接accept 2022-09-23

The second review will take about one month.

Yes2022 2022-09-23

Congratulations! May I ask how long it will take for the second trial to have a result?

masssss 2022-09-15

Hello, may I ask if there are major changes when you submit an article twice? Do you need to explain to the editor when submitting for the second time? Or is it sufficient to submit it as a new article directly?

laplace 2022-09-14

A theoretical computational work, submitted for over 3 months, has finally been accepted.
6.2 Submitted.
6.3 Under review.
7.27 Received reviewer comments from 3 reviewers. Not many issues, but quite challenging. The editor rejected the submission for a resubmission.
8.14 Revised.
9.13 Received second round of reviewer comments. Reviewers agreed to accept, but the editor raised a few formatting issues.
9.14 Revised and accepted on the same day, online.
Overall, the editor was very fast, but some reviewers were a bit slow. The first round of review took 8 weeks, which was really frustrating. I am very happy to have it accepted. I work at a small primary school ranked 400+. I am not willing to give up scientific research. I hope everyone can persist in their research ideals, as efforts will always yield results!

绝对零度one 2022-09-13

Hello, did you check the status of the article through the corresponding author's email?

last one 2022-09-13

It has been 10 days since submission, and it is still in the "with editor" status. Have any friends recently encountered a similar situation?

冰咖啡加半糖 2022-09-08

Submitted on August 10th.
Received reviewer comments on August 25th, with minor revisions suggested.
Returned revised manuscript on August 30th.
Accepted on August 31st.
Receiving reviewer comments on my birthday, the best birthday gift ever!
Hope everyone can publish their work in their desired journals. :)

yyyymmm 2022-09-02

I have referred to a lot of experts' information before, and now I want to share my experience for everyone's reference.

Submitted on 5.21.
Returned on 6.30 (two minor revisions and one rejection, edited and resubmitted upon editor's request), I am very grateful for the opportunity given by the editor.

Resubmitted on 8.27 (made extensive revisions and added more data to convince the reviewer who rejected the manuscript).

Accepted on 9.2 (I didn't expect it to be so fast, as I have seen others waiting a long time for the second review).

I am very happy to have been accepted. I have been working on this research for a long time and made numerous revisions. Finally, I wish every researcher good results.

Fang ever 2022-09-02

Submitted on July 26th
Received reviewer comments on August 24th
Returned revised manuscript on September 1st
Accepted on September 2nd
Hope everyone can publish their work in their desired journal.

Yes2022 2022-08-31

Is it always this long for the first trial now?

atomcai 2022-08-29

March 28th submission
Under review on the same day
May 23rd, first round of reviews with 1 important comment and 2 highly important comments. Editor provided minor bibliographic suggestions (MBS) and gave 21 days for revision.
Supplemental density functional theory (DFT) calculations were added on June 25th and a 49-page response was provided.
Under review again on June 27th.
August 14th, received 2 highly important comments (20%) and 1 very important comment (5%).
Online publication on August 16th.

接accept 2022-08-28

Still no news yet... Are you also in the second review?

Yes2022 2022-08-27

Have you got any news?

Yes2022 2022-08-27

May I ask which month did you submit your application? I haven't received any updates for more than a month since the end of July.

鱼鱼鱼鱼鱼yu 2022-08-24

First trial takes 3 weeks, with 2 minor revisions. Allow 3 weeks for modification, and once the revised suggestions are returned, proceed with acceptance directly.

接accept 2022-08-19

It seems that recently the feedback on manuscript reviews has been very slow, and I don't know the reason.

接accept 2022-08-17

7.8 Submission
7.21 First review result: rejected and resubmitted (3 reviewers, 2 positive and 1 negative)
8.3 Resubmission
Until now, there is no news. I hope the reviewers can give me a chance. Doing research is not easy for anyone.

yin_zheng 2022-07-22

It has been nearly ten days since I submitted, and there is no news. Looking forward to it.

xuhuilin 2022-07-21

Pure theoretical calculations, regarding the traditional direction of chemical bonding, can be quite challenging.
Submitted on July 1st, 2022.
Reviewed by two referees for minor revisions on July 15th, 2022.
Revised on July 19th, 2022.
Accepted online on July 20th, 2022.
Overall, it went relatively smoothly.

moumou south 2022-07-20

Analytical chemistry is so difficult.

zym314@ 2022-07-19

Is it so fast to submit for review now?

咪咕的朋友们 2022-07-12

Editorial recommendation to submit to a journal with stronger professional focus.

LPGogo2717 2022-07-06

4.6. Submit
4.8. Submit for review
4.20. First round of revisions, two reviewers, one highly important, one important, editor requests revised submission
6.11. Revise
6.13. Submit for review
7.1. Second round returned, both reviewers satisfied, plus editorial department raised some formatting issues
7.4. Revise
7.5. Accepted
Efficiency is fast, worth a try.

BXC 2022-07-05

2022.4.25 Submission, review within three days
5.22 One very important, one important, not many issues, rejected by the editor and asked to resubmit
6.7 Resubmitted with revisions
6.30 Two very important, minor revisions
7.3 Revised
7.5 Accepted

LPGogo2717 2022-06-29

Hello, may I ask if you have the results for your paper?
I'm also in the second round of review, and it has already exceeded the first round's timeline, still under review. I'm getting anxious.

LPGogo2717 2022-06-29

Hello, may I ask if you have any results for your paper?
I am also in the second review, it has already exceeded the time for the first review and it is still under review. I am very anxious.

jiayougdk 2022-06-28

Hello, may I ask if you have accepted it?

wstcyyyy 2022-06-26

2022.5.12 Submission;
2022.5.18 Under review.
It has been 45 days since the submission and 39 days since the review started, but there is still no news. I don't know what happened.
Hope it will be accepted!

JCG 2022-06-25

2022.5.9 Submission;
2022.5.27 Received the first round of reviews. One reviewer is considered very important (top 5%) and suggested minor revisions, while another reviewer is highly important (top 20%) and suggested major revisions. They raised 15 questions, but the most challenging ones are 5-6. The editor provided 21 days for revisions;
2022.6.8 Submitted the revised manuscript along with a 7000-word, 20-page response letter.
2022.6.27 Accepted for publication.

moumou south 2022-06-23

The first submission was rejected the following day. The second submission was reviewed on the same day. May the dreams of researchers all over the world come true.