zhhhui 2023-07-21

So slow, it was submitted on July 10th, and it has been 11 days since then. It is still submitted to the journal, I don't understand why it's taking so long.

天火 2023-07-21

Most DIPs within 20 days are usually transfers, there's no need to ask again.

第五叶 2023-07-21

7.17 submitted to journal
7.19 with editor
7.20 under review

琢磨 2023-07-20

Does it mean rejection when the status of "reviews required completed" changes to "decision in process" for this journal?

Evy 2023-07-20

I also submitted to the journal 7.11, and it is still under review.

家豪 2023-07-20

No need, it's probably just slower recently. I waited for a week before it changed to "with editor".

走心1 2023-07-20

Posted on July 11th, it is still "Submitted to Journal" until now. I would like to ask if all co-authors need to confirm before proceeding to the next stage, or is it a matter handled by the editorial department and not related to us?

花落不沾衣 2023-07-20

Is it necessary to remind?

zhhhui 2023-07-20

Why is there such a large difference in the time interval with the editor? Does it have anything to do with the research direction?

花落不沾衣 2023-07-20

This speed is really fast.

墨斗鱼 2023-07-19

7.19 It has been half a month already, one of the reviewers completed the review within a week after acceptance, while the other one has not finished the review for almost half a month...

li-ethan 2023-07-18

7.17 submit
7.18 with editor
7.27 with editor
8.1 under review Invited 10 reviewers, 1 accepted the review
8.6 under review Added 7 more reviewers

Mr Black 2023-07-18

7.8 submission, currently still submitted to journal.

哈哈哈1992 2023-07-18

The current speed is indeed very slow.

阿克瑟普特 2023-07-17

Could you tell me how long did the dip last after the second review? Did you directly receive it?

花落不沾衣 2023-07-17

Posted on July 13th, it is currently still submitted to the journal.

Ge5ge 2023-07-16

My first review was completed in two weeks, but the status of the second review has remained under review without any changes. It feels a bit unreasonable.

在读研究僧 2023-07-16

Two reviewers are reviewing the minor revisions. One has completed it, but we are still waiting for the other one. It has been a month now and we still haven't received any updates.

在读研究僧 2023-07-16

Same question, it has been a month since the second revision of my minor repair and there is still no news. It shows that two reviewers have been invited for the second revision, and one of them has completed the review. However, the other one is also too slow. It was just a minor repair, and it has already been a month.

兽兽1 2023-07-16

7.10 submitted and no movement until now

Ge5ge 2023-07-15

Excuse me, fellow researcher above, how long did your second review process take?

Yuan Liu east 2023-07-14

Similar to you, submitted on 7.6 and with editor on 7.12.

家豪 2023-07-14

7.12 with editor, I hope it can pass and go for review.

飘云 2023-07-14

I would like to ask two questions:
(1) This journal only has "Consider after revision," "Consider after substantial revision," and "Accept after revision," without the traditional "Major/Minor revision." Which status of this journal corresponds to minor revision?
(2) After the second round of revisions, will this journal still send the manuscript for a third round of external review?

Ge5ge 2023-07-12

Did you submit the manuscript to a new reviewer for the second review? How long did the review process take?

24March 2023-07-12

After 6.22 with the editor, the status has remained unchanged until now. If it doesn't change again next week, I plan to write a letter to urge them.

Ge5ge 2023-07-12

Does this journal generally assign new reviewers for the second review? How long does the second review process usually take?

哈哈哈1992 2023-07-11

Yes, it has been motionless all along.

家豪 2023-07-11

Just asking everyone, has it been slow recently?
After 7.5 sub, no movement at all, urgent
Seeking good luck

Update
7.12 with editor
7.27 under review (waited for two weeks, didn't rush)
Sent to over 10 reviewers that day, only 3 accepted for review after a few days
Accept good luck

家豪 2023-07-11

7.5sub remains motionless.