hocking 2023-01-15

Congratulations, brother! May I ask if the reminder letter should be sent directly to Editor-in-Chief Jie Lu?

DDDor1Mi 2023-01-14

The first review was fast, but after submitting the second review, it stayed with AE for a month without being sent for review. After sending an email to urge, it was immediately sent for review. After the second review was completed, it stayed with AE for another month. Only after sending an email to urge did they give the results. They said they wanted to change the language and used the recommended editing service. After submitting the changes, it was accepted the next day. Knosys will send you emails at each step to inform you of the progress. There were some issues during the revision, but when I called the China office of the editorial department, the person was very friendly and the communication went smoothly.

2022.6.12 submitted
2022.6.15 with editor
2022.6.23 under review
2022.9.18 required reviews completed
2022.9.30 revision
2022.10.18 revision submitted
2022.10.19 with editor
2022.11.23 under review
2022.12.5 required review completed
2023.1.3 conditional accept (language editing)
2023.1.13 revision submitted
2023.1.14 accept

senllh 2023-01-12

The review speed is relatively good, with a three-month period for both the first and second reviews.

Received 20 Jun 2022
Conditional accept 23 Sep 2022
Revised 31 Oct 2022
Accept 11 Jan 2023

keepL 2023-01-10

Also received the suggestions for language editing, may I trouble the experts downstairs to ask if everyone is recommending the use of proofreading services?

keepL 2023-01-10

Did I understand correctly that I received a "conditionally accepted"? Does this mean I need to make some adjustments to my cover letter and include a point-to-point response?

DDDor1Mi 2022-12-26

May I ask how long does it take to get the results in the end? It has been about 20 days since I completed the required reviews. When I sent it back for repairs, it stayed in their hands for a month. I sent an email to urge them, but now I dare not send another one. Sigh...

guoxiansheng 2022-12-24

You are so fast! I thought submissions were not being reviewed during the holiday season. I submitted my manuscript on November 19th, and it is still "with editor" up to now. I want to follow up, but I'm not sure if I can do so during Christmas.

乌拉木木 2022-12-24

When I submitted my application on 12.15, the number was already over 6500.

乌拉木木 2022-12-24

12.24 under review translates to "12.24 being reviewed" in English.

guoxiansheng 2022-12-22

You are so fast! I won't submit it for review anymore.
Is there any reason for rejection? I'm worried because there was no clear rejection from the editorial side.
I will make good revisions according to the review comments. I will definitely succeed next time!

kkfc 2022-12-22

No, I am the first reviewer. I feel that the reviewers all said it can be modified, but it's still tragic. So, I transferred it.

guoxiansheng 2022-12-22

What is the meaning of "老哥大修之后投的，被拒了？？？不是说大修之后跟少拒的吗" in English?

"After applying for it following the major renovation, it was rejected??? Wasn't it said that there would be fewer rejections after the major renovation?"

kkfc 2022-12-22

Too fast. I entered the dip in the afternoon and was rejected. None of the three reviewers seemed to directly reject it. It seems that even major revisions will be rejected.

guoxiansheng 2022-12-22

Alright, thank you, big brother. Praying for a good outcome.

kkfc 2022-12-22

I don't understand. Based on your situation, you should send it to AE. As long as you send it to AE, it will be reviewed. Look at the efficiency of each AE.

guoxiansheng 2022-12-22

My November 29 with editor, December 10 status date changed a bit, and it is still with editor until now. Is it going to be rejected or did the editor forget... It's Christmas vacation again, and my mindset is collapsing.

kkfc 2022-12-22

12.20 rrc Three reviewers have completed the review. This is the first time I have seen such a fast response after submitting so many papers. However, is the associate editor on leave for Christmas? It has been two days and there is still no decision in sight. Life and death are predetermined, and wealth and fortune are in the hands of heaven.

jie996 2022-12-21

It has been 3 months, and there is no news at all. Please reject it quickly. You have a big head.

乌拉木木 2022-12-17

2022.12.15 submitted
2022.12.15 with editor

guoxiansheng 2022-12-16

Brother, what was the reason for being rejected? I submitted one day earlier than you, and I am also with the editor.

蓝莓陨石 2022-12-16

The translation of the text into English is:

11.30 submit
12.01 with editor
12.16 reject

guoxiansheng 2022-12-14

I also submitted on November 19th, and now it is still with the editor. I don't know what the situation is either.

kkfc 2022-12-10

@Hellen How did the first results turn out?

kkfc 2022-12-10

@hocking will send an email with a tracking link after starting the review.

Hellen 2022-12-10

I also submitted on the 19th. Currently, it's still "with editor". Just waiting. It's indeed a bit agonizing, the second time...

hocking 2022-12-10

Brother, how can you see that there are 2 or 3 reviewers?

kkfc 2022-12-10

11.19 submitted
11.20 with editor
12.04 with editor
12.06 under review
12.09 3 reviewers reviewing (changed from 2 to 2+, should be 3 reviewers, worried, hoping for quick results, to die early and be reborn early)

Karl_66 2022-12-10

What reasons were you rejected for, buddy?

不屈不挠 2022-12-10

2022.11.29 提交 (submit)
2022.11.30 與編輯 (with editor)
2022.12.10 拒絕 (reject)

Translated into English:

2022.11.29 submit
2022.11.30 with editor
2022.12.10 reject

BeCalm 2022-12-09

The number of submissions this year is significantly higher than last year, it should be around 1200.