October001 2023-04-12

Congratulations! Good luck rubbing off on you~~~

little-stone 2023-04-11

My major revision has also been submitted, but there is no news. I asked the official website of Elsevier and it seems that the editors have not sent any new invitations for reviewers. I'll just have to wait.

wm 2023-04-10

Until now, I have been with the editor. How long did it take for the experts to submit?

嘴巴选手小天 2023-04-10

Initial Date Submitted: Apr 03, 2023
Apr 03, 2023: With Editor, still in the editor's hands.

yyyyyyzer 2023-04-04

I was quite anxious at noon, but I received the email I was waiting for in the afternoon. Wishing good luck and smooth reception!

yyyyyyzer 2023-04-04

2023.1.5 Submission
2023.1.6 Sent for external review
2023.1.27 Major revision (4 reviewers, 29 comments, all very professional, clearly knowledgeable in my field)
2023.3.2 Major revision submitted for external review
2023.3.20 Minor revision (4 reviewers agree to accept, editor provides 4 comments including formatting, polishing, etc.)
2023.4.2 Minor revision submitted
2023.4.4 Accepted

yyyyyyzer 2023-04-04

I am also eager to get this graduation paper, but there has been no result yet. I am so anxious.

something 2023-04-04

Got the results, one reviewer thinks the performance is too poor (much worse than the previous senior). The other two think it needs major revisions... Haven't encountered a good editor - Transfer.

something 2023-04-03

1.20 submit
1.23 with editor
2.16 under review invited 2+
2.22 under review (find another reviewer) 2+
3.7 under review (Reviewer 1 accepted review)
3.8 under review (Reviewer 2+ accepted review)
3.9 under review (Reviewer 2+ accepted review)
Mar 24, 2023 Required Reviews Completed (Reviews completed: 2)
Mar 26, 2023 Required Reviews Completed (Reviews completed: 2+)
Mar 31, 2023 Decision in Process
The editor is really dragging this out, the experience is really poor...

leo 2023-04-02

Within two weeks, just wait. If you're lucky, it could be within a week. Plus, the one you chose may not necessarily be it.

甜甜honey 2023-04-01

How long after being "with editor" did you go "under review"? I also chose this editor, but it has been a week and it hasn't been sent for review yet.

甜甜honey 2023-04-01

Excuse me, which editor did you choose? My appointment on the 25th is with the editor, on the 4th of January is it also with the editor?

7788uu 2023-03-31

2023-03-31 bajo revisión.

leo 2023-03-31

11 Dec 2022 Submitted
5 Jan 2023 Major revision
25 Jan 2023 Revised
4 Feb 2023 Submitted for review
15 Feb 2023 Minor revision
Revised on the same day
And then came the long wait...
2 Mar 2023 Resubmitted for review
18 Mar 2023 Required reviews complete
30 Mar 2023 Accepted
The whole process took 3 and a half months. Dr. Li Jin, the editor, was a bit slow in handling the manuscript, but the RRC usually provided responses within two weeks. The reviewers were very rigorous and even pointed out minor issues. After two rounds of revisions, the quality of the article greatly improved. Thanks to JAC!

leo 2023-03-31

Look, the editing process generally takes within two weeks.

October001 2023-03-29

May I ask how long it takes for RRC to have results?

YITIANYITIAN 2023-03-28

Jac still values the workload. He also provided a second review, which was quite meticulous and serious.

kong123 2023-03-28

2023.3.5 Renovation, renovation return
2023.3.7 Under review
2023.3.28 An reviewer has been invited, but they have not accepted the review yet.
What should I do in this situation? Thank you.

冠军终归马德里 2023-03-28

Feb 24, 2023 submitted
Feb 27, 2023 with editor
Mar 05, 2023 Under Review
Mar 07, 2023 Under Review
After about ten days, one reviewer provided feedback. However, it has been over twenty days without any new reviewers agreeing to review. It feels like the review process will not be completed within two months, and I will definitely not be able to graduate on time. It seems like there is no such thing as a fifteen-day milestone.

leo 2023-03-27

It seems that fifteen days is a crucial point. The minor revisions have been completed for almost two weeks now, constantly going back and forth. The editor is incredibly patient, which only makes the author more anxious~~~

7788uu 2023-03-27

2023-03-26 Con Editor

neko 2023-03-23

Has anyone experienced the phenomenon of queuing for PDF builds? Is it because there are too many manuscripts recently? The corresponding author also did not receive any emails or anything.

Yovela 2023-03-17

It has been nine days and it has not been reviewed yet... Worried about graduation, how long did everyone take to get it reviewed?

小城市 2023-03-17

I don't do the old profession, but I'm crazy about collecting articles catalyzed by junk batteries. This journal has a bad reputation.

我是你的解忧酒 2023-03-16

10.31 submitted
12.7 major
1.3 resubmitted
1.5 With editor
1.8 Under review - One reviewer agrees to the second review
1.17 Another reviewer agrees to the second review
2.7 One review completed
2.12 required reviews completed - Another review completed
2.13 Major revision - One of the reviewers asked some very basic questions, possibly due to their lack of expertise
2.13 Go back for technical review
2.15 Under review with the editor
2.21 Reminder for submission
3.2 Reminder for submission
3.13 Reminder for submission - These reminders were mainly because one of the reviewers declined the review invitation
3.14 RRC
3.14 major - This reviewer has a poor level of expertise, does not understand the article or consult any references or literature, and just asks random questions, even requesting to cite their own articles. Perhaps this is due to their lack of professionalism. The reviewer's comment is: "Unfortunately, I don't believe that..."
3.15 resubmitted - Received the decision for major revision at midnight and was very angry. Worked overnight and returned it by 5 am.
3.15 with Editor
3.15 Accept

dfjlsnklf 2023-03-16

The first essay has been accepted, and now I am submitting a literature review. I am very anxious because the literature review lacks innovation. What should I do?

TianyuZhang 2023-03-13

2023-03-13 Xiaoxiu

hahahaha999 2023-03-13

2022/07/26 Submitted to AFM
2022/09/13 Rejected by AFM (2 minor revisions, 2 rejections)
2022/09/30 Submitted to Inorganic Chemistry
2022/10/03 Rejected by Inorganic Chemistry
2022/10/05 Submitted to CEJ
2022/10/09 Rejected by CEJ
2022/10/18 Submitted to ACS Sustainable Engineering
2022/10/24 Rejected by ACS Sustainable Engineering
2022/10/25 Submitted to Alloy and Compounds
2022/12/21 2 minor revisions
2023/01/03 Revised and returned
2023/01/24 Accepted by Alloy and Compounds

injumory 2023-03-13

2023.3.7投 - Invest on March 7, 2023.
2023.3.11建议转投 - Suggest to transfer investment on March 11, 2023.
拒绝转投 - Refuse to transfer investment.

hahahaha999 2023-03-12

Already been hired.