there is still no feedback.

星辰 2021-09-09

This manuscript review is so slow. It has been over three months since submission and it's still not finished. Last time, it only took about one and a half months to complete the first review...

Dr. Lengtoo 2021-09-05

2021.5.21 submitted
2021.8.10 major revision
2021.8.16 revision submitted
2021.8.31 reviews completed

星辰 2021-09-01

May I ask if there were no comments given after the review?

十七7 2021-08-25

Directly rejected, reasons given are unclear.

XiangLiu 2021-08-25

Hello, has your current status changed? After I made the second modification, Research Square showed that I would receive feedback in three days (is it a minor revision that doesn't need to be seen by the reviewer again?), but it has been a month and the submission system status has not changed. I am debating whether I should remind the editor...

hwding 2021-08-13

Contact information can be found on the journal website, where you can inquire about the current status of the journal...

wangle53 2021-08-13

Hello, I also submitted to the NCAA and my status is also "reviews completed" which has remained unchanged. I want to contact the journal, but I can't find their contact information. Could you please let me know how you dealt with this?

dejavu1 2021-08-06

How long does it usually take to see results after a major repair?

Victor 2021-07-23

After I submitted my application in early July, it has been 20 days and it is still in the "editor assignment pending" status. Is this normal?

luluhe 2021-07-18

2020/11/22: Submitted
2020/12/17: Under Review
2021/02/26: Major Revision
2021/04/24: Revision Submitted
2021/05/05: Under Review
2021/05/08: Reviews Completed
2021/06/04: Major Revision
2021/06/30: Revision Submitted
2021/07/02: Under Reviewer
2021/07/18: Accept
Although it is in the third tier, this journal has a good reputation. It would be even better if it could be promoted to the second tier. I'm not sure if it's because of my research area, but the time from submission to acceptance feels quite long. The reviewers are also responsible and their suggested revisions are quite reasonable.

hwding 2021-07-10

It shouldn't be, I see that the current impact factor is around 5.6, so it should be in the normal second zone.

hwding 2021-07-10

2021.1.20 Submitted
2021.3.11 Major Revision
2021.3.29 Resubmitted
2021.4.16 Accept with Minor Revision
2021.4.23 Resubmitted
2021.7.10 Accept

It took about 3 months from initial submission to minor revision, and the final round of review took over 2 and a half months. In total, it took almost half a year.

iwtsp 2021-07-08

Will this journal be downgraded to Zone 3 next year?

happy486 2021-06-22

I would like to ask, how long does it usually take for you to confirm the receipt of the official publication? I am looking forward to your reply. Thank you.

happy486 2021-06-22

I would like to ask, how long does it usually take for you to confirm receiving the official publication? Looking forward to your reply, thank you!!!

happy486 2021-06-22

I would like to ask, how long does it usually take for you to confirm receiving the official publication? Looking forward to your reply.

happy486 2021-06-22

I would like to ask you, how long does it approximately take to receive the official publication confirmation?

happy486 2021-06-22

I want to ask you, how long does it usually take for you to confirm receiving the official publication?

vera486 2021-06-19

December 2, 2020 - Submitted the initial draft.
December 7, 2020 - Requested to supplement an equity statement and submitted it on the same day.
March 10, 2021 - Requested major revisions. Redid all the experiments as the reviewer requested cross-validation training. Also supplemented some experiments as requested by the reviewer. The initial draft submitted had many grammar and formatting errors, and the reviewer was really meticulous and considerate in pointing them out. Requested to return the revised manuscript before May 10th.
May 3, 2021 - Submitted the revised manuscript.
June 17, 2021 - Accepted.
Overall, it went relatively smoothly. Usually, it takes about 3 to 4 months to receive the reviewer's comments for the initial submission and 1 to 1.5 months for the comments after major revisions. This time, luckily, there was no request for minor revisions and it was accepted. It is essential to address the reviewer's requests and comments during major revisions!

hwding 2021-06-08

My submission on January 18th underwent major revisions and was resubmitted. In mid-April, it received an "accept with minor revision" decision. It has been one and a half months since I made the revisions, and there is still no outcome. The revision process is so slow this time!

sirius 2021-06-08

Complete version:
20201218 Submission
20201219 Incorrect submission format, email sent requesting revisions and resubmission
20201230 Under review
20210216 Under review, change in timeline
20210218 Major revision
20210407 Resubmitted with major revisions (Note: Please provide response to reviewer comments in the designated field and upload supplementary PDF as supporting material)
Status changed to "revision being submitted"
20210409 Editor assignment pending
20210429 Under review
20210606 Editor assignment pending
20210607 Accepted
Thank you to the journal editor and the reviewers! This is my first article in four years of pursuing a PhD. Grateful, grateful!

Sanliwa 2021-05-20

The submission is still under review and there is no progress.

wongks 2021-05-16

How long does it take to receive a response after receiving the acceptance email? It has been over two months and there has been no news at all.

跳落之猫 2021-04-28

12.18 Submitted
1.4 Major revision
1.23 Resubmitted after modification
2.19 Major revision (but mainly regarding text issues)
3.31 Resubmitted after modification
4.23 Accepted

Sirius083 2021-04-27

I don't know why it takes so long, I think it's just to have the previous reviewer re-review it, there's no need to find another reviewer. I don't know what the situation is, I hope it can be under review quickly.

XiangLiu 2021-04-27

Mine too, it has been one month since the editor assignment was changed to pending.