Lt小白 2022-03-23

I would like to ask if this journal is slow?

泽铭sama 2022-03-17

You are so fast! I also submitted to this journal on February 16th, and it's still under review until today...

JinHong G 2022-03-16

3.15 reviews required have been completed.

香蕉Allen 2022-03-06

Rejected by ASS, several review comments were rejected when submitted to JPD, and after revision, it was submitted to MATERIALS CHEMISTRY AND PHYSICS.
The manuscript was submitted on February 13th and is currently under review since February 28th.
The research is good, but unfortunately, my presentation is not. It is my first paper. I am approaching the mid-term and don't have time for further modifications, so I had to submit it. Previously, the ASS editor suggested transferring to this journal, but I didn't agree. Now, I am submitting it myself, which is embarrassing.

wuyujie 2022-03-02

2021.11.22 Submitted with editor
2022.2.28 Finally under review...

JinHong G 2022-02-22

February 7th with editor
February 20th Under Review

孤竹博 2022-02-16

The editors' opinions are all very professional, but the reviewing speed is giving me a bit of a headache. I submitted revisions on December 11, 2021, and as of February 16, 2022, I am still waiting for the review comments. I sincerely wish the journal continues to improve, but I hope the speed can be faster.

Guo2020 2021-12-18

December 17th, received. Thank you to the editor and reviewers, this is the second SCI article during my master's program.

清颜 2021-12-15

March submission, feedback received in mid-August, response sent back by the end of August, external review conducted on the same day, initial review completed in early September, editor has been unable to make a decision, making a decision is too difficult, accepted in mid-December.

孤城GG 2021-12-15

Actually, it's not particularly slow, but it's slower than expected.
The first review took four months for minor revisions. I thought it would be faster after the revisions, but ended up waiting for another four months.
I thought to myself that this article wasn't urgent, but then I received an email saying it was accepted, along with the email to send the paper to the publishing house. It's unbelievable.
Submitted in late April, minor revisions in August, returned in a week, accepted in December.

Guo2020 2021-12-13

August with editor
November 5th under review
November 29th revise
December 6th submit
December 7th format revise
December 7th submit
December 7th with editor

?8 2021-12-13

I have been with my editor for over a month.

CC必中 2021-12-01

How long have you been waiting? It's really too slow.

天若有情 2021-11-26

Too slow, definitely do not invest.

BangBangZedong 2021-11-25

It has been nearly 11 months, and we still don't know the outcome. I really don't know how this journal manages to survive. Just because of one paper, it has caused so much delay for others. I am truly disappointed.

鲫鱼 2021-11-25

It has been two months since I submitted to the editor, but there has been no news at all. I have no idea what happened to the editor.

?8 2021-10-30

This is also good! It seems that this journal is very slow, but it's much better than waiting for a year and a half only to be rejected.

?8 2021-10-30

Can't be! I just invested, can't believe I fell into a trap, right? If it gets rejected after a year or so, it would be over.

BangBangZedong 2021-10-25

This journal is incredibly slow to the point of heartbreak. It took seven months to receive revision suggestions, and after making the revisions, there has been no response for over three months. They don't even reply to emails. It's truly frustrating.

难却 2021-10-02

Dear editor,
I apologize for contacting you during this time. I submitted my manuscript titled "..............." [manuscript id: ............] to your journal through the online submission system on June 30, 2021. On the same day, the status changed to "with editor." However, the status has remained the same since then.
I would appreciate it if you could inform me if there have been any updates regarding my submission. I am eagerly awaiting your response.
Thank you for your attention!

LYH不要996 2021-09-27

How should I write this reminder email? I have also been with the editor for a long time and want to remind them.

难却 2021-09-22

Posted on June 28, 2021, I sent a reminder email to the editor after about fifteen days. The editor was very kind and informed me that my manuscript was being processed after a while.

On August 18, I received the revision comments, which were numerous, detailed, and professional. On September 16 afternoon, after making the revisions, I replied with a letter that was over 20 pages long. I received the acceptance notification a little after 8 PM that night. Seeing others' submission experiences, I felt it was a slow process, and I also felt anxious throughout the entire process. In the end, I still had a positive outcome! Thank you, editor! With one more year ahead, I will work hard on the next article! Wishing everyone's dreams come true!

handsome man 2021-09-14

Is the detailed process of your submission downloaded from the journal or recorded after each viewing by yourself? If it's the latter, that's too troublesome!

不是诺贝尔本人 2021-08-13

Has the original poster got any updates? The last modification date of my external review hasn't changed for 2 months.

Winston 2021-07-11

with the editor, it will take about three months.

YXT-H 2021-07-11

Finally received after 8 months and 10 days.

难却 2021-07-11

Hello, may I ask how long did you maintain the "with editor" status when you first invested?

Winston 2021-07-04

It has been almost a month since the reviewers who are required to complete the rework have been waiting silently.

YXT-H 2021-07-03

Must complain about the speed of this journal. It took 7 months to receive the review comments after submission, and after making the revisions, it has been 14 days and still no idea about the outcome. I wonder what the editor is doing. My fellow classmates who are in a rush to graduate must be cautious!

upcLeon 2021-06-24

Slow to the point of doubting life, it has been 8 months, and there was even one reminder in between. After making corrections, it has been another two months for external review.