kkljjkoll 2023-02-14

How many days with the editor?

hope321 2023-02-13

I just wrote a reminder letter, sigh, I don't think the outcome will be too good...

冲冲冲1231978 2023-02-12

February 1st, submitted to journal
February 1st, with editor
February 11th, under review (track link)

kkljjkoll 2023-02-11

This environmental management is so slow recently. It takes half a month for a submission, and it's still "with editor".

seven.蚊子 2023-02-11

The translation of the text is: "Still in decision process, but the date has changed to February 9. What does this mean?"

hope321 2023-02-10

Generally, this means...

Bring 2023-02-10

Now it has been with the editor. When I submitted, the manuscript number was already over a thousand, close to two thousand. Last year, there were less than 3000 submissions. According to this rough calculation, it seems that the acceptance rate is only around ten percent.

seven.蚊子 2023-02-10

The status remains unchanged, but the duration of the status has changed. What's the situation?

tfz 2023-02-10

Submitted to journal on January 27th, and still submitted to journal on February 10th. Why is it taking so long?

四篇起步 2023-02-09

20 days still with editor

冲冲冲1231978 2023-02-09

Isn't it still said that the 8th is for reviewing with the editor? Why did it dip on the 6th?

seven.蚊子 2023-02-09

2.6 has become "decision in process" until today, it should be rejected as it has not been reviewed.

seven.蚊子 2023-02-09

On February 6th, it changed to "decision in process". Does it mean I didn't get it?

chris800 2023-02-08

How difficult is this journal?

Bring 2023-02-08

Ah, the content I have researched feels a bit niche and interdisciplinary. It seems like it doesn't align well with the scope of this journal either. I just don't know where else it would be more suitable to submit. I feel like it's most likely going to be rejected. I hope they can provide a result soon. I really lack confidence and I regret submitting it... Sigh.

seven.蚊子 2023-02-08

Still no change, how can it take the editor this long?

yzzzl 2023-02-08

I made a submission on January 18th, and the next day I had a meeting with the editor. As of now, it is still the same. What does it mean that there has been a change in the date midway? Did they switch editors?

chris800 2023-02-08

I submitted my manuscript on 2.1 and have been waiting for a week. It is still in the "submitted to journal" status. Does the "under review" stage usually take less time than the "with editor" stage?

Bring 2023-02-08

I also applied on the same day as you. Worried about it taking too long, I'll just wait here for a while and check the progress...

chris800 2023-02-07

If you really can't wait, then push a little, otherwise it might be delayed for a few months, who knows.

chris800 2023-02-07

Is this the journal editor working on the final draft?

hope321 2023-02-06

Last submission took 2.5 months to complete. This time I submitted on January 19th, and it is still in the "submitted to journal" status. It's quite urgent for the paper. I don't know what to do.

seven.蚊子 2023-02-05

1.10submit - Submit at 1.10
1.15with editor - With editor at 1.15
现在还在with editor - Still with editor now
好慢啊 - So slow

乘风破浪的ZBC 2023-02-04

My first article was accepted on the 29th of the twelfth lunar month, and I am happy about it. The research topic is artificial wetlands. I feel that this journal is quite efficient, as it took exactly two months from submission to acceptance. Below is the timeline:

November 18, 2022: Submitted to the journal
November 19, 2022: With editor
November 25, 2022: Under review (3 reviewers)
December 19, 2022: Required Reviews Complete
December 21, 2022: Under review (probably added another reviewer)
December 26, 2022: Consider After Substantial Revision
January 8, 2023: With editor (submitted revised manuscript)
January 8, 2023: Under review
January 18, 2023: Accept after Revision (one formatting error)
January 18, 2023: With editor (submitted revised manuscript)
January 20, 2023: Accept

Thank you to the editor and reviewers! I hope the journal will continue to improve, and I hope everyone's articles will have good results!

David_Lv 2023-02-04

This is too terrifying, but my system shows that I have sent it to 2+ reviewers and two reviewers have accepted it.

easyhrui 2023-02-03

2022.11.16 Submission
2022.11.20 Under Review
2022.12.08 Revise (Consider after revision)
2022.12.21 Submission
2022.12.22 With editor
2022.12.28 Under Review
2023.01.06 Required Reviews Completed
2023.01.07 Revise (Accept after revision)
2023.01.26 Submission
2023.01.26 Building PDF
2023.01.27 With editor
2023.02.02 Accept

zfhoo 2023-02-02

I submitted it before the new year, and it was reviewed by eight reviewers in the first round.

David_Lv 2023-01-31

I also don't know why the first reviewer was so quick. After receiving the "under review" email, I opened the interface of the tracking system, and when I went back for the second time, the first reviewer had already completed the review. It's quite terrifying.

yzzzl 2023-01-29

You're too fast.

canbaobao 2023-01-29

You are so fast.