艾静 2022-06-11

My submission took over a month to be reviewed, and it's possible that it was reviewed by the same editor.

三冬 2022-06-11

How is your present situation now?

雨秋飞一 2022-05-23

So fast, may I ask which editor?

xtrnn 2022-05-21

2022.3.30 submit
2022.4.6 under review
2022.5.10 revise-mandatory (two reviewers, given two months to revise)
2022.5.17 revision submit
2022.5.21 accept

never reject 2022-05-12

Please indicate your publishing options after clicking "generate PDF" in the final submission. Click on "publishing options", but there is only an option to publish as a subscription article, and it cannot be selected. The option to close is available below, but unable to proceed to the next step. It seems to be stuck in a loop. May I ask for any solutions? It's urgent.

海清粉 2022-05-08

Like you, I submitted my work on April 1st, and it's been with the editor since April 4th. Until now, it's still with the editor. Compared to before, the speed is like night and day.

小盲盒 2022-05-07

I submitted it a month ago and have been working with the editor all this time. The progress is indeed slow.

雨秋飞一 2022-05-01

witheditor, 5 weeks. Now under review for three weeks, the date has been changed once. It is estimated that the review will be completed soon. How about yours? What is the current status?

先生meal 2022-04-30

How long does everyone's under review usually take? Please let me know.

Tedxm 2022-04-24

I forgot the specific time points, there were two revisions in between. The first revision was mandatory and had two reviewers. One reviewer provided feedback after the revision, and after making the necessary changes, it was under review again. The reviewer who did not provide feedback the first time gave feedback this time, and the other reviewer accepted the revised version. In the second revision, minor changes were requested, and after making the changes, it was accepted directly by the editor in about three days. It was submitted on December 31, 2021, and accepted on April 23, 2022, taking nearly five months. I would like to express my gratitude to Professor Leila Ladani from the University of Texas at Arlington for being the editor.

谦 2022-04-21

The speed is indeed not fast.

学术小垃圾呀 2022-04-20

Dec 8, 2021, submit
Dec 13, 2021, with editor
Jan 3, 2022, under review
Jan 26, 2022, required reviews completed
Feb 5, 2022, revise-mandatory
Mar 19, 2022, with editor
Mar 22, 2022, under review
Apr 12, 2022, required reviews completed
Apr 19, 2022, accepted

The editor is Dr. Leila Ladani, and it seems that some other people have also mentioned that this editor's processing speed can be a bit slow.
PS: Both this article and another one from 2021 have three reviewers.

雨秋飞一 2022-04-19

5 weeks with editor, currently under review.

谦 2022-04-19

Has the final external review been completed? I feel that the manuscript review process is a bit slow now.

870631529 2022-04-12

I don't know why the guide for authors of Elsevier journals cannot be opened now. Hello, can you please send me the submission format of this journal to my email: 870631529.

870631529 2022-04-12

Hello boss, can you please send me the submission format of this journal to my email: 870631529? I don't know why the guide for authors of Elsevier journals cannot be accessed now.

科研民工 2022-04-10

20220126-Submitted
20220131-With editor
20220206-Under review
20220305-Revise-Mandatory
Two reviewers, overall evaluations are relatively positive, one has 6 minor revision comments, the other asked more detailed questions and provided 17 comments.
20220316-Revision submitted
20220317-Under review
20220409-Accepted

材料界李云龙 2022-04-10

Basically, it means accepting the modified version. Previously, I was in this state and immediately accepted it after it was modified.

雨秋飞一 2022-04-09

Still with Editor, how about you?

先生meal 2022-04-07

Brother, how are you doing now?

雨秋飞一 2022-04-04

Did you submit it for review? What was the result? Mine has also been with the editor for a month.

雨秋飞一 2022-04-04

Has your submission been reviewed? Thank you.

雨秋飞一 2022-03-29

No, still with the editor. I'm not sure why, maybe because there is too much content and the editor is too busy to look at it.

先生meal 2022-03-29

Did you submit it for review? Mine has been half a month and still no news.

雨秋飞一 2022-03-28

3.11 submitted to journal
3.13 with editor
3.20 with editor

It has been over two weeks with the editor, and I can't figure out what the situation is. Has anyone experienced this kind of status change? Please help me understand. Thank you. I have submitted two articles before, and they were quickly under review.

雨秋飞一 2022-03-28

Has it been submitted for review now? What is the result?

Never rejected 2022-03-15

In early March, I submitted a short message. The editor rejected it for the second time within 5 days without sending it for review. They pointed out that the analysis was not innovative enough and not thorough. Upon reflection, I realized that the angle of storytelling was not good, deliberately omitting the technical aspect.

Never rejected 2022-03-14

Submitted at the end of October, results were released at the end of December, with minor revisions. The chief editor probably took into consideration the Spring Festival and gave two months for revisions. Although it was referred to as minor revisions, as a precaution, additional experiments were conducted. Due to the boss being busy, there was a delay of two weeks. The revised manuscript was submitted at the beginning of March and accepted the following day.

It is worth noting that in the feedback for the minor revisions, the chief editor mentioned that according to the latest policy, the results and discussion should be divided into two sections. However, if it is really difficult to separate them, it is possible to argue reasonably.

Tedxm 2022-03-10

Only upload the revised draft in Word, is that okay?

科研小僧 2022-03-07

Mine too...