klgkk 2022-07-25

7.19 submitted
7.19 with editor
7.24 with editor (change of date)
There is more bad luck than good luck, hoping for good fortune.

chemfang 2022-07-22

"required reviews completed" means that the external review comments have been received. Generally, after receiving two comments, it will show as "required reviews completed". Then, it depends on the editor's decision whether to wait for more comments or make a decision directly.

chemfang 2022-07-22

The editor sent it to 5 reviewers, but only 3 reviewers' opinions came back. The other 2 reviewers may have declined to review it.

喃喃学语 2022-07-21

Hello, I would like to ask about the Title field in the registration of the journal website. It always shows "You did not enter the required number of Keywords." Can you please help me check how you filled out your personal information when you registered? I have tried many times but it still doesn't work.

Mr Chen 2022-07-20

Did you edit the reply?

喃喃学语 2022-07-19

May I ask what field you are in?

凡尘. 2022-07-15

Hello, does "5 reviewers returned 3 opinions" mean that there are only three review comments in total?

Mr Chen 2022-07-15

Hello, may I ask what does "required reviews completed" mean?

终点站 2022-07-15

2022-03-24 submit to journal
2022-03-24 With editor
2022-03-25 Under review
2022-04-23 Under review (change in date)
2022-05-12 Under review (change in date)
2022-05-14 Required Reviews Completed
2022-05-23 Required Reviews Completed (change in date)
2022-05-23 major revision (given 45 days, 3 out of 5 reviewers provided comments, 2 minor revisions and 1 major revision)
2022-07-02 Revision
2022-07-05 Under review
2022-07-14 Accepted

The Impact Factor is also about to exceed 10, hoping for continued success! The submission volume is a bit large, but the editorial processing speed is fast, it's just that the reviewers are a bit slow, but the editor usually handles it promptly once received.

OMR 2022-07-13

How are things going now? Is there a positive outcome after the decision is being processed?

gmy123456 2022-07-13

6.15 submitted
6.16 with editor
6.18 under review
6.25 minor revision
7.3 submitted revision
7.4 with editor
7.10 accept

凡尘. 2022-07-12

7.10 Submitted to journal
7.10 With editor
7.11 Under review
The review process is quite fast because many students who have successfully submitted their manuscripts do not come here to express their opinions. Therefore, many of the papers we see are from students who have been with the editor for a long time. My senior has had two papers accepted, and both were quite fast, so everyone should not panic.

阿庆科研废柴 2022-07-08

Submitted on May 7, 2022, reviewed and completed on June 10, 2022. Required reviews were completed between June 10 and June 26, 2022. Revision requested on June 29, 2022, and accepted on July 5, 2022. Overall speed is acceptable, except for the required review time which was too long.

yy 2022-07-03

I have been with the editor for half a month already and there has been no change in status during this period.

慢性流浪 2022-07-03

"Under Review (7.2)"

慢性流浪 2022-07-02

I want to ask, brother, have you ever changed the date during the process with the editor?

慢性流浪 2022-07-02

Submitted to the journal on June 21st, and on the same day with the editor.
It has been 11 days since it was with the editor (July 2nd) ?
The dates in between have not changed.
Is this a prelude to rejection?

l666666666 2022-06-29

Original Text: 楼主，状态是从editorial manager里查看的吗？

English Translation: OP, is the status viewed from the editorial manager?

XYH 2022-06-28

How is the original poster's post now? My situation is the same as yours.

l666666666 2022-06-28

2022.6.25 submitted to journal
2022.6.25 with editor
I would like to ask if the references marked as "Not Validated" in the Reference Checking Results need to be modified and re-uploaded? Where should they be uploaded from?

Kkkkkkkkk77 2022-06-26

Comrades, it seems that the decision is still in process. They should reject me soon if I'm not mistaken. Editors have been holding onto it for too long, and it's not a good sign.

guhai 2022-06-25

5.16 submitted to journal
5.17 with editor
5.27 under review
6.10 required review completed
6.25 still required review completed

Kkkkkkkkk77 2022-06-23

6.16 submit
Submitted on June 16th.

第二天6.17 凌晨变with editor
On the next day, June 17th, it changed to "with editor" in the early morning.

6.22 又变一次with editor？？？
On June 22nd, it changed to "with editor" again? What does this mean? Can you please reject it more promptly?

Kkkkkkkkk77 2022-06-23

I am too...

Bi8bolan 2022-06-22

Apr 13, 2022 Submmited to journal
Apr 15, 2022 Under Review
Apr 18, 2022 Under Review
Apr 27, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
May 4, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
May 9, 2022 Major Revision
Jun 1, 2022 With Editor
Jun 3, 2022 Under Review
Jun 3, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Jun 4, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Jun 5, 2022 Minor Revision
Jun 6, 2022 With Editor
Jun 22, 2022 Accept

Zhipeng_Yang 2022-06-20

Almost, mine has also been for many days. May I ask how you are now, OP?

Zhipeng_Yang 2022-06-20

What is the current result for the original poster?

Zhipeng_Yang 2022-06-20

How are you doing now, OP?

沪上晓风75 2022-06-18

The minor revisions were sent back two weeks ago, but it's been slow with the editor lately in this journal.

咩小力 2022-06-17

Decision in Process, ultimately rejected or transferred? Mine has also been with the editor for almost a week, not sent for review yet, and now it's in the Decision in Process stage, which is tragic. From reading other people's comments, if a paper is sent for review, it could be under review the next day or the day after. However, if it is with the editor, chances are slim as they are too busy to handle unreviewed manuscripts at once.