Dr.girl 2022-06-11

Hello, it seems that the journal website has recently been upgraded. Previously, I could check the status of submitted papers by accessing the submission system, but now I can't. Do you know where I can view the status of my papers?

yang shan 2022-05-23

I submitted my manuscript on August 23, 2021, and it was assigned to an editor for three months. However, as of May 23, 2022, which is nine months later, I still haven't received any news. I have sent multiple emails to the editor expressing my urgent concern, but all I received were official replies. I have only one feeling, my patience is wearing thin.

liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 2022-05-18

Do you know when we can search for it on WOS after it goes online, bro?

小杨冲冲冲 2022-05-06

The submission was made on October 29, 2021. Two months later, an inquiry about the progress was made to the editor, and the reply received was that a decision would be made within six weeks. However, subsequent submissions require at least seven months for the peer review process. On February 7, 2022, a minor revision decision was received, with 30 comments provided. However, most of them were small edits. After submitting on March 5, it was accepted on March 8. Two weeks later, it underwent proofreading, and in mid-April, it was published online.

linger9 2022-04-18

Have you submitted it for review now?

liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 2022-04-14

It's done. The minor revision was given on April 13th, and the rework will be done on April 14th. The next step is to update the acceptance notification. The journal is relatively slow, and after communicating with the editor, it was found that they receive a large number of submissions every day, and the quality is good, but they need to be reminded.

逃跑计划 2022-04-11

However, it has always been in the "Editor Assignment Pending" status, and when I send an email to this address " <em@editorialmanager.com>", the email is always rejected. I would like to ask for your advice on this matter.

胜次 2022-04-06

After major revisions, do I need to return it to the reviewer?

liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 2022-04-04

9 reviewers, with nearly a hundred comments of varying sizes, spent a month making revisions. The person was almost exhausted from all the changes.

liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 2022-04-04

Not yet, it has been almost 20 days since I submitted the major revision, but I haven't received any results yet. I'm getting anxious. I just emailed the editor and they said I will receive the results in a week. Hopefully, they will accept it.

胜次 2022-04-04

Brother, are there still reviewers for the major revision?

胜次 2022-04-04

Does the major revision need to be returned to the reviewer?

胜次 2022-04-04

Has the result come out, bro?

胜次 2022-04-04

Brother, has the result come out?

胜次 2022-04-03

Has the result come out now?

liiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii 2022-03-25

The results of the major revisions of the manuscript have not been obtained yet, and the details of the submission will be updated later.

kickwy 2022-03-24

Has your present been reviewed?

kickwy 2022-03-24

Submitted on February 17th, it has been a month already, but it has not been reviewed yet. I am anxious.

胜次 2022-03-22

Hey bro, is this journal any good?

雨泽 2022-02-18

From submission to acceptance, it took less than four months for me to receive my first SCI paper as a graduate student. I'm so happy! Here is a breakdown of the timeline:

2021.11.1: submitted
2021.12.1: editor assignment pending
2021.12.21: editor assignment pending; sent a reminder for the second time after almost two months; reviewers were assigned
2021.12.23: under review
2022.1.8: reviews completed; the status remained the same for a few days, but the dates were updated
2022.1.20: minor revision; received feedback from seven reviewers with over thirty comments; took a month to make revisions, and wrote a 15-page response.
2022.2.16: revision submitted
2022.2.18: accepted

My experience:
The time spent in the "editor assignment pending" status was quite long, typically around two months. So, my fellow researchers don't need to worry if you don't receive reviews after two months; just send a reminder email. Once the reviewers are assigned, the review process is relatively fast, with results usually available within a month.
Also, for minor revisions, there is no need to resubmit to the reviewers; the editor decides whether to accept the revisions. Address the reviewer's comments one by one in your response, and generally, acceptance can be expected within 2-3 days.

litang 2022-01-31

Hello boss, may I ask if the 12 suggestions for repair, major revisions, and after submitting the modified version, will they still be shown to the reviewer?

litang 2022-01-31

Does it mean that the revised version was not sent back to the reviewer? Anxious during the revision process.

litang 2022-01-31

Submitted for over 3 months, under review for over 4 months, returned for major revisions.

努力发SCI的东 2022-01-23

About half a month of proof, brother.

小栋 2022-01-23

May I ask how long it takes for you to do the proofreading after hiring? It has been almost a month since I was hired, and I still haven't received any updates.

格格巫你站住 2022-01-12

Submitted on January 12, 2022, waiting calmly for the outcome.

Nayo 2021-12-17

I am even more miserable than the senior brother upstairs. I have been applying for over three months, but still only got allocated to editing. The emails I sent did not receive any response, and I am at a loss. I am looking forward to your reply.

yang shan 2021-11-16

Hello, boss. It has been nearly 3 months since I submitted my contribution, but it is still in the process of being assigned to an editor. I followed up once in the middle and received a standard official reply, saying that they won't forget about my submission. I'm wondering what should I do in this situation? Looking forward to your reply, feeling anxious.

yang shan 2021-11-16

Hello, boss. It's been almost 3 months since I submitted my work, but it is still being reviewed by the editors. I have followed up once and received a generic official response saying that they won't forget about my submission. I'm wondering what I should do in this situation. I'm eagerly awaiting your reply and feeling anxious and even on the verge of tears.

xiao~xiong 2021-11-15

Excuse me, it has been half a month since I submitted the major revision and it shows "reviews completed". How long does it usually take to get the results?