liangcha 2023-03-10

Too slow, still the same, it took 20 days to show the successful submission. There are so many mediocre journals, why did I impulsively submit to this one? It would be better to withdraw immediately and submit to other journals.

lixiaoru 2023-03-09

It has been more than 20 days, still with editor.

学习不哭 2023-03-08

Submission: 2022.11.14
External review: 2022.12.4
Major revision: 2023.1.15
Revised: 2023.2.22 (Due to the Spring Festival, the deadline was extended by 10 days)
External review: 2023.2.26
Today is 2023.3.8, and it is still in the external review status.
The journal's submission process is taking quite a long time, and I hope to receive a response soon.

Gingergigi 2023-03-04

It's hard to say, maybe they are faster than me.

pumpkin@ 2023-03-03

Just started with editor3 days, it seems there is still more waiting.

Gingergigi 2023-03-03

No, it has been over a month, I'm wondering whether I should send an email to ask about your situation.

pumpkin@ 2023-03-02

Has your situation changed?

pumpkin@ 2023-03-02

Has your current progress status changed?

Gingergigi 2023-02-25

Yes, it's been exactly 15 days. I suspect it was planned this way. It has been a month since I submitted it, but I have no idea what's going on.

pumpkin@ 2023-02-24

Suddenly I realized how slow it is. Before submitting, I checked the latest literature and found that the time from submission to acceptance was quite short. Now, I feel a bit slow after submitting myself. It has been a week and it is still in the "submit" status. Does it take 15 days for the status to change for you?

Gingergigi 2023-02-24

Does anyone know what's the situation with submitting the manuscript for 15 days and with the editor for 10 days?

echoeseddy 2023-02-15

Hello, does your submission process have a "with editor" option?

你说我是谁 2023-02-07

I would like to ask if there were any reviewers who rejected your article during the major revision process?

搬砖劳工 2023-01-29

When I invested this year, I also maintained this state for nearly 40 days, and it took more than 5 months in total.

McSun 2023-01-19

Hello, mine is also a manuscript submitted for a long time, almost half a month. I wanted to ask you if your status has changed now? I'm not sure if this is normal.

小生繁华 2023-01-14

Can I ask if your manuscript is directly submitted as "manuscript submitted" and then goes through major revision? It has been half a month for me and it is still "manuscript submitted".

DM. 2023-01-11

The review process was relatively slow, taking four months. Due to my limited skills, the manuscript went through one major revision and one minor revision. The reviewers were very professional, and I am grateful to the editor-in-chief.
15 Sep 2022 manuscript submitted
13 Oct 2022 major revision
10 Nov 2022 revised manuscript submitted
10 Dec 2022 minor revision
23 Dec 2022 revised manuscript submitted
11 Jan 2023 accept

DM. 2023-01-05

They have a holiday on Christmas.

leeaccept 2023-01-05

It has been nearly 20 days since submission, and it still says "Manuscript Submitted." Is there anyone else like me? Should I send an email to inquire?

limz 2022-12-07

Posted on May 2nd, finally accepted on August 1st, with about a month of modifications in between.

limz 2022-12-07

Submitted an article on the synthesis of electrical materials, received major revision comments after about two months. Added experiments and made revisions according to the reviewer's requirements. The revised manuscript was accepted within a week of submission.

暴走的酸橙 2022-11-22

27th September 2022 - Manuscript submitted
30th September 2022 - Under editor's review
14th October 2022 - Under review
16th November 2022 - Minor revision
21st November 2022 - Revised manuscript submitted
21st November 2022 - Accepted

向日葵611 2022-11-18

First time submitting in English, feels like the journal is very formal and the review process is also considered normal speed. It starts off a bit slow during the initial review process, with two external reviewers taking two months for major revisions. However, after the revisions were made, it was quickly accepted.

1 July 2022: Manuscript submitted
15 July 2022: Under editor review
18 July 2022: Under peer review
28 Sep 2022: Major revision
21 Oct 2022: Revised manuscript submitted
29 Oct 2022: Accepted
09 Nov 2022: Request final material from author
15 Nov 2022: Online proofing
17 Nov 2022: Published

Hope this can provide some reference for those who haven't submitted yet~

DM. 2022-11-14

Congratulations, your progress is impressive. Especially being able to accept it so quickly after a major overhaul.

会飞的实验室 2022-11-14

01 Sep 2022 Manuscript submitted
05 Sep 2022 With editor
15 Sep 2022 Under review
16 Oct 2022 Major revision
27 Oct 2022 Revised manuscript submitted
11 Nov 2022 Under review
14 Nov 2022 Accept

会飞的实验室 2022-11-12

I submitted it on the 27th, and it is still in the external review status today. It was actually sent for external review on approximately the 30th. I made a mistake with the timing.

DM. 2022-11-11

I submitted the major revision on November 10th, let's see who among us will get the second result first.

会飞的实验室 2022-11-11

01 Sep 2022 manuscript submitted
05 Sep 2022 with editor
15 Sep 2022 under review
16 Oct 2022 major revision
27 Oct 2022 revised manuscript submitted
11 Nov 2022 under review

Translation:
01 Sep 2022 - The manuscript was submitted.
05 Sep 2022 - It is with the editor.
15 Sep 2022 - It is currently under review.
16 Oct 2022 - A major revision is scheduled.
27 Oct 2022 - The revised manuscript has been submitted.
11 Nov 2022 - It is under review.

HITcui 2022-11-08

10.27 manuscript submitted, until now there is no response from the editor. The efficiency is extremely slow, and I highly recommend against submitting to them as it will waste time.

DM. 2022-11-02

Hello, after the major revision, should it be sent to the same reviewer for another review? What should I do if there are some contents that cannot be changed during the revision? Seeking help online, I have already added you as a friend.