午离 2022-12-12

9.10submit
9.11with editor
10.7under review
No news until now.

xingce 2022-12-11

This journal sends for external review every two months, which I think is a normal phenomenon.

xingce 2022-12-11

This journal is amazing, I received the external review in just eight days. A senior student from the same laboratory took nearly two months to get the review done.

xingce 2022-12-11

It's been a year already, it's too slow, isn't it?

icanmakeit 2022-12-11

Submitted on December 16, 2021, still not hired.

icanmakeit 2022-12-11

Just wait, I submitted it in December last year and it still hasn't been recorded. It's been 6 months since the second review and there is still no news.

运气爆好 2022-12-11

Submitted on November 27, 2022.
Editor assigned on November 28, 2022.
Still editor assigned on December 11, 2022.
So slow, it's been two weeks and they haven't even assigned an editor. It's frustrating!!

letpubw 2022-12-09

Record the submission time
2022.12.08 Submitted
2022.12.10 Editor Assigned
2022.12.16 Under Review

xingce 2022-12-09

This is too slow. This journal is not good for graduating in a hurry.

iaaa 2022-12-09

It has been seven months for the second review and it is still "Under Review"!

xingce 2022-12-09

Has there been any changes in the middle date? I see that everyone has three reviewers, and there have been three changes.

GarrickO 2022-12-08

This journal is so damn slow. The first review took more than 5 months, and after major revisions, the second review has been silent for nearly half a year. Anyone who submits should be mentally prepared for over a year.

bigbigpang 2022-12-08

The first trial took about 20 days, and the second trial has been almost 2 months.

SSJg 2022-12-08

I am too, it has been two months since the status of "Reviews Completed" in the second review.

柠檬汽水96 2022-12-05

Mine too, it has been two months since Reviews Completed. When it was one month before, I sent an email to the editorial department asking when I could get the results. The reply I received was just to wait and they didn't help to push for a response. Now another month has passed, and there is still no progress.

bigbigpang 2022-12-03

Then you can give it a little push.

alphalrx 2022-12-01

I am too, it has been almost three months since the review was completed.

lj meng 2022-11-28

Mine too, after the status updated to "reviews completed" on 9.25, I haven't received any news. I even suspect if the editor has contracted COVID-19...

student_wr 2022-11-26

Reply to Ping Ping Fan: Thank you, it has already been proofread. The 48-hour period starts from the proofread email, but if it exceeds the time limit, another email reminder will be sent. Proofreading was done on the 22nd, and it was online on the 24th.

bigbigpang 2022-11-26

Stop rushing, the West is celebrating holidays, we have waited until February, just a few more days left, pushing too hard is likely to be rejected.

7788_ttt 2022-11-26

Yes, you're right. What you said makes sense. So, may I ask if it's been 2 months already, can I send an email to remind them? I'm worried that reminding them might result in a straight rejection.

平平凡凡 2022-11-26

7788_ttt: Generally, the editor is still waiting for more opinions to make a decision. This way, the possibility of a good outcome is higher. Just imagine if there are already two rejections, the editor would be able to make a good decision to reject it.

平平凡凡 2022-11-26

student_wr: I don't know about this issue. Generally, there shouldn't be a problem even if the proofreading takes 48 hours or a little later.

7788_ttt 2022-11-25

Hello, my review has been complete for two months. May I ask what the situation is? Also, has the reviewer's comments not been replied to yet, or are they still being worked on by the editor? Is there a high possibility of a setback?

7788_ttt 2022-11-25

Hello, boss. I would like to ask about my completed review, which has been maintained for 2 months. What could be the situation? Will it be rejected, or are there still review comments that have not been received yet?

student_wr 2022-11-22

Is the 48-hour proofreading period calculated from the time the proofreading email is sent? Or is it calculated like the copyright agreement, where you click on the email link, enter your email, and then start counting from the time the new secure login email is sent?

Mr_whatever 2022-11-21

2022-11-20 accept (English)

平平凡凡 2022-11-21

Yes, the total number of reviews completed changed to one, which means receiving feedback from one reviewer.

Mr_whatever 2022-11-20

2022-11-20 has completed reviews.

科研汤 2022-11-18

11.16 revisión enviada
11.17 editor asignado
11.18 en revisión

Translation:
11.16 revision submitted
11.17 editor assigned
11.18 under review