小螺号 2023-06-09

What does "Decision in Process" mean after "required reviews complete"?

追逐阳光的向日葵 2023-06-09

How long does this condition last?

民科来灌水了 2023-06-09

Difficult to collapse.
The biggest uncertainty factor is the efficiency of the reviewers.

dfbsjfwkbf 2023-06-08

Submitted to journal on 2023/6/8.
With editor within only 5 hours.
Good luck to the person above, please send for review!

小螺号 2023-06-07

It has been over a week since my Required Reviews were completed, but there is still no news.

Zinnia 2023-06-06

There is no need to choose an editor for this. It took over a week, almost two weeks to submit for review.

Zinnia 2023-06-06

May 26th: Consider after substantial revision (the email states that the two reviewers have reached an agreement and there is no need to find a third reviewer, as they suggest accepting the paper after minor revisions).
June 5th: Modified back, with editor.

Niudawu 2023-06-06

Have you selected an editor? How long does it take to submit for review?

Zinnia 2023-06-06

Update:
May 26: Consider after substantial revision (The email states that both reviewers have agreed and there is no need to find a third reviewer. They suggest accepting the paper after minor revisions).
June 5: Changed back, with editor.

Zinnia 2023-06-06

Xiao Xiu, just returned from repairs yesterday (2023.6.5). I hope to receive messages and updates in the near future. Haha.

liu tao tao 2023-06-05

Not necessarily, it could be a decision before submission for review.

追逐阳光的向日葵 2023-06-04

May I ask how is the current status? Has it been submitted for review?

追逐阳光的向日葵 2023-06-04

2023.6.2 submitted to journal
2023.6.4 Decision in Process
Expected rejection is not far away.

琢磨 2023-06-03

Does it mean immediate rejection if the editor takes a month?

琢磨 2023-06-03

Can you please tell me if it's under review? I also have "with editor" since the 20th.

二师兄想吃唐僧 2023-06-02

On May 24th, the review comments were returned. There were four reviewers in total, with three minor revisions and a total of around ten suggestions. The fourth reviewer acknowledged the significance of the paper but questioned the logicality of the methodology and provided suggestions on data processing methods, totaling 12 suggestions. Among them, three were duplicates, so it can be considered as nine suggestions. The editor provided 20 days for revisions. Good luck to myself.

鞋子特大号 2023-05-29

How is the progress, OP?

liu tao tao 2023-05-29

Did the original poster win?

Martina111 2023-05-25

OP, what is the status after "decision in process"? My status is also the same after "with editor".

Zinnia 2023-05-22

The first submission was made on March 31st. There were two status updates in between (with editor and then under review). On May 22nd, the status was updated to required reviews complete. To be continued... looking forward to good news about the article.

谭米线 2023-05-22

5.8 submitted means that something was turned in or sent in on the date of 5.8.

5.19 with editor means that something was received or acknowledged by an editor on the date of 5.19.

生菜1998 2023-05-19

It has been one month since the second trial.

二师兄想吃唐僧 2023-05-19

A total of 6 reviewers were chosen, and 4 reviewers accepted.
On May 13th, one review comment was revised.
On May 17th, another review comment was revised.
On May 19th, Required reviews complete.
The outcome is unknown, anxiously waiting, mainly because it takes a little long in the hands of the editor.

Maria1020 2023-05-18

Dear friend upstairs, after the review, a link-tracking service will be sent to the submission email. By clicking on it, you will be able to see the number of reviewers and the progress of the review.

爱祖国 2023-05-12

Excuse me, OP, does this journal submission have any requirements for line spacing and font? I couldn't find it in the author's instructions.

liu tao tao 2023-05-10

I have been with it for one month, and it is currently under review.

rhrqyt 2023-05-10

How is your situation right now? It is indeed too slow.

rhrqyt 2023-05-10

Is it still with the editor now?

liu tao tao 2023-05-08

How to know how many reviewers there are and where to see them?

liu tao tao 2023-05-08

I am currently in the process of reviewing, and it has been around a month in the hands of the editor. Currently, it has been under review for 8 days, which is a bit slow.