生态站门口 2023-02-18

Always with the editor, it seems that this journal's current state will take over a month.

aoming 2023-02-18

May I ask what is your current status?

生态站门口 2023-02-18

11 days is just a small matter. I used to login and check once a day, then once a week, and now I just glance at it once every two weeks. It really refreshed my understanding.

aoming 2023-02-17

It has been 11 days, still editing.

科研dddddog 2023-02-17

I am too, I have been submitting for more than half a month, and I am still "with editor." What exactly is going on?

生态站门口 2023-02-17

What happened to this journal? There has been no news from the editor since "with editor". Previously, I used to log in and check every day, but now I only log in once a week. How long do I have to wait?

梦番地 2023-02-17

What was the result for the original poster?

Jay_ME 2023-02-16

2.9 submitted to journal
2.9 with editor
2.10 with editor
2.16 under review

科研dddddog 2023-02-14

It has been almost a week already, why did it become slower?

Doctor.T 2023-02-10

2023.2.8 under review translates to "February 8, 2023, under review."

edgar61 2023-02-09

2022.9.18 submitted to the journal
2022.10.13 under review
2023.1.27 under review
2023.1.29 under review
2023.1.30 under review
This speed is incredible.

不知道啊啊 2023-02-09

On the 12th day with the editor, why has this journal become so slow?

生态站门口 2023-02-09

Always with the editor, it seems to be settled there. Has anyone experienced any changes?

Doctor.T 2023-02-07

Have you submitted it for review?

Doctor.T 2023-02-07

It has been 16 days since the submission, and there has been no movement yet.

Doctor.T 2023-02-07

2023.1.23 submitted to the journal
2023.1.24 with editor
2023.1.26 with editor

Translated:

Submitted to the journal on January 23, 2023
With editor on January 24, 2023
With editor on January 26, 2023

隔壁小刘 2023-02-06

After being rejected by EST, the paper was submitted to JHM on November 19, 2022. It took one week for the review process. The first-round comments were received on December 19, 2022, with six reviewers providing feedback. Five of them suggested major revisions, while one seemed to reject the paper. The editor gave a 20-day window for revisions. An extension was requested until February 9, 2023. On February 5th, a response was received, and now waiting for the result. Not sure how fast the second-round review will be. Hoping for a positive outcome. This is my first small top paper in life.

不知道啊啊 2023-02-06

It's my ninth day already, why is it so slow? I don't understand.

David zhou 2023-02-04

I really can't imagine a materials science journal even accepting articles on microbial genome sequencing.

David zhou 2023-02-04

My roommate wrote a soil microbiome sequencing article for agricultural studies. It got rejected by several top microbiology journals with high impact factors, claiming there were serious design flaws and therefore not suitable for publication. Well, guess what? It got accepted by JHM after two months of submission.

暮雨倾晨 2023-02-03

It's been almost a week for me.

溢满哀伤之尽 2023-02-03

2022.11.23 submitted
2022.11.26 with editor
2022.11.27 under review
2022.12.17 Required reviews completed
2023.1.6 revision submitted
2023.1.6 under review
2023.1.15 Required reviews completed
2023.1.15 accepted

In English:

2022.11.23 submitted
2022.11.26 with editor
2022.11.27 under review
2022.12.17 Required reviews completed
2023.1.6 revision submitted
2023.1.6 under review
2023.1.15 Required reviews completed
2023.1.15 accepted

AQ1 2023-02-02

What should I do if I can't find the reviewer after submitting for review?

123chemis 2023-02-02

Just give it a little thought and you'll realize how absurd it is that there are only 13 teachers in the Environmental College of Tsinghua University. Additionally, I checked the official website of JHM and found that there are already 30 articles as of February 2, 2023, with Tsinghua University as the unit (of course, this data is not accurate because they may not be the primary authors). It turns out that even Tsinghua University has teachers who don't do proper research.

Tiny98 2023-02-01

Feb 1, 2023 with editor

Tiny98 2023-02-01

Jan 31, 2023 submitted to the journal.

晨风与暮光 2023-01-28

2022.11.06 submitted to the journal
2022.11.08 with editor
2022.11.13 under review
2022.12.04 major revision
2022.12.26 revision submitted
2023.01.14 accepted

Translation:
2022.11.06 submitted to the journal
2022.11.08 with editor
2022.11.13 under review
2022.12.04 major revision
2022.12.26 revision submitted
2023.01.14 accepted

hhhhyy 2023-01-28

DIP generally refers to a transfer.

菌的秘密 2023-01-27

Hello, is there a "decision in process" status after RRC?

菌的秘密 2023-01-27

Is there a "decision in process" status after RRC?