灌水老先生 2023-05-26

This situation may result in rejection. I have experienced this before and was rejected. Our teachers here also mentioned that this journal has been slow this year. I submitted my manuscript on February 17th, it was reviewed on March 15th, and the feedback was returned on May 3rd. I received minor revisions on May 26th. The review process took one month, the peer review process took nearly two months, and the decision took another month. Adding the four months from last year, it has been almost a year.

科研新手要加油 2023-05-26

My 5.8 with editor, 5.18 decision in process. Still decision in process today. What does this mean? They are taking so long to consider. Either send it for review or reject it. The efficiency of JHM has decreased now.

Dsivan 2023-05-25

I started on May 16th and the status of the editor has changed 3 times.

楠楠~ 2023-05-24

It takes one month to submit for review.

wmomo 2023-05-24

How long has everyone been waiting for review? With Editor since May 14th until now; the dates have changed twice.

上辈子是数学题 2023-05-23

May I ask what is the final result?

灌水老先生 2023-05-21

Another week has passed.............still no news.

Sugar‘s 2023-05-19

4.29 submit, 5.3 with editor, 5.7 status updated but still with editor, later there was no progress, and directly rejected after 20 days, which makes me wonder why it took so long? Some journals are more straightforward, they give a verdict in just one week.

褶皱臂尾轮虫 2023-05-18

I would like to ask, has anyone had the situation where they received the comments from the reviewers, made revisions accordingly, but the experts still did not agree to review it again? In such cases, does the editor make the final decision or does it get sent for review again? This is the first time I have encountered this, please enlighten me.

科研新手要加油 2023-05-17

This is the correct procedure, don't worry, just wait for the final result.

禾岩 2023-05-17

Can you see which editor it is?

JoJo 2023-05-16

Also, it is May 5th with the editor until now.

上辈子是数学题 2023-05-15

May I ask what the outcome will be, OP?

禾岩 2023-05-15

How long will it take to submit it now? Why does it seem like there has been no progress after "with editor"?

灌水老先生 2023-05-14

Still no change, I want to remind the editor, I have been holding it in my hands for a month and still waiting for review...

左海刻苦的蚕豆 2023-05-13

What's been going on recently? Why is it so slow? It has been over half a month and it's still in the hands of the editor. Is there anyone else who's experiencing the same thing as me?

lmy1013 2023-05-12

4.11 submit to the journal - Submitted to the journal on April 11th.
4.12 with editor - Under the editor's consideration on April 12th.
4.13 under review - Currently being reviewed on April 13th.
5.4 moderate revise - Requires moderate revisions on May 4th.
5.8 re-submit - Resubmitted on May 8th.
5.9 under review - Currently being reviewed again on May 9th.
5.10 accept - Accepted on May 10th.

楠楠~ 2023-05-11

4.20-Present, no news yet, with Editor

禾岩 2023-05-11

Does your mood change every day?

zzz456 2023-05-08

Still editing in hand, the status has not changed since April 24th. Is there anyone else in the same situation as me?

搬砖的科研人@CFD 2023-05-07

Posted on May 2nd, until now with editor.

搬砖的科研人@CFD 2023-05-07

May 2, 2023 8:49:23:917AM - Submitted to Journal
May 3, 2023 4:00:38:117AM - With Editor
May 3, 2023 2:27:52:197PM - With Editor

zzz456 2023-05-06

Have you achieved any results yet? It has been two weeks and it's still in the hands of the editor.

灌水老先生 2023-05-04

Shaily Mahendra, PhD

zzz456 2023-05-04

Posted on April 21, and still with the editor until April 23. Wishing you good results!

禾岩 2023-05-04

Which editor can inform me?

禾岩 2023-05-04

May I ask which editor?

朗格缪尔-归去来兮 2023-05-03

2.26 JHM submission; 3.26 received reviewers' comments, two reviewers, one mentioned issues with innovation, one had very positive feedback, final outcome was major revision; 4.12 received reviewers' comments; 4.30 made minor revisions and submitted on the same day; 5.3 article accepted. The article is related to materials and environment. Before submitting to JHM, it was rejected by Matter and GC. JHM's speed is quite fast, and the journal editor is very helpful.

化城小胡椒 2023-05-03

Decision in process, waiting for the results.

化城小胡椒 2023-05-03

April 1st - With Editor
April 4th - Under Review
April 25th - Reviews Completed
May 2nd - Decisions in Process
I heard that "Decisions in Process" status means rejection
May 3rd - Rejected