Verified Reviews - MATERIALS CHEMISTRY AND PHYSICS
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Nice to meet you 2022-11-09

Waiting for a decision is really difficult... I have been waiting for two months for a response to come back...

多兰 2022-11-09

The text "11.9 underreview" is already in English. It does not require any translation.

wuyujie 2022-11-08

2021.11.22 Submitted with editor
2022.2.28 Finally under review...
It took three months to be under review.

An endless waiting period, during which I asked the professor to send reminder letters three times.
About a year has passed...

2022.10.5 Received a minor revision for image format and reference blabla.
2022.10.18 Accepted.

It is really too slow.
Too! Slow!

Skylor 2022-11-07

Posted in early July, sent for external review within two weeks.
Received reviewer's comments in early October, only one reviewer, with four relatively simple questions.
Accepted in early November.

桀骜绵羊 2022-11-07

It has been half a year, and there is no news.

桀骜绵羊 2022-11-07

I have been waiting for six months, under review for five months, feeling desperate.

tuer1983 2022-11-06

It's already November, but still no news. I can't withdraw the submission either. It's frustrating. How did I fall into such a deep pit? Can someone tell me what to do?

Joselfwei 2022-10-26

6.11 submitted
According to the email sent by the system, the review was completed at the end of August.
9.21 Sent a reminder email.
9.24 The editor replied and gave revision comments.
10.21 Revised.
waiting...
blessed

多兰 2022-10-23

I have been under for half a year.

无昵称11 2022-10-19

Posted in April 2021, it is still under review.

多兰 2022-10-06

10.6 under review (It has been over five months, which is frustrating.)

不必问君行 2022-09-29

Don't submit to this journal, it's too slow. I submitted on July 28th, and it was with the editor until August 2nd. It remained with the editor until September 29th without being sent for review for two months. I sent three reminder emails in between, but I really don't know what the editor of this journal is doing every day! If you are in a hurry to publish your article, definitely do not submit to this journal, it's been a frustrating two months. I have already withdrawn my submission and plan to submit to another journal.

迷途 2022-09-27

Maybe I was lucky, and it was accepted in just two months.
Submitted on July 15, 2022, accepted on September 24, 2022.

blueonblue 2022-09-22

Received 12 June 2017
Received in revised form 15 September 2017
Accepted 29 September 2017
Available online 4 October 2017

Received 22 April 2019
Received in revised form 19 June 2019
Accepted 24 June 2019
Available online 26 June 2019

The text above states the dates of certain events related to the publication of an article or research paper. The first set of dates indicates the initial submission and subsequent revisions, followed by the acceptance and online availability of the publication. The second set of dates follows the same pattern for a different publication.

多兰 2022-09-13

Today it is still under review. I asked the chat, and the result is that they still haven't found a reviewer. Currently, there is no reviewer who has agreed to review it. The editor is Yasufumi Fujiwara. Everyone really needs to be cautious.

little居 2022-09-06

7.2 with editor
9.6 have not been reviewed or rejected
Submission needs to be careful, although it does not affect graduation, it has a significant impact on graduate awards and evaluations. It's too slow.

xiaomage 2022-09-06

9.5 with editor

tuer1983 2022-09-03

It's simply indescribable. I submitted it on May 5th, and it was only sent for peer review on July 1st. It's now September 3rd, and there has been no response at all. I feel like it may take half a year or even longer to receive the external reviewer's comments.

多兰 2022-09-02

9.2 under review.

多兰 2022-09-02

Continue updating, it has been under review for four months.

xiaomage 2022-09-02

Brother, we're doing well now. Just wait a little longer and we'll win.

BARRY 2022-09-02

Wait patiently. I haven't received any news for six months.

BARRY 2022-09-02

Just wait patiently. It has been six months, and there is still no news.

xiaomage 2022-09-01

Rejected twice, recording the third time. 9.1 submitted.

科研的笨鸟 2022-08-30

2022.8.24 under review, seeking good luck.

Mayong 2022-08-24

2022.7.15 submitted to journal
2022.7.17 with editor
2022.7.18 under review
2022.8.11 under review
2022.8.23 Required Reviews Completed
The first review should be completed, but I haven't received any feedback yet. It should be coming soon. I hope it's faster.

Mayong 2022-08-21

2022.7.15 submitted to journal
2022.7.17 with editor
2022.7.18 under review
2022.8.11 under review

Translation:

Submitted to the journal on July 15, 2022.
With editor on July 17, 2022.
Under review on July 18, 2022.
Still under review on August 11, 2022.

难儿本色 2022-08-19

The text is already in English. It states that a submission was made to a journal on August 13th, and it was sent to the editor on August 18th. As of August 19th, the decision is currently being processed.

做完实验打boss 2022-08-18

Received at Editorial Office 18 Mar 2022
Article revised 12 Aug 2022
Article accepted for publication 18 Aug 2022

The time in the editor's hands after submission was indeed a bit long, about over a month. After being sent for review, it was assigned to two reviewers, one of whom accepted the review quickly, while the other took a while and finally provided feedback. The revisions were accepted quickly, taking a total of 5 months.

I had previously submitted an article to this journal and the review time given by the editor was 14 days. Therefore, I feel that if suitable reviewers are found, the review process should be quite fast.

科研的笨鸟 2022-08-15

2022.6.20 Submission
2022.6.27 with editor - present
It's a bit slow, and I'm afraid of being rejected.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now