曹贵成ggw 2022-08-17

Status update, the previous one should be an editing for format review, and the status as of 20220807 is updated to "Under Review";
A new edit has been made, it should still be in the hands of the editor and not yet submitted for review.

曹贵成ggw 2022-08-17

Responsibility editor was assigned on August 17, 2022, and the status remains as Awaiting Admin Processing.

曹贵成ggw 2022-08-17

I am a submission made on the system. After submitting, I can receive an email on the same day, and this applies to all authors.

ice1 2022-08-17

Did you submit in the new system? Did you receive any notifications after submitting?
After I submitted in the new system, they said I would receive a new email within a day, but I still haven't received anything.

曹贵成ggw 2022-08-16

2022.08.16 Submission
Awaiting Admin Processing
Looking forward to a positive outcome

凉宫夕立 2022-08-07

5.18 Submission
6.16 Major revision
6.21 Submit R1
7.15 Acceptance
Fast speed, meticulous reviewers, and the editor will check grammar during finalization.

科研打工人96 2022-07-27

May I ask if the system's date is updated when it shows "under review"? Does it mean that it has been sent for external review?

scut@Alexander 2022-07-10

2.12 submit
2.13 under review
5.28 minor revision - Both reviewers provided minor revisions, with a four-week timeframe.
6.13 revised submission
6.21 accept
Overall speed is acceptable, although the initial review took a longer time.

桔#梗 2022-07-04

Has there been any change in the status of the review? My status has remained unchanged for nearly 6 months.

向日葵 2022-07-03

Is it difficult to submit an article to this journal?

AAAAAAaaaaaa 2022-07-03

2022.1.28 Submission
2022.6.18 First round of revisions (two reviewers)
2022.6.22 First round of revisions returned
2022.6.26 Accepted

The first round of revisions took quite a long time, almost 5 months. However, the editor was attentive and provided feedback on some formatting issues.

nopiont0 2022-06-17

Sure, I graduated half a year ago before sending it out.

Le123123 2022-06-12

It has been four months now and still no letter. I feel it's quite slow. Hahaha.

吃柚子的虫 2022-06-12

Excuse me, is this journal currently slow?

Le123123 2022-06-08

How long do you usually have to wait for a decision, my friends? Please share your experiences! Thank you all!

Le123123 2022-06-08

Waiting for a decision for eight months? Is it confirmed? It's been three weeks for me now, and there's no news at all.

爱吃蔬菜的西瓜 2022-05-16

The influence of the journal has been continuously increasing in recent years. The editors and associate editors are very good, but the review process is indeed a bit slow.

Submission: September 10, 2021
Minor revision: March 21, 2022
Revised submission: March 29, 2022
Second minor revision: April 10, 2022
Revised submission: April 14, 2022
Accepted: May 15, 2022

OUOUOUYE 2022-05-15

May I ask where to submit the reminder letter? It has been almost 4 months under review.

OUOUOUYE 2022-05-15

Hello, may I ask how to submit a reminder letter? My paper has been "Under Review" for almost four months.

socool 2022-05-11

Today is the first time I submitted an article. I give it a positive review and hope to be accepted.
Recording the timeline:
20220511: Awaiting Admin Processing
20220513: Under Review

爱吃蔬菜的西瓜 2022-04-28

The second minor repair is scheduled to return on April 14, 2022. It has been almost half a month since awaiting decision, but there is still no news. How long does everyone usually wait?

nopiont0 2022-04-12

My article went through the first round of revisions and took 9 months to be accepted. The whole process from submission to acceptance took 16 months. If I hadn't submitted another article to graduate, I might have failed with this journal. If you want a quick acceptance, it's better not to submit to this journal. However, their editors are very responsible. During the proofreading process, they singled out many ambiguous or poorly written sentences in the article for improvement. The final check was still very satisfying.

咿呀咿呦 2022-04-11

The first review time is not fixed, some review times are long, and some review times are short.
I didn't pay attention to whether the completed manuscript would have the status of "required reviews completed" at that time, and I forgot.
Wishing your article to be accepted smoothly! Good luck!

爱吃蔬菜的西瓜 2022-04-08

Hello, is there any news about the article now? I have been waiting for over a week after the minor revision.

Paper will be accepted 2022-04-01

How long does the review process usually take?

seven2015 2022-03-31

May I ask how long it takes to receive a decision for the paper with the status "awaiting decision"? It has been approximately a week now.

Paper will be accepted 2022-03-28

Is this out of line? May I ask if the review process is normally this slow?

nopiont0 2022-03-05

There were only two reviewers, and the questions were also very pertinent. However, we have been awaiting a decision for 8 months. We sent four reminder letters during this time, but the responses were always about the severe impact of the epidemic on our work efficiency, and asking for patience in waiting.

先生的科学 2022-03-02

My submission has been under review for 7 months already, sent on 2021.07.26, and there is still no news at the moment.
On 2022.6.22, it was finally accepted.

Paper will be accepted 2022-03-01

Excuse me, how many reviewers are there? Why are they so slow? Sigh.