xiaolaodi 2022-03-04

Hello, may I ask if you had previously sent an email to the editor-in-chief of MTAP? Will the editor-in-chief reply? Thank you.

wangbeibei 2022-03-04

2021.10.20 submitted - Submitted on October 20, 2021
2021.12.14 major revisions - Major revisions made on December 14, 2021
2022.2.12 review completed - Review completed on February 12, 2022
2022.3.4 accept - Accepted on March 4, 2022

The speed is still very fast, wishing everyone good luck.

AWC-Frog 2022-03-04

I proofed on February 1st, it has been a month now, and it is still not online, unable to retrieve.

QAQAQA 2022-03-03

Record the submission time and hope for a good result.
2021.9.15 submit
2021.10.25 under review
2021.3.3 Still under review... I asked the editor in charge of querying the status of the manuscript and they said they have received two replies. The speed is too slow...

ハローキティ 2022-03-03

Received the copyright transfer, when will the proofs be ready?

DDDor1Mi 2022-03-01

Posted on January 18th, 2021, repaired on June 15th, received on January 31st, 2022, and published online on February 28th.

There are many reviewers, it feels like they invited a lot of reviewers and forwarded all the responses to you. The review comments are not difficult. The whole process of this journal is too long, emailing them to urge doesn't work either.

科研小青年嘿嘿 2022-02-28

I received it on January 25th, but I still haven't received the proof yet...

科研小青年嘿嘿 2022-02-28

I received it on January 25th, but I still don't have the proof and the revised draft yet.

Xi-Zeyu 2022-02-27

Have you received the email about the revised draft? I accepted it on February 1st, but so far, I haven't received any news about the revised draft.

什么时候才能中trans 2022-02-27

How long will you receive the proof? Why are you rushing like this? Should I send it to the previous email address?

cgdsy 2022-02-26

Record your own submission time for everyone's reference and to accumulate some luck for yourself.
Initial Date Submitted 2022-02-24 02:05:46
Under Review 2022-02-25 11:23:52
The review status changed 3 times during the review period.
Reviews Completed 2022-08-05
2022-08-24 major revision
2022-09-05 revision submitted
2022-10-05 Still Editor Assigned; wrote to urge the submission, editorial department feedback: the manuscript editor is still evaluating
2023-01-04 Editor Assigned (Is this editorial department on vacation?)
2023-02-03 Continue to send submission reminder letters
2023-02-04 Finally Under Review, I'm really crying
2023-03-03 Reviews Completed
2023-04-18 Reviews Completed
2023-04-19 03:00:07 Accept (the journal is quite friendly, just a bit slow)

Fanerpp 2022-02-22

How long does it take for the original poster to receive copyright transfer and proof after acceptance?

Fanerpp 2022-02-22

2021.1.4 Submission
2021.2.1 Review
2021.4.3 Review completed
2021.7.2 Major revision
2021.7.15 Submit
2021.11.20 Review
2022.1.5 Minor revision
2022.1.10 Submit
2022.2.2 Accept

什么时候才能中trans 2022-02-22

It took a year and a half, with the following milestones:
2020-8-24 submitted
2021-5-1 major revision
2021-6-15 revision submitted
2022-2-3 reviews completed
2022-2-20 reviews completed
2022-2-21 accepted

QZZ_922 2022-02-18

Original poster, how did you submit your revised manuscript? I submitted two PDFs of the revised version and my response to the comments, but they were returned and I was asked to submit the source file. Should I upload all the LaTeX files since my manuscript was written in LaTeX?

QZZ_922 2022-02-18

Original poster, how did you submit your revised manuscript? I submitted two PDF files containing the revised version and comments, but they were returned and I was asked to submit the source files. I wrote it in LaTeX, so should I upload all the LaTeX files?

科研小青年嘿嘿 2022-02-18

How long does it take for the proof to be received after the OP accepts it? I haven't received mine for a long time.

VV 2022-02-16

Give it a try, it's been 4 months since the second trial, it's too difficult.

ハローキティ 2022-02-05

What does it mean when the status changes directly from "Editor Assigned" to "Reviews Completed" a few months later? There is no "Under Review."

sara2020 2022-02-05

How long does it take to receive the proof after the OP accepts it?

lulu 2022-01-26

I replied with a PDF.

QZZ_922 2022-01-26

I would like to ask everyone, when resubmitting for major revision, should we submit in latex or pdf format?

QZZ_922 2022-01-26

I would like to ask everyone if when resubmitting a major repair, should we submit it in LaTeX or PDF format?

QZZ_922 2022-01-26

I want to ask everyone, when resubmitting for a major revision, should we submit in LaTeX or PDF format?

吴相澎 2022-01-25

2021-08-11 04:33:54 Post
2022-01-25 04:14:52 Received
The first review took over two months, and the second review took over one month. One of the reviewers is an industry expert and has published hundreds of articles. They serve as editors and invited reviewers for various prestigious journals. Their suggestions were sharp and difficult to implement. Under their guidance, over 30% of the content was rewritten, greatly improving the quality of the article.

Super王可 2022-01-22

Not yet, it is said that this process is also very slow.

dusongsong 2022-01-21

Excuse me, has the original poster posted online? I also received the acceptance notice in early January, but I haven't received the notification for online proofreading yet.

Super王可 2022-01-15

The first sci article went through a grueling process of 11 months. The second review took 6 months in the hands of the editor, and it was driving me crazy. Thankfully, the final result turned out to be good. I wanted to share it with everyone. Good luck to all!

2021.2.25 - Submitted
2021.5.20 - Major revision
2021.6.21 - Resubmitted
2021.12.6 - Under review
2022.1.13 - Reviews completed
2022.1.15 - Accepted

瓦妮莎 2022-01-13

It has been 5 months since I submitted it, and currently it says "Reviews Completed". I'm afraid that this status will continue for a long time. It's too slow, and I'm scared.

hs8945 2022-01-13

Okay, thank you. Can only wait and see.