巽为风 2022-12-05

12.5 Accept

741wu 2022-12-05

8.11 Submitted to Journal
8.21 With Editor
8.22 Decision in Process
8.26 Reject, saying the language of the article is not authentic, choose to resubmit after modifying the language

9.11 Submitted to Journal
9.17 With Editor
9.18 Under Review
10.20 Major Revision, one month, three reviewers, 19 comments

11.17 Submitted Revised Manuscript
11.23 Required Reviewers Completed
11.24 Under review
12.5 Accept

First article, thanks to Thiagarajan Gnanasekaran, Ph.D., Editor, sending good luck, and wishing everyone a smooth acceptance.

小菜青虫 2022-12-03

Great, bring on the good luck!!!

小菜青虫 2022-12-03

So fast, welcome good luck!!!

我和我的瓜 2022-12-03

A second-tier journal, with 12 reviewers, has 8 pages of comments and more than 60 opinions. People are exhausted.

小菜青虫 2022-12-03

This speed is too damaging, isn't it?

西工大小博士 2022-12-02

How long does the general review process take?

西工大小博士 2022-12-02

2022.11.11 submit
2022.11.16 with editor
2022.11.30 with editor
2022.12.1 under review
2022.12.19 major revision by four reviewers, 30 comments
2023.1.2 with editor
2023.1.5 with editor
2023.1.8 under review
2023.1.9 under review
2023.1.18 Required Reviews Completed
2023.1.19 under review
2023.1.29 accept

巽为风 2022-12-02

Is this still the first review for approval?

青平 2022-12-01

9.06 Submission
9.13 With editor
11.30 Under review

小菜青虫 2022-12-01

Did you also receive pending submission transfer offers from the journal you previously submitted to? Were you given several options to directly click the Submit button?

myuany 2022-12-01

Finally hit the jackpot. The editor and reviewers probably couldn't bear to read this submitted article for a year.

myuany 2022-12-01

"lupu in Romania"

caseone 2022-11-30

Congratulations XD, this speed is impressive. I hope mine can also be received smoothly, hahaha!

明月清风 2022-11-30

2022.9.17 Submit initial draft
2022.11.12 Minor revisions
2022.11.25 Submit revised draft
2022.11.29 Acceptance
First article, in commemoration of this.

牟维鹏 2022-11-30

10.24 Major revision.
11.21 Rework.
11.30 Accept.

巽为风 2022-11-29

We will return around the same time, it has been almost two weeks on my end as well.

巽为风 2022-11-29

How to see that the reviewer has not accepted the manuscript for review.

青平 2022-11-29

It's a coincidence, in early September, I submitted (a project) and a week later, (I started working) with the editor, and it has been ongoing until now.

Dgsh 2022-11-29

It has been almost two weeks since the return for repair, and there is still one reviewer who hasn't accepted the review. Good luck with that.

flora 2022-11-29

Submit the advice of other journal editors to transfer here, submitted on 10.7.
Under review as of 10.14.
Major revision on 10.21, with 2 reviewers and 11 comments.
Resubmitted on 11.14.
With editor and under review as of 11.18.
RRc on 11.20.
Accepted on 11.25.
The first article, just for commemoration.

巽为风 2022-11-28

Look at the editor, which editor are you?

myuany 2022-11-28

Today is November 28th, and it's just one week away from the one-year anniversary of the submission. Currently, it's the second review of the RRC. I'm nervous.

寒江孤雁 2022-11-28

I voted on the 18th, and still haven't received the confirmation from the editor. How about your situation?

caseone 2022-11-28

Brother, you are really fast! Catch good luck and hopefully accept it!

caseone 2022-11-28

2022.11.08 Submitted to Journal
2022.11.15 With Editor
2022.11.25 Under Review
2011.11.28 Under Review

Translation:
2022.11.08 Submitted to Journal
2022.11.15 With Editor
2022.11.25 Under Review
2011.11.28 Under Review

巽为风 2022-11-27

Generally, we send 4 of them.

ZHAO J C 2022-11-27

It took me more than 20 days to receive the result of the second review. Generally, as long as you take the major revisions seriously and respond well to most of the comments, there is a high probability of success. Don't worry. I didn't receive the one you mentioned when submitting. Did you select any specific option in the submission system?

mingming铭铭 2022-11-26

Dear, did you receive any request to provide interactive plots when you submitted your contribution? Is it mandatory to have them or optional?

SFAACEDVG 2022-11-26

How many reviewers does this journal usually have for a comprehensive review?