巽为风 2022-11-26

It has been 10 days since my second review, and it is still in the "under review" status.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-26

It's hard to say, it could take a few days if it's fast, but it could also take up to a month if it's slow, depending on whether or not it needs to be reviewed.

巽为风 2022-11-26

10.1 submitted to the journal
10.9 with editor + under review
10.14 under review
11.1 major revision
11.11 revised submission + with editor
11.16 under review

寒江孤雁 2022-11-26

Submitted on November 18th, and still not with the editor by November 25th? Is it still the same now, do we have to wait for another half month? Has your status changed?

巽为风 2022-11-26

Oh no, you're quite fast.

巽为风 2022-11-26

How long is the deadline for requesting a second trial, and how long does it usually take to obtain the results?

巽为风 2022-11-26

I'm frustrated. On November 1st, I submitted for major revisions. Both reviewers gave overall positive evaluations and praised my work. They both suggested accepting the modifications. The editor also suggested modifying the abstract and updating the introduction before acceptance. On November 10th, I received a direct response from the editor, but it has been ten days since then and it's still under review. It's too slow.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-23

November 23rd: accept

打工的人 2022-11-23

Rejected, rejected. Submitted for review on August 6th, with the editor in late August. Under review until October 16th. Required reviews completed on November 3rd. Decision in process on November 22nd. Rejected on November 23rd. Goodbye. Made me wait for over three months.

打工的人 2022-11-23

Is it over if the status changes directly from "required review completed" to "decision in process"?

打工的人 2022-11-23

On November 22nd, the status changed from RRC to "decision in process". The decision was made without receiving any review comments, and I have a strong feeling that it will be rejected. I have been waiting for three months in vain, and I am completely frustrated.

Dr.tan 2022-11-22

Submitted on 11.21, the current status is still "submit to journal".

Cliff-y 2022-11-21

I also only have one reviewer's feedback, and I don't know what to do yet.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-20

Haha, hopefully, I hope you all win too!

学术混子t t t 2022-11-20

I am also the one who has submitted the second review of major revision on the 7th, but until today, there is still no result.

Cliff-y 2022-11-19

The major renovation that my classmate gave before has also been approved, so there should be no problem.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-19

One first review with two reviewers, one rejection, and one minor revision; now the second review is about to be released, I wonder if the likelihood of this situation being accepted is high or not.

Wangwant 2022-11-18

The editor of this journal sent an email with a website link, which can be clicked to view. I haven't found such a link for other journals either.

Cliff-y 2022-11-17

How can I see the situation of the reviewers? My paper is under review, but I haven't received the link for communication.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-16

August 8th: submitted to journal
August 11th: with editor
August 16th: with editor
August 25th: under review
October 3rd: major revision
October 25th: submitted to journal & with editor
October 30th: with editor
November 2nd: under review
November 8th: under review.

打工的人 2022-11-16

All the review comments have come back on November 3rd. The status has changed from "under review" to "required reviews completed". It's already November 16th today, and it's still "required reviews completed". My mindset is about to collapse. Why is the editor so slow? Is it for revisions or rejection? Please give a result soon. Why am I still waiting? It's really painful.

Wangwant 2022-11-15

9.12 submit
10.14 under review
11.13 under review
So slow, feels like it will never end
11.17 Still haven't found a reviewer
Reviews completed: 0
Review invitations accepted: 0
Review invitations sent: 2+
11.18 Review invitations accepted: 1
12.09 Review invitations accepted: 1
Reviews completed: 0
2023.2.10 Review invitations accepted: 1
Reviews completed: 0
No review comments for five months, withdrew the submission, but the editor said I can switch to another editor, and then
One week, 2.16 Reviews completed: 2; Required Reviews Complete

Cliff-y 2022-11-15

Then let's switch to experimental simulation, it's more reliable.

Cliff-y 2022-11-15

What does it mean, what is abnormal review status?

queershanren 2022-11-13

This situation is simply not being submitted for review.

老龙 2022-11-13

11.11 avec éditeur translates to "11.11 with editor" in English.

小武4 2022-11-12

Brother, what was your final decision?

小武4 2022-11-12

Abnormal review status

头给你锤歪 2022-11-11

9.12 - Submitted
9.20 - With editor
10.02 - Under review
10.24 - Major revision
11.04 - Revision submitted
11.05 - With editor
11.10 - Accepted

江江江1007 2022-11-11

Fudan University's Wu Renbing is exceptionally fast in handling manuscripts.