Verified Reviews - KNOWLEDGE-BASED SYSTEMS
Note: Verified reviews are sourced from across review platforms and social media globally.

Keeny 2023-05-08

2023.05.04 Post
2023.05.05 with editor

Keeny 2023-05-08

2023.05.05 With Editor

MD_ANDY 2023-05-06

Hello, I want to know what to invest in after being rejected? I want to invest in something fast, but I don't have anyone around me who does NLP. I don't know if you have any recommendations or not.

MD_ANDY 2023-05-06

I want to know what you will switch to later.

MD_ANDY 2023-05-06

I want to know the result. If I decide to run away, which journal should I submit to?

Keeny 2023-05-05

Record the submission status:
2023.05.04 Submission

lcxxxiii 2023-05-02

It's just measuring FLOPs, right?

Ricardo_Xu 2023-04-30

How do I withdraw the submission, brother? Is there any way? I can't wait any longer either.

之物 2023-04-28

Too slow... I'm ready to withdraw the submission.

dosonleung 2023-04-27

The translation of the text is as follows: "The speed was very slow, it took around 11 months from the first submission to acceptance after three revisions. The reviewers did not pay much attention to detail, and their responses were quite vague, for example, mentioning that the dataset was not large enough or that the analysis of time complexity was missing (my model is based on deep learning, so how can I analyze time complexity [doge])."

之物 2023-04-25

How long did it take for the results to come out in the end? It has been a month since the required reviewers completed it.

大白兔一枚 2023-04-23

How can I see that 12 reviewers have been sent? My link only shows 2+ reviewers without the specific number...
I suggest you remind them, the editor needs to collect at least 2 opinions to make a decision. If there is only 1 now, they will have to send it to other reviewers after editing, and it will take a long time to wait.

hy3761 2023-04-20

2.16 submitted, 3.24 under review, it has been a month now. The tracking link shows that it has been sent to 12 reviewers, but only one has agreed to review it. Has anyone else experienced a similar situation?

叨乐 2023-04-18

20221108 Submitted to Journal
20221114 Under Review (Sent 2+, accepted 3)
20221226 Required Reviews Completed
20221228 Revised
20230228 With Editor
20230301 Under Review (Sent 2+, accepted 2)
20230409 Required Reviews Completed
20230410 Revised (including language editing); conditionally accepted
20230418 With Editor

尼古拉凯奇 2023-04-17

Post from 2022-10-10 to 2023-4-17, always in the first round under review. I've sent three reminders during this time, but haven't received any replies. I have decided to withdraw the submission. I chose to submit to this journal because I heard they had a fast review process, but it turns out... it's really frustrating.

之物 2023-04-17

It has been a month since the required reviews were completed and there has been no response.

东方梅小四 2023-04-14

The text you provided is already in English. It says "I use LaTeX."

dingding_777 2023-04-12

May I ask what format should be used for submitting the paper? Is it required to be in Word format?

dingding_777 2023-04-12

May I ask what format you used when submitting the revised manuscript? Did they specify that it must be in Word format?

dingding_777 2023-04-12

Hello, may I ask if you require the submission to be in Word format when you return the revised draft? After generating the PDF, when I click "view reference," it prompts that Microsoft Word cannot process the PDF format. Does this have a significant impact?

123nini 2023-04-09

I submitted it on the 29th and have been working with the editor since then.

lily0118 2023-04-09

I submitted it on April 29th, and on the 30th it was with the editor, but there has been no further progress since then.

chuyunxinlan 2023-04-07

I submitted it on September 29th last year, and now it is April 6th of the second year. The current status is under review.

zzzzzzzzzzzg 2023-04-07

You are so quick in the second review.

Tingrid 2023-04-07

2023.2.27 Submitted
2023.2.28 Under Editor Review
2023.3.11 Under Editor Review
2023.3.24 Under Review
2023.3.27 Under Review, 3 Agreed to Review and 4 Invited to Review
2023.5.8 Required Reviews Completed
2023.6.26 Major Revision

zzz---- 2023-04-06

The recent process seems a bit slow according to everyone's comments. May I ask, my classmate, has there been any progress with your submission?

东方梅小四 2023-04-06

The receiving time was written incorrectly, it should be April 4, 2023.

东方梅小四 2023-04-06

October 7, 2022 - Submission
October 11, 2022 - Under review
October 29, 2022 - Major Revise, four reviewers, each opinion is very professional, it is estimated that it has been sent to the hands of professionals in the field, quite explosive.
March 15, 2023 - Revised manuscript submitted
March 26, 2023 - Received second-round review comments, conditionally accepted
March 31, 2023 - Revised manuscript submitted
April 01, 2023 - Accept

gc1995 2023-04-04

2022-10-14 Submission
2022-12-25 Major revision with 2 reviewers and over 40 comments
2023-1-8 First resubmission
2023-3-30 Decision in process
2023-4-4 Accepted
Overall, it took 5 and a half months. Finally, wishing everyone a good outcome!

早日中刊 2023-04-01

Just waiting for news after voting on the 31st.

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started