遥感人 2021-08-15

What's going on with this journal recently? I submitted it on August 10th, and on August 15th it still says "Submitted to Journal." Surprisingly, it hasn't been assigned a number yet.

独孤求爱007 2021-08-04

The following text has been translated into English:

Mar 22, 2021 Submitted to journal
Mar 22, 2021 With Editor
Mar 26, 2021 Under Review
May 05, 2021 Required Reviews Completed
May 25, 2021 Decision in Process
May 30, 2021 Consider after substantial revision N1
July 06, 2021 With Editor
July 06, 2021 Under Review
July 12, 2021 Under Review
July 29, 2021 Decision in Process
August 1, 2021 Accept after Revision N1
August 2, 2021 With Editor
August 3, 2021 Decision in Process
August 4, 2021 Accept

x-x-x 2021-07-29

Add: The three reviewers will directly accept the revised manuscript without encountering any special circumstances (such as multiple reviewers or sending the manuscript for a second review). Wishing the journal success and continuous improvement.

x-x-x 2021-07-29

01.20 submitted to journal - The document was sent to the journal on January 20th.
01.31 with editor - The document is being reviewed by the editor as of January 31st.
02.04 under review - The document is currently being assessed by reviewers as of February 4th.
04.03 consider after sustainably revised - The document will be reconsidered for publication after sustainable revisions have been made by the author(s) on April 3rd.
05.17 resubmit - The revised document was resubmitted on May 17th.
05.22 under review - The revised document is currently being reviewed again as of May 22nd.
06.13 accept - The document has been accepted for publication on June 13th.

xinyanmaio 2021-07-12

20.12.16 submitted
20.12.17 with editor
20.12.19 under review
21.3.4 under review
21.4.4 consider after substantially revise
21.5.9 resubmitted
21.5.17 under review
21.6.6 Required reviews completed
21.6.24 Required reviews completed
21.7.11 accept
Five reviewers, 1 major revision, 2 minor revisions, 2 acceptances. The issues were quite complicated, and it took about 40 days for the revisions to be sent back. After resubmission, it was accepted without further review. Overall, the process was slow and anxious, but fortunately, the outcome was good.

Ph.Der 2021-07-05

21.3.29 submitted
21.4.2 with editor
21.4.19 under review
21.5.4 under review
21.6.2 consider after substantially revise
21.6.22 resubmitted & under review
21.6.29 accept
Two reviewers, one major revision and one minor revision. The issues were relatively simple, but as a precaution, a confirmatory experiment was added, which caused a delay of 20 days for revisions. After a brief review, the paper was accepted directly. Overall, the speed was decent, assuming the paper could be submitted for review.

ZXTSHU 2021-07-02

March 12th submission
April 20th major revision
May 20th minor revision
May 29th under review
June 29th accepted directly

智者怎么说 2021-06-30

20210205, submit
20210427, consider after revise
20210608, with editor
20210618, under review
20210627, accept
After a total of four and a half months, it finally resulted in a positive outcome. Thank you to the editor and reviewers.
Wishing the journal continued success. Wishing all the experts and scholars early acceptance.

啊呀呀呀呀 2021-06-29

How many days did this status of "required reviews completed" last?

啊呀呀呀呀 2021-06-29

How is it now? Has it been repaired?

小小怪 2021-06-22

2021.06.02 under review - Under review on June 2, 2021
2021.06.22 Required Reviews Completed - Required reviews completed on June 22, 2021
不知道结果如何，祝自己好运555555 - I don't know the result, wish myself good luck 555555

guo 2021-06-15

I would like to ask if anyone has received the review result "consider after revision"? It seems like everyone has either received major revision or minor revision.

RENLI 2021-06-13

Hello, may I ask where you downloaded the template? Thank you for your help.

jia 2021-06-13

Before submitting, I read many comments saying it was slow, but with the idea of giving it a try, I didn't expect it to be fast. Many times, it's better to take others' opinions as a reference. The official journal stated that the first comments would be given within an average of 4 weeks, which is only for reference.

2021.3.30 - Submitted
2021.3.31 - Under review
2021.4.16 - Required reviews completed
2021.4.26 - Major revision
2021.6.7 - Submitted revision
2021.6.8 - Under review
2021.6.11 - Accepted

For the revision, we were given 40 days, but due to our own reasons, we delayed it until the 39th day for submission. Otherwise, the process might have been faster.

Professor Zhou 2021-06-11

My submission to the journal has been with the editor for almost 20 days now, after taking 10 days to reach them. It is advisable to be cautious when submitting to this journal, and if the results are excellent, it is recommended to consider transferring it elsewhere.

环境工程 2021-06-10

This journal is too slow. It has been several days since I submitted, but it is still showing as "submitted to journal". Has the editor even logged into the system to check? I see that they publish a good number of articles every year, so why is it taking so long? Fortunately, I don't urgently need this article, but I hope the subsequent process will be faster. When I submitted to other journals in the past, they usually started processing on the same day or the next day. It's frustrating to have to wait so long in this case.

kust 2021-06-03

4.11 with editor
4.12 under review
4.24 consider after revise (2 reviewers)
5.25 submit revised manuscript
5.27 accept after revise
5.29 submit revised manuscript (with editor)
6.2 accept

兔子 2021-06-03

One month with the editor, I sent an email as a reminder to the editor, but half a day later I received a rejection notice. It's really disappointing how quickly they rejected it as soon as I followed up.

兔子 2021-06-01

5.6 submission
6.1 still with editor
Waiting, hoping for smooth progress.

田青 2021-05-30

Slow, it is really slow. The submission from March 21st took a whole month with the editor; on April 24th, it became "Under Review," and the status of the manuscript was changed on May 17th, but it is still "Under Review" to this day. The reviewers and the editor have worked hard, hoping for an ideal outcome! The article of my senior in the neighboring RCR took 8 months to review!

Ph.Der 2021-05-25

3.29 submitted - Submitted on March 29th
4.2 with editor - With editor on April 2nd
3.19 under review - Under review since March 19th
5.4 under review - Under review since May 4th

Ph.Der 2021-05-25

Update again, until May 25th, it is still in "Under review" status. It's really anxious waiting.

小小怪 2021-05-25

First time posting, I wrote the wrong submission period.

小小怪 2021-05-25

2021.4.26 Submit to the journal;
2021.5.11 with editor;
2021.5.24 Still with editor after update, does anyone know what's going on?

独孤求爱007 2021-05-19

The required reviews were completed on May 5th, but we still haven't received the results. Is this journal taking so long to make a decision?

asistent 2021-05-16

It has been 15 days, and it is still in the "with endotr" state.

asistent 2021-05-16

It has been 15 days, and it is still in the "with enditor" state.

asistent 2021-05-16

It has been 15 days, still with the editor.

asistent 2021-05-16

Submitted for 15 days, still in "with editor" status.

爱浓醇 2021-05-16

About half a month after submission, it is still "With Editor." After emailing to inquire about the editor, it was instantly rejected. The AE (Associate Editor) is Paolo Roccaro, and it feels like being deceived and irresponsibly handled.