xingce 2023-03-03

I have finished proofreading. The paper will be received on the 6th of February, and the copyright agreement will be sent on the 27th. I chose to publish it for free and received the proofreading file on the same day.

xingce 2023-03-03

I have finished proofreading the paper. I received it on February 6th and sent the copyright agreement on the 27th. Then, I chose to publish it for free and received the proofread file on the same day.

jingM 2023-03-03

Posted on March 14, 2022, the result of the first review is expected to be available in about three months. After major revisions, the paper will be resubmitted on June 21. The second review will be under review until August 29. On March 2, 2023, the paper was accepted, taking approximately one year. If you are in a hurry to graduate, please consider this carefully. However, the reviewers are all very nice, and if you make good revisions based on their suggestions, your paper is unlikely to be rejected.

jgf7544 2023-03-02

If there is any information (such as copyright agreements), please mention it on the forum.

wjp 2023-03-02

I accepted 2.5, but I haven't received anything at all. This journal took a whole year to review my submission and the publication process afterwards is also very slow.

jgf7544 2023-03-02

Employed on February 22nd, until now I haven't received any emails regarding copyright agreements or similar.

科研汤 2023-03-02

It's really outrageous.

wjp 2023-03-02

I received the offer on the 2.5th, but I haven't received any transfer agreement or proofreading email yet.

keithxs 2023-03-01

May I ask if you can open the website link of the free publishing option that he sent to you? It's the link below "Continue with publishing your article:" in the email. Why can't I open this website?

xingce 2023-03-01

I received the option to publish for free the day before yesterday. Currently, I have not received the proofreading files yet. They said the proofreading will be done in the next two days.

wjp 2023-02-28

Hello, I just received a job offer. However, it has been over half a month since I received the acceptance notice and I haven't received any further updates. May I ask if you received any other notifications after receiving the acceptance notice?

wjp 2023-02-28

Hello, I just got accepted for a job. However, after receiving the acceptance notice, I haven't received any follow-up messages for over half a month. Isn't there usually a proof process? May I ask if you received any other notifications after receiving the acceptance notice?

lingxiaoguang 2023-02-28

Just asking, how do I urge for my manuscript? I submitted it in October last year, but there has been no news at all until now.

jgf7544 2023-02-25

Every year, don't expect to have a final result.

墨舞之灰 2023-02-22

Hello, may I ask how to urge the submission? I also submitted on 22nd April, but it is still under review until now.

elainzaizai 2023-02-16

Yes, I'm speechless. It's expected to be 36 solar terms.

elainzaizai 2023-02-16

Until now it has been like this. I am speechless.
During this period, I couldn't help it and sent an email to the journal in December. The reply was that the reviews were completed and to patiently wait for the editor's handling.
This is another instance, which has taken more than half a year. I feel that the speed of this journal is considered good if it can be published within two years. Too slow!

科研汤 2023-02-15

What a pity, it has been 8 months already, it's too slow.

仍有人仰望星空 2023-02-15

Posted on June 13, 2022, no news for eight months after the first review. I submitted a special issue, reminded them numerous times, but finally had no choice but to withdraw and submit to a conference.

柠檬汽水96 2023-02-14

The second review has been going on for more than 6 months... In fact, it showed "Reviews Completed" around 2 months after submission. I have followed up 3 times in the past 4 months, and I am really speechless. The manuscript was reviewed and finalized a long time ago. Does it really take over 4 months for the editor to make a decision? The key point is, it has been 4 months and still no decision has been given...

xingce 2023-02-14

We will only know the total number of people after receiving the review comments.

科研汤 2023-02-11

2023.2.11 is under review.

bigbigpang 2023-02-11

The second trial has been 4 months already, it's frustrating.

stalker 2023-02-09

May I ask how to know the number of reviewers?

IKER 2023-02-07

Posted on April 26, 2022, and reminded in February 2023, it says that I have contacted 29 reviewers, with 17 rejections and 12 no responses. Does it mean that it has been a year and I haven't found a single reviewer?

xingce 2023-02-06

However, I have been quite lucky in this regard. It took a total of four months from submitting to acceptance.

xingce 2023-02-06

The first reviewer's comments came back after one month, but there are a total of five reviewers, and it will take two months for all five reviewers to complete their review.

保佑中中中 2023-02-06

The first trial only takes one month, it's so fast.

xingce 2023-02-06

2022-10-02 editor resigned
2022-10-10 under review
2022-11-11 Reviews Completed
2022-11-17 Reviews Completed
2022-12-08 Reviews Completed
2022-12-09 Reviews Completed
2022-12-10 Major Revision
2023-01-13 submit
2023-01-16 assigned
2023-02-04 Reviews Completed
2023-02-06 Accept

Translated:
2022-10-02: Editor resigned.
2022-10-10: Under review.
2022-11-11: Reviews completed.
2022-11-17: Reviews completed.
2022-12-08: Reviews completed.
2022-12-09: Reviews completed.
2022-12-10: Major revision.
2023-01-13: Submitted.
2023-01-16: Assigned.
2023-02-04: Reviews completed.
2023-02-06: Accepted.

保佑中中中 2023-02-05

It's already been quite fast. I submitted it in February last year, and it took 5 months for the allocation editor. Today, I finally received the second external review. I envy the original poster.