yang&zhou 2022-09-30

Original: 楼主，现在是什么状态
Translation: OP, what is the current status?

wangbala 2022-09-26

26-Apr-2022 Submitted
29-Jul-2022 Major Revision
21-Aug-2022 Revision Submitted
08-Sep-2022 Minor Revision
11-Sep-2022 Revision Submitted
26-Sep-2022 Provisionally Accepted
The field covered is a bit narrow, which is causing delays in finding reviewers.

剩寒 2022-09-12

20-Jun-2022 Received
24-Aug-2022 First Review Major Revision
05-Sep-2022 Second Review Submitted for Review
12-Sep-2022 Provisionally Accepted
One non-expert (no comments), one expert (8 comments).

锦程安好弃逍遥 2022-09-09

24-May-2022 Submitted
06-Jul-2022 Major revision
01-Aug-2022 Revision submitted
06-Sep-2022 Minor revision
06-Sep-2022 Revision submitted
07-Sep-2022 Provisionally Accepted

Translated:

24-May-2022 Submitted
06-Jul-2022 Major revision
01-Aug-2022 Revision submitted
06-Sep-2022 Minor revision
06-Sep-2022 Revision submitted
07-Sep-2022 Provisionally Accepted

MM_gdbt 2022-09-06

4.21 Submission
During this period, there were various changes in the status of reviewers agreeing to review and then not reviewing, which made me feel uncomfortable.
9.3 Minor revisions
9.5 Accepted

li_marta123 2022-09-02

How long after being hired can I see the draft? I was hired on August 18th, and as of September 2nd, I haven't received the proof yet. Feeling anxious.

铠黄 2022-08-21

Submission one week or Manuscript Received

对苯醌 2022-08-11

My submission also received the first reviewer in just over a week, but the first reviewer disappeared after a week. I am still looking for another reviewer. Do you know what happened?

对苯醌 2022-08-11

Excuse me, do you have any updates? Mine is also the same. Has the first reviewer finished reviewing or has the review been rejected? Are we now moving on to the next step?

xh97 2022-07-27

The word template I am using is double-columned.

1998xm 2022-07-25

After submission, there will be a major revision process, and after the revised manuscript is returned, admission will be granted within 7 days.

oliveX 2022-07-25

Hello, may I ask if your article is written in a LaTeX template? There are two types of templates available: one with two columns and another with a single column. I would like to know if you submitted your article in the two-column format.

xh97 2022-07-17

One week after the first reviewer reviewed the manuscript, it changed to finding out the reason for the first reviewer.

xh97 2022-07-09

Does this mean that the opinion of the first reviewer is rejection? [trembles]

xh97 2022-07-09

6.6 Submission
6.8 Editing and Reviewing
6.10 Searching for Reviewers
7.2 First reviewer agrees to review
7.9 Searching for reviewers again (1st reviewer has turned gray)
A little worried

CX330 2022-07-06

The editor is very responsible, and the review process is very fast.

MM_gdbt 2022-07-06

I started the first round of manuscript review half a month after submission. After another half month, it shows that the search for reviewers has started again. It has been two months since then. Can I directly send an email to urge them?

xh97 2022-07-02

6.6 Submission
6.8 Editing and reviewing
6.10 Searching for reviewers
7.2 First reviewer agrees to review

xh97 2022-07-01

Can't find reviewers who will receive feedback from the journal? Don't want to wait indefinitely.

xh97 2022-06-29

I have been looking for the first reviewer for nearly 20 days now and still haven't found one.

mdl9966 2022-06-29

2022.5.3 SUBMITTED
2022.6.9 Moderate Revision
2022.6.20 Revised
2022.6.21 Minor Revision
2022.6.21 Revised
2022.6.22 Accept
Both major and minor revisions have been submitted for external review.

xh97 2022-06-28

Has the reviewer still not been found?

C49115487 2022-06-28

One month after submission, there will be a review result. The opinions of the two reviewers are both friendly. They have given 7 days for revisions. After the revisions, it was accepted directly within 5 days.

PassionUping 2022-06-27

5.12 Submission
Waiting

KeYanBigDog 2022-06-27

2022.3.25 Submission
2022.6.21 Major Revision
2022.6.26 Revised Submission

For the first review, there were two reviewers who provided eight modification suggestions. Most of the suggestions were related to formatting and language expression, but the most important one was to add experimental validation. A reminder letter was sent in between, and the editor-in-chief always responded promptly.

二哈们的小主人 2022-06-25

I submitted my contribution in early March and I am still searching for a reviewer. I feel hopeless now.

s_u 2022-06-24

Do I need to delete the previous file when uploading a modified file to MST?

xh97 2022-06-24

Headache, how long do I have to wait to determine whether the article can be reviewed by someone, is it three months?

科研狗的日常 2022-06-23

I see that everyone is concerned about the issue of "out to reviewers". There are generally two situations for this issue. First, your first reviewer has finished reviewing, but the second one has not started yet. Second, the reviewers' opinions are seriously conflicting, and the editor cannot make a good decision, so they have to find another reviewer. Generally, it takes about 10 days for the manuscript to be handed from the editor to the reviewers.

摸鱼星丶人 2022-06-22

Then you are much faster than me. I submitted on May 3rd, and it wasn't until the 15th that I started looking for reviewers. It has been a month and a half now, and still no one has accepted the review.