Verified Reviews - MEASUREMENT
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

chensiya 2023-07-11

Mine too, I submitted on June 15th, and the "with editor" status changed once on the 26th. It is still "with editor" now.

鲸鲸 2023-07-10

Record:
2023.3.1 submitted to journal
2023.3.3 under review
2023.6.2 major revision
2023.6.18 revision submitted to journal

浑水摸鱼打老虎 2023-07-09

Is the deadline for reviewers of this journal 4 weeks? A total of 2 reviewers were invited to review, the first one completed the review in 20 days, and the second reviewer has been silent for 25 days.

whiwnl 2023-07-08

2023-07-08 Decision in Process.

ScigLio 2023-07-07

Update: 7.7 Under Review

whiwnl 2023-07-07

This time is a resubmission after rejection, which is the second submission to the journal Measurement. The manuscript has been revised based on the feedback from the first rejection. The process is as follows:

2023-04-13: Submitted to Journal
2023-04-16: With Editor
2023-04-28: Under Review
2023-07-06: Required Reviews Completed (Interestingly, July 6th is my birthday. I hope for a positive outcome)

I will continue to update the status in the comments section.

StevenTian 2023-07-07

Reply to the above: All materials must be submitted at once. Jun 6 Under Review.

scoott 2023-07-06

Has "with editor" been cooled since July 6th until now?

GOBEAR 2023-07-06

0625-submit
Until now - with editor
Will follow up later, keep up the good work.

想发四区 2023-07-06

May I ask if I need to upload the cover letter again after submitting the manuscript?

sdfwef 2023-07-05

I am too. I submitted on 3.24, and it is still under review as of 7.5.

StevenTian 2023-07-05

6.28 Submit revised draft for first review
6.30 With editor

ScigLio 2023-07-05

Record of submissions:
7.1 submitted
7.4 with editor
Wishing all my buddies the best of luck!! Hopefully, my luck will be better ?

creatorqwq 2023-07-02

4.5 submit
4.7 with editor: I can't remember the exact time, but it took a few days to be with the editor.
5.20 Required reviews complete: Four reviewers were invited, but one of them did not return the review comments on time, so the editor invited new reviewers.
6.1 major: There were a total of five reviewers, but one of them did not provide comments on time. Therefore, there were comments from four reviewers for major revisions. Overall, the first and third reviewers had more comments, while the other two were more positive. Major revisions were requested to be returned within 20 days.
6.16 submit
6.29 accept with minor revise: Only three out of the four reviewers provided feedback. The second reviewer requested a modification in one sentence, while the other two believed it could be published.
7.2 accept
It took about 3 months from submission to acceptance, which is relatively fast for a journal. The reviewers' comments were also fair, and the editor is Professor Grzegorz M. Krolczyk.
Hope all the buddies can get accepted soon.

Quantum_Sensor 2023-07-01

Initial Date Submitted: Jun 09, 2023.
With Editor: Jun 26, 2023.

scoott 2023-06-27

Jun 26, 2023 With Editor has updated the time.

getup2study 2023-06-27

May 26, 2023 With Editor
Jun 26, 2023 Reject

Editor M.R.J.
The reason for rejection is that the research content does not match the journal.

yukifaye 2023-06-25

The review speed is very powerful, and rejection can be done within one day.

scoott 2023-06-21

Record the progress.
Submitted Jun 19, 2023
With Editor Jun 20, 2023

好好学习天天向上 2023-06-19

Feb 21, 2023 Submitted to Journal
Feb 23/26, 2023 With Editor,the deadline changed twice
Feb 28/Mar 17, 2023 Under Review, the deadline changed twice
Mar 24, 2023 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 29, 2023 Major revision: Three reviewers provided feedback, one negative with 10 comments, two positive with 4 and 7 comments respectively, and the Associate Editor provided two comments.
Apr 27, 2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
Apr 28, 2023 With Editor
May 01, 2023 Under Review
May 17, 2023 Acceptance after minor revision: Reviewer 1 raised three additional questions, Reviewer 2 agreed to accept the revised version, and Reviewer 3 withdrew from the process.
May 18, 2023 Revision Submitted to Journal
May 20, 2023 With Editor
May 25 2023 Decision in progress/Accepted

wang_dachui 2023-06-19

It has been five months... Family members... still under review.

丫丫学习 2023-06-14

投稿于6月4日,预计编辑处理时间为1-2天。在6月6日或7日发现进入审稿状态。到6月13日,有2位以上审稿人完成了审稿。目前正在等待结果,编辑表示要根据所有审稿人的意见来判断。如果审稿人之间意见相差较大,可能会继续保持在审稿状态。目前看来,编辑的处理速度很快,无论是拒绝、接收还是送出都很迅速。

StevenTian 2023-06-12

2023.6.12 Major Revision

忍者饿了 2023-06-11

Double-blind, manuscripts must be uploaded without author information.

liuf 2023-06-11

Is this journal double-blind reviewed?

浑水摸鱼打老虎 2023-06-08

June 7th under review.

上弦滅 2023-06-05

2023.04.09: submitted to journal
2023.04.14: with editor
2023.06.04: wrote a revised manuscript letter
2023.06.10: reject

YitaX 2023-06-01

18-2-2023 submit
25-3-2023 Required reviews complete
26-3-2023 major revision (Three reviewers, first reviewer has eight questions, second reviewer has two questions, third reviewer has six questions)
1-4-2023 resubmit
15-4-2023 major revision (First and third reviewers agree to accept, second reviewer's questions have not been addressed)
20-4-2023 resubmit (Respond politely and point out the unreasonable aspects of the second reviewer's questions)
4-5-2023 Accept
It took a total of two and a half months, two rounds of review, and overall the time was okay.

wztWZT 2023-05-30

May I ask everyone, how long is it considered normal to wait for a response from an editor? How can I find the contact information of my assigned editor?

wztWZT 2023-05-30

Hello, I am also submitting to this journal. May I ask where to find my assigned editor?

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started