ssjay 2023-06-23

I will analyze my experience. I applied on September 13th, 2022 and received a rejection notification on January 27th, 2023, taking more than 4 and a half months. The speed of this is really... disgustingly slow.

ZWZ1 2023-06-23

6.22 under review. The speed is quite fast, hoping for a positive outcome.

ers 2023-06-22

March 29th submitted
June 3rd revise
June 17th revised
June 17th with editor
June 17th under review
June 21st accept
The speed is quite fast, and the editor is also very good.

Noah 2023-06-22

Submitted on February 18th.
Major revision submitted on May 12th. A total of 15 reviewers were assigned during this period, and 5 of them completed the review.
Resubmitted on May 25th.
Minor revision on June 15th.
Resubmitted on June 16th.
Accepted on June 21st.
Overall, the process was much slower compared to last year.

24March 2023-06-22

You are so fast, but the status of my submission that I made on the 15th still hasn't changed.

xiaopang123 2023-06-21

Is it under review?

24March 2023-06-21

How is the original poster doing now?

yzh2019 2023-06-20

2023-6-19 sub
2023-6-19 with editor

Yang Bojin 2023-06-20

I have been waiting for twenty days, and I sent a reminder to the email that I received an automated response from Esweir, but it seems like it didn't work.

杰哥 2023-06-20

06-14-2023 submit - Submitted on 06-14-2023
06-14-2023 With Editor-至今 - With Editor until now

yhtcswc 2023-06-19

Stupid journal, stupid editor, so slow it's driving me crazy.

sssssnz 2023-06-19

05-04 Submitted to journal
05-11 With editor
05-13 With editor
06-01 Sent an email reminder...
06-19 Under Review

民科来灌水了 2023-06-19

Do not rush within a month.

Coisini 2023-06-19

Who should I send an email to during the "sub to journal" period to request an update? It has been twenty days and I can't bear it any longer...

Coisini 2023-06-19

It has been 20 days and it's still the first subject... I'm speechless.

民科来灌水了 2023-06-19

It has been one week since the second review comments came back, and it is still under review........ Anxious, either the editor is on vacation or there are too many manuscripts......

陈园润 2023-06-19

Mine too, it has been more than two and a half months since it was sent back for repair.

ers 2023-06-17

I would like to consult the host regarding whether it is necessary to modify the "submitted kml files will be published with your online article on sciencedirect" and the "interactive plot viewer" mentioned in the email. Thank you.

ers 2023-06-17

I would like to consult with the original poster. Do we need to make changes to the mention of "submitted kml files will be published with your online article on sciencedirect" and "interactive plot viewer" in the modification email sent by the editor? Thank you.

ers 2023-06-17

I want to consult with the original poster, are the modifications necessary for the "Submitted KML files will be published with your online article on ScienceDirect" and "Interactive Plot Viewer" mentioned in the email? Thank you.

Good Luck~ 2023-06-17

Wishing everyone to be published.

沐光而行 2023-06-15

Congratulations to the host, I'll share some good luck, hahaha! I hope I can have the same luck next time I participate!

小damn 2023-06-15

The journal editing efficiency is quite high, hoping the journal will continue to improve!

03-30-2023
Submitted to Journal;

03-31-2023
With Editor;

04-23-2023
Under Review;

05-10-2023
Under Review;

05-16-2023
Under Review;

05-18-2023
Revise;

06-08-2023
With Editor;

06-09-2023
Under Review;

06-14-2023
Required Reviews Completed;

06-14-2023
Accept.

ZWZ1 2023-06-14

6.8 submit - Submit.
6.9 sent back to another - Sent back to another.
6.13 submit - Submit.
6.14 with editor - With editor.

小螺号 2023-06-14

Impressive, three reviewers provided feedback for revisions, but the editor rejected them. It took a week to make a decision, and the initial process was also particularly slow.

SAS 2023-06-13

Record it
2023-6-08 submitted
2023-6-09 with editor
2023-6-13 with editor
(Hoping for approval)

sssssnz 2023-06-12

05-04 Submitted to journal
05-11 With editor
05-13 With editor

Translation:
05-04 Submitted to journal
05-11 With editor
05-13 With editor

Dorothea 2023-06-10

03-05 submitted to journal
04-06 under review
04-30 required reviews completed
05-02 consider after substantial revision
05-22 submitted to journal
05-25 under review
05-29 required reviews completed
06-09 accepted

Submitted for initial review took a month, the waiting time was quite long, but the rest of the process was very fast. The editors and reviewers were all very good!

ZNG 2023-06-10

The final editing decision determines whether you will revise, accept, or reject. There is a high probability of revision during the first review, and there is hope for acceptance without rejection. (Comprehensive evaluation is randomly selected)

鞋子特大号 2023-06-10

Is there any progress? How long does it take from "required reviews completed" to "decision in process"?