Tim Luo 2023-04-01

I have also been employed for almost a year, with six rounds of review.

Arry12138 2023-03-25

The second MSSP is done, and it's just like the first experience. Submitted in March 2022, the first result was out in June, with a rejection and a suggestion to resubmit. After making the revisions in July, it was submitted again, and after another round of modifications, it was accepted in February 2023.

Clark Mark 2023-03-24

I have also been constantly with editor.

tongtong111 2023-03-23

Record of submission process:
23-02-24 submitted
23-02-26 with editor

Very9 2023-03-21

Elsevier will send a link to the corresponding author's email address for "Track your submission", which will provide real-time updates on the progress of the peer review.

sinllay 2023-03-20

When entering the review stage, the corresponding author will receive an email titled "Track the status of your submission". By clicking on the link inside the email, you will be able to see it.

没有昵称22 2023-03-19

Hello, may I ask where can I view these review records? Thank you.

没有昵称22 2023-03-19

Hello, may I ask how to check if the reviewer has been invited?

sinllay 2023-03-19

2023.02.22 submit with editor
2023.02.28 under review
2023.03.18 under review (finally invited 2 reviewers)
Not sure how many reviewers are needed in total.

小七wwW 2023-03-13

Okay, thank you.

dyen0019 2023-03-13

Bilibili has submission guidelines! The author has provided detailed steps for submitting through Editorial Manager! 【Elsevier Editorial Manager User Guide】_Bilibili

dyen0019 2023-03-13

You can find the submission website "editorial manager" with asterisks (*) indicating the necessary materials. When I submitted, it only required uploading a cover letter and manuscript. Other stages may also require additional materials such as a declaration of interest statement.

小七wwW 2023-03-10

Hello, may I ask if you need to submit a title page when submitting your manuscript? I noticed that the MSSP submission guidelines require a cover letter, but there is no option for it in the submission system.

dyen0019 2023-03-07

20220731 Submitted
20220731 Under review
20220811 With editor
20220820 Editor invited
20220820 Under review
20221108 Major Revisions
20221208 Approved Revisions
20221208 With Editor
20221208 Editor Invited
20221209 Under Review
20230116 Minor Revisions
20230131 Approved Revisions
20230131 With Editor
20230201 Editor Invited
20230201 Under Review
20230305 Required Reviews Completed
20230306 Accept

The paper is in the field of health monitoring for damage identification. The first review required major revisions, while the second review required minor revisions. There were two reviewers, one of whom provided feedback relatively quickly within around 20 days, while the other reviewer took longer for both rounds, exceeding 30 days each time.

香蕉香蕉不拿na 2023-03-07

The process took a total of 9 months and 17 days. The expert opinions were very professional, with three reviewers providing two sets of feedback. One of the opinions was very good, while the other one was average. The third reviewer never reviewed. I am extremely happy with my first doctoral paper! Responding seriously to the reviewer's questions was very helpful!

Submitted to the journal on May 9, 2022.
Under review on May 12, 2022.
Major revision required on September 10, 2022.
Accepted on February 27, 2023.

WX公众号“非线性动力学” 2023-03-01

Posted in early October;
Submitted for review in early November, under review;
Received two major revisions on January 3, editor gave one month to make modifications and return;
Received feedback on February 2 for further revisions;
One reviewer accepted on February 12, while the other reviewer suggested minor revisions;
Received feedback on February 21;
Accepted by the end of February.

按期毕业 2023-02-28

The text translates to: "The one I recently submitted is under external review, it may be because the editor has been busy for the past period."

GZUAMTDRWEI 2023-02-28

Recently it has been quite slow, it took a month and a half for the submission to enter the external review stage. I hope everything goes smoothly!

XW_HNU 2023-02-26

Engineering, especially top journals in the field of mechanical signal processing, seem to be getting better recently, with stricter submission requirements.

MMM 2023-02-12

0206 2023 with editor - in the process of being edited
0224 2023 under review - currently being reviewed
0321 2023 Major Revision - requires significant changes
0328 2023 Under review - currently being reviewed
0426 2023 Accepted - has been approved

dyen0019 2023-02-01

20221210 Under Review
Review invitations accepted: 2

20221221 Under Review
Reviews completed: 1

20230116 2nd revision
Review Complete: Minor Revisions

20230131 Approved Revisions

20230131 With Editor

20230201 Editor Invited

aisin3 2023-01-31

Received at Editorial Office, 5 Aug 2022
Article revised, 28 Oct 2022
Article accepted, 28 Nov 2022

Translation:
Received at Editorial Office, August 5, 2022
Article revised, October 28, 2022
Article accepted, November 28, 2022

zyuncn 2023-01-26

2020.07 submitted
2022.11 major revision
2022.12 revised manuscript received
2023.01 accept
Total time taken: 2 and a half years, 8 reminders for submission.

XW_HNU 2023-01-25

0513 submitted
0707 major revision
0821 major revision
1003 major revision
1212 minor revision
0125 accept

Translation:
0513 submitted
0707 major revision
0821 major revision
1003 major revision
1212 minor revision
0125 accept

飞飞戴安娜 2022-12-11

How many reviewers do you have for your article?

dyen0019 2022-12-09

20221006 Reviews Completed: 1
20221108 Major Revisions
20221208 Approved Revisions
20221208 With Editor
20221208 Editor Invited
20221209 Under Review

Translation:

20221006 Reviews Completed: 1
20221108 Major Revisions
20221208 Approved Revisions
20221208 With Editor
20221208 Editor Invited
20221209 Under Review

能不能中 2022-12-04

Is there an experiment?

古德蜡克 2022-11-15

Did you get any results, bro? I've also been waiting for 10 days.

飞飞戴安娜 2022-11-12

After "under review," we will send you an email so that you can track your submission and monitor the status of the review. You can see it through this. In my case, the second review is stuck because one reviewer has been consistently rejecting it.

ycsycs 2022-11-11

I don't know. Did you ask by email?