Walker621 2023-03-27

Good luck to everyone!

不完美的上帝 2023-03-25

24-Mar-2023 Manuscript Received
30-Mar-2023 Out to reviewers, in progress
13-Apr-2023 1st reviewer agreed to report, in progress
15-Apr-2023 Out to reviewers, in progress, finding reviewers is slow...
11-May-2023 1st reviewer agreed to report, in progress
26-May-2023 All reviewer reports received, wish me good luck!
2-Jun-2023 Major revision, two reviewers. The first reviewer provided few comments as they are not an expert, but the second reviewer gave serious feedback with 17 comments. We must succeed, my friends!
17-Jul-2023 Revised. There was a delay of over a month due to some issues, requested an extension.
19-Jul-2023 Accepted.

Zh-Xiyi 2023-03-25

2023.3.16 Submission
2023.3.24 Rejection, but advised to submit to another journal
It seems that the editor is unhappy because none of the MST papers were cited. I have noticed that many papers on fault diagnosis have been published. They said my paper is not suitable but did not completely reject it, suggesting to submit to Engineering Research Express.

Alyssa1997 2023-03-22

What's your current situation? I've also been submitting for three months now, and I'm feeling so anxious in my third year of graduate school, I'm starting to think about death.

111 2023-03-20

2023-3-17 Sent to reviewer
2023-3-19 First reviewer starts reviewing.

科研民工小义 2023-03-15

2023-02-21 Submit.
2023-03-06 First reviewer agreed to report.
2023-03-28 All reviewer reports received.
2023-04-03 Major Revision
2023-04-15 A revision has been submitted
2023-04-17 Return by IOP staff (requesting additional original documents such as Word files)
2023-04-18 Manuscript received
2023-04-19 Awaiting Referee Reports (submitting copyright documents)
2023-04-29 All reviewer reports received
2023-05-03 Minor revision
2023-05-04 Manuscript Received
2023-05-05 Provisionally Accepted
2023-05-09 Formal Accept

科研民工小义 2023-03-15

Hope to be accepted before graduation!

小菜鸡1号 2023-03-12

I didn't spend a long time editing, but that's when I started checking the status of the manuscript. Based on my submission (rejection) experience, if there is no email contact within three weeks after submitting a manuscript (excluding the three major warning journals F, M, H, because they will contact you within a week), it is basically sent for external review. So I would check the status of the manuscript within three weeks. In addition, based on my experience with submitting to MST journal (sending dozens of emails back and forth), the editorial team of this journal is truly efficient. The MST team handles manuscripts and emails only once a day at 18:00 Beijing time. If you don't receive an email from them between 18:00 and 20:00, don't wait for it today.

ICer2023 2023-03-11

Still being edited by the editor, there are no issues with the editor's review. The next step should be sending it to the reviewer. The timing for this depends on luck...

111 2023-03-11

The following text translates to: "I submitted a manuscript for the special issue on advanced fiber sensing. It has been two weeks, and the status is still showing as manuscript submitted. The public account has indicated that it is under editorial review. Does anyone know what the situation is? How much longer do I have until the next stage?"

111 2023-03-11

Why did you stay in the editing area for so long?

一斤菌 2023-03-10

Find the first reviewer, the first reviewer starts reviewing... entering a long waiting period.

一斤菌 2023-03-10

Esperando informes de árbitros 03-10

一斤菌 2023-03-10

What about now? Has the situation changed?

小菜鸡1号 2023-03-09

Received on November 28, 2022
Sent to reviewer on December 24, 2022
First reviewer began reviewing on December 26, 2022
Received reviewer's comments on January 30, 2022: Major revision (27 days for revision)
Submitted revised manuscript on February 21, 2023
Accepted on March 8, 2023
Manuscript accepted online on March 8, 2023

ICer2023 2023-03-08

I'm sorry, but I cannot directly access or translate specific web pages or URLs. Please provide the text you would like to be translated, and I'll be happy to assist you.

瓦妮莎 2023-03-08

Where is my article track?

瓦妮莎 2023-03-08

The submission was made on 28th February 2023, and as of 8th March, it is awaiting referee reports. However, when I checked the article number on WeChat, it showed editor review. What is this situation? Has it been sent for review (to the reviewers) or not?

111 2023-03-06

Manuscript Received on February 24, 2023.

一斤菌 2023-03-05

2023.03.03 Submission
Waiting for a miracle...

ZQ 2023-03-01

The copyright transfer form is filled out online. You will know once you log in to the submission system.

lovelinessying 2023-03-01

May I ask, senior, where did you find your copyright transfer form? The editor sent me an email asking for the copyright transfer form, but I can't find it.

ZQ 2023-02-25

2022.09.17 Submission of manuscript;
2022.09.30 Passed the initial review and sent to reviewers;
2022.10.01 First reviewer starts reviewing;
2022.10.30 Sent to reviewers, by this time the first reviewer should have finished reviewing, but the second reviewer has not yet reviewed;
2022.12.13 Reminder, received a reply stating that the second review report has not been received, and efforts are being made to find a reviewer;
2022.12.23 Reviewers start reviewing, the reminder seems to have worked;
2023.01.04 Received all review reports, waiting for a decision;
2023.01.16 Received the review decision, a total of 9 points were raised by the two reviewers, the editor provided revisions and requested submission of the revised manuscript by January 30th;
2023.01.26 Submitted revised manuscript;
2023.01.09 Resent to reviewers and requested to fill out the electronic copyright form;
2023.02.24 Official acceptance.

天亦无双 2023-02-22

I have no idea about the final handling of this journal after the second submission.

2022.9.14 Submitted
2022.10.7 Requested revisions
2022.10.22 Revised
2022.11.8 Second round of revisions
2022.11.12 Revised again

Up until this point, everything seemed normal, with the second round of revisions mainly addressing minor issues. However, something absurd happened. After a long wait, I couldn't understand why the review process took so long when there were only a few changes made during the second round of revisions. In February of this year, I became quite frustrated and sent a reminder letter.

2023.2.21 Rejected

I have experienced revisions being rejected before, so I checked the comments to see what they were. Two reviewers, neither of whom had seen the original manuscript or the revision process, simply stated that the paper lacked innovation and there were already similar studies. Isn't that obvious? They were reviewing work done almost half a year ago. Of course, there were similar studies.

I have submitted many papers and reviewed many papers. I have been rejected many times and given many rejection comments. However, this is the first time I have seen such an irresponsible decision regarding the rejection of a revised paper from this journal. It feels like the decision-making process, from the editor to the reviewers, has nothing to do with the content of the paper. It seems to be based solely on moods. Editor, why did you even receive the comments if you're just going to forward them without looking at them?

Pure speculation, but either this journal is overwhelmed with submissions and has to reject a large number of them, or the editorial level is unable to keep up, or there are no reviewers willing to review papers for this journal. Regardless of the reason, I suggest avoiding this journal if you're in a hurry.

zhangxiaoshuai 2023-02-20

I submitted it on November 8th, and the first trial hasn't come back yet. I am waiting to graduate in my third year of study, feeling frustrated.

ZQ 2023-02-20

Currently, it is in the state of "manuscript revision: sent to reviewers".

ICer2023 2023-02-19

Is the author still in the "manuscript revision: sent to reviewers" status?

Daniel Wu 2023-02-19

Hello, if it is a research on the control of nonlinear systems, can it be submitted to this journal?

ZQ 2023-02-18

Returned the review results on January 16, 2023. Central revision requested to return the revised manuscript within 15 days.
Submitted the revised manuscript on January 26, 2023.
Resent it to the reviewer and requested submission of the copyright form on January 29, 2023.
Still don't know the results after the revision, feeling a bit unreasonably slow.

ICer2023 2023-02-11

Can I remind you? After being reminded, please reply officially.